House in Shelter Island, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Our Shelter Island beach house is within a 5-minute walk to beautiful Wades Beach. A heated salt water pool is located within an enclosed patio and has an automatic safety cover which can only be accessed by tenant with a key (lock is separate from the pool), providing peace of mind to anyone with small children or guests.
Enjoy close proximity to one of Shelter Island's beautiful beaches and relax in the pastoral yard while grilling your dinner.
It offers guests a peaceful and quiet spot for an unforgettable vacation only 100 miles from New York City. Our beach house is situated on more than one acre on South Midway Road, about 1 mile from Shelter Island Heights, with easy access to the surrounding restaurants, shops and Mashomack Nature Preserve. Our house is just a short walk from the house to the sand and the water.
The interior features 4 bedrooms (2 master bedrooms with private bathrooms) and 3 full bathrooms in a sunny two-story-style layout (dual zone Central Air equipped). Beautiful Vintage doors and classic appointments adorn the open floor plan with beamed ceilings, cast iron tub, country kitchen and stained glass windows. The master bedroom has a veranda to enjoy.
The backyard has a wraparound porch with furniture, sunning deck and gas grill perfect for a barbecue. The large backyard is ideal for summer evening entertaining. Comfortably furnished, our house provides a relaxed atmosphere in wonderful surroundings. It is close to local restaurants, boat yard, ferries and all amenities that Shelter Island offers.
Please note: I do not allow pets of any kind.
House features:
18 x 36 heated salt water pool
4 large bedrooms (1 king, 1 queen, 1 full and 2 twin)
3 full bathrooms
Sun room
Living room
Private upstairs deck
Large backyard (1.25 acre)
Free Highspeed Wireless Internet Network
Central A/C & Heat throughout
Ceiling fans throughout
Two televisions
Dishwasher
Microwave & Oven
Gas Grill
Laundry room with washing machine & dryer
Enjoy close proximity to one of Shelter Island's beautiful beaches and relax in the pastoral yard while grilling your dinner.
It offers guests a peaceful and quiet spot for an unforgettable vacation only 100 miles from New York City. Our beach house is situated on more than one acre on South Midway Road, about 1 mile from Shelter Island Heights, with easy access to the surrounding restaurants, shops and Mashomack Nature Preserve. Our house is just a short walk from the house to the sand and the water.
The interior features 4 bedrooms (2 master bedrooms with private bathrooms) and 3 full bathrooms in a sunny two-story-style layout (dual zone Central Air equipped). Beautiful Vintage doors and classic appointments adorn the open floor plan with beamed ceilings, cast iron tub, country kitchen and stained glass windows. The master bedroom has a veranda to enjoy.
The backyard has a wraparound porch with furniture, sunning deck and gas grill perfect for a barbecue. The large backyard is ideal for summer evening entertaining. Comfortably furnished, our house provides a relaxed atmosphere in wonderful surroundings. It is close to local restaurants, boat yard, ferries and all amenities that Shelter Island offers.
Please note: I do not allow pets of any kind.
House features:
18 x 36 heated salt water pool
4 large bedrooms (1 king, 1 queen, 1 full and 2 twin)
3 full bathrooms
Sun room
Living room
Private upstairs deck
Large backyard (1.25 acre)
Free Highspeed Wireless Internet Network
Central A/C & Heat throughout
Ceiling fans throughout
Two televisions
Dishwasher
Microwave & Oven
Gas Grill
Laundry room with washing machine & dryer
Amenities at Contemporary Home with heated pool and waterviews on Shelter Island
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
Perfect!
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2020
A very nice place for a family vacation. Everything went well and the manager was easy at hand if needed however no problems really occurred
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2019
The house was lovely, even better than the pictures. It was so light and spacious. The family room/sun room is enviable, with pretty grounds around it and a view to the road which is not very close to the house. Everything is wonderfully maintained. The house was immaculate.
Everything was provided, even beach towels and chairs, and pool toys . There was nothing that we needed to bring or get, other than our personal clothing and food we wanted to eat.
The agent was delightful as she knows a lot about Shelter Island. She is also informative, on time and responsive. The owner, Christina, was very prompt about getting back to me with answers to questions both before and after the rental was finalized.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2019
A really well laid out and located property on Shelter Island. Other reviews mention the pictures don't do it justice and I can happily reaffirm that, it's really great both inside and out. Particularly great for kids.
The pool is amazing and somehow managed to convince my 4 year old to learn to swim. Not me, the pool, that's how nice it is.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(12 Ratings)
"Perfect!"
Jamie N.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
