House in Shelter Island, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Nestled along the tranquil shoreline of Menantic Creek, Menantic House is a thoughtfully renovated waterfront retreat that captures everything people love about Shelter Island—privacy, expansive water views, exceptional outdoor living, and effortless access to the water.
With 153 feet of private shoreline, a private dock, and generous indoor and outdoor gathering spaces, the home is designed for families and friends looking to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy island life at its own pace.
Launch the provided kayak or stand-up paddleboard directly from your private beach and dock, spend the afternoon exploring the creek, or simply soak in the peaceful atmosphere. From slow mornings with coffee overlooking the water to evenings gathered outdoors, the waterfront is at the heart of the Menantic House experience.
Inside, bright open living spaces are filled with natural light and framed by beautiful water views. The renovated kitchen flows seamlessly into comfortable living and dining areas, creating an inviting space to gather after a day on the water. On cooler evenings, the stone fireplace provides a warm and welcoming place to unwind, while large windows keep the waterfront landscape front and center throughout the home.
Three thoughtfully appointed bedrooms each feature their own ensuite bathroom, offering comfort and privacy for couples, families, or friends traveling together. The spacious primary suite also includes a dedicated workspace, making longer stays and remote work both comfortable and convenient.
Outside, you'll discover the lifestyle that makes Menantic House so special. Spend the afternoon in the heated spa pool, then raise the temperature for a relaxing hot tub experience beneath the stars. Unwind in the cedar sauna after a day on the water, gather around the Solo Stove fire pit, enjoy long dinners under the open sky, or explore Shelter Island by bicycle. The fully fenced backyard offers plenty of space to play a game of cornhole, relax, and take in the peaceful waterfront setting.
Whether you spend your days exploring Shelter Island or never leave the property, Menantic House is designed for effortless waterfront living. Guests can enjoy the island's quiet beaches, scenic nature preserves, and locally loved restaurants, then venture just a short ferry ride to Long Island's celebrated North Fork wineries or the renowned ocean beaches, villages, and dining of the Hamptons. Shelter Island offers the rare opportunity to experience the very best of both destinations while returning each evening to the peace and privacy of your own waterfront retreat.
Whether you're planning a summer week on the water, a long weekend with friends, or a relaxing island escape, Menantic House offers an exceptional blend of comfort, privacy, and memorable waterfront experiences that will draw you back year after year.
STR Permit Number: 2026-V-0024
LTR Permit Number: 2026-L-0099
With 153 feet of private shoreline, a private dock, and generous indoor and outdoor gathering spaces, the home is designed for families and friends looking to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy island life at its own pace.
Launch the provided kayak or stand-up paddleboard directly from your private beach and dock, spend the afternoon exploring the creek, or simply soak in the peaceful atmosphere. From slow mornings with coffee overlooking the water to evenings gathered outdoors, the waterfront is at the heart of the Menantic House experience.
Inside, bright open living spaces are filled with natural light and framed by beautiful water views. The renovated kitchen flows seamlessly into comfortable living and dining areas, creating an inviting space to gather after a day on the water. On cooler evenings, the stone fireplace provides a warm and welcoming place to unwind, while large windows keep the waterfront landscape front and center throughout the home.
Three thoughtfully appointed bedrooms each feature their own ensuite bathroom, offering comfort and privacy for couples, families, or friends traveling together. The spacious primary suite also includes a dedicated workspace, making longer stays and remote work both comfortable and convenient.
Outside, you'll discover the lifestyle that makes Menantic House so special. Spend the afternoon in the heated spa pool, then raise the temperature for a relaxing hot tub experience beneath the stars. Unwind in the cedar sauna after a day on the water, gather around the Solo Stove fire pit, enjoy long dinners under the open sky, or explore Shelter Island by bicycle. The fully fenced backyard offers plenty of space to play a game of cornhole, relax, and take in the peaceful waterfront setting.
Whether you spend your days exploring Shelter Island or never leave the property, Menantic House is designed for effortless waterfront living. Guests can enjoy the island's quiet beaches, scenic nature preserves, and locally loved restaurants, then venture just a short ferry ride to Long Island's celebrated North Fork wineries or the renowned ocean beaches, villages, and dining of the Hamptons. Shelter Island offers the rare opportunity to experience the very best of both destinations while returning each evening to the peace and privacy of your own waterfront retreat.
Whether you're planning a summer week on the water, a long weekend with friends, or a relaxing island escape, Menantic House offers an exceptional blend of comfort, privacy, and memorable waterfront experiences that will draw you back year after year.
STR Permit Number: 2026-V-0024
LTR Permit Number: 2026-L-0099
Amenities at Waterfront Retreat | Spa Pool, Sauna & Dock
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Shelter Island, NY
$$$$
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
