The Gotham Hotel

The front desk staff were super welcoming and friendly. The rooms were clean. The Juliette balcony was great. Very conveniently located if travelling by train/tube, and in walking distance to Times Square and other popular sight-seeing areas.

Everything was perfect. Exceeded our expectations. Location is great, hotel is very comfortable and offers very qualitative amenities. We had a room with a balcony on the street side : fantastic view and no noise when windows closed.

The room was clean and spacious, the mini bar in the room was great, the breakfast from the restaurant in the hotel was excellent. The location of the hotel was great, it was close to everything. The staff was excellent, informative and accommodated my requests.

Good location

I was on the 10th floor and at least from my room the walls were paper thin. I could hear every time someone was walking, closed a door or knocked on a door, and the water pipes were so loud whenever anyone was flushing a toilet from any floor it seemed I could hear the entire flush traveling through the pipes. When someone was taking a shower it sounded like the water was going to leak through the ceiling. So many other random noises it turned into a game trying to figure out what they were. Room was cleaned daily which was nice and the mini bar pricess were reasonable plus they gave us a $40 mini bar credit upon arrival. Parking is directly across the street which was convenient and with the hotel discount was only $40/day. Mattress, pillows, and sheets were middle of the line at best. You would never use the balcony unless you had to smoke, or you enjoy the view of a dirty alley. Bathroom again nothing special, toilet paper was cheap one-ply and towels were mid. Bring earplugs if you are planning on staying here, but you won't see me here again.