House in Shelter Island, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Fabulous open floor plan features soaring ceilings and a striking stone fireplace, as well as a gourmet fully equipped kitchen for the discerning cook. This 4 bedroom/3.5 bath beautiful home is private, nestled among mature trees and set far back from the road. The backyard is a secluded oasis with heated pool, chaise lounges, and an enormous NEW deck with a large teak dining table and seating for 10, comfortable lounging/seating area, and gas grill. All baths are newly renovated. On the front porch are comfortable rockers and vintage chairs, where you can enjoy your morning coffee or a glass of wine in the evening. Stargaze from your perch on the beautiful new deck outside the master bedroom. The first floor of the house has an expansive layout with open living and dining areas and kitchen with a breakfast bar, Subzero refrigerator and Wolf 6-burner range. A cozy family room, fully equipped with games and TV, leads out to the deck. A guest room (Queen) with ensuite bath completes the first floor. The second floor, includes a loft area (with twin sleeper and queen sleeper) overlooking the living area, a spacious primary (king) bedroom with ensuite bath and private deck as well as two additional bedrooms (one with king, one with twins and trundle) and a full hall bathroom with a new washer/dryer. Congdon's Creek is within walking distance and Wades Beach is just over a mile away.
THE POOL IS NOT OPEN UNTIL LATE MAY AND CLOSES MID-SEPTEMBER UNLESS OTHER ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE FOR AN ADDITIONAL FEE.
PLEASE ALSO KNOW THAT NO PETS OF ANY SIZE ARE ALLOWED AND THAT MINIMUM AGE OF PRIMARY RENTER MUST BE 30.
THE POOL IS NOT OPEN UNTIL LATE MAY AND CLOSES MID-SEPTEMBER UNLESS OTHER ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE FOR AN ADDITIONAL FEE.
PLEASE ALSO KNOW THAT NO PETS OF ANY SIZE ARE ALLOWED AND THAT MINIMUM AGE OF PRIMARY RENTER MUST BE 30.
Amenities at Private oasis with new baths and heated Gunite pool near Wades Beach
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
The house was perfect! It felt like being at a friend’s house.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
What a perfect Air B&B! Everything was easy… all there. Great towels !Only thing missing was an Oyster chuck(opener)Don’t actually know the name ….Thank you again !
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
Amazing stay! The property was exceptionally clean and fully stocked with everything we could possibly need for a week long stay. All kitchen utensils, grilling gear and tons of towels for the pool. We highly appreciated the updated bathrooms. The heated pool and backyard/deck were perfect for the warm summer days. Our kids had so much fun! The home itself is great for a family and had plenty of space and bathrooms. Check in was a breeze and communication was great with the property manager who was available with little delay on answering any questions we had. Everything was within 5-10 mins drive between the grocery store, beaches, cafes and the ferries. Highly recommend this place if you are going to stay at Shelter Island
5 / 10·Sep 2021
This was our second time staying at this property. The owner, Joyce, is a pleasure to work with. She is responsive and very accommodating. Kim, the property manager, is easy to contact and available whenever needed! Kim is a resident of shelter island and has a wealth of information and suggestions for your time on Shelter Island. The home is perfectly kept and has a perfect layout for a family. The home is centrally located, making it easy to get around on the island… a quick drive to the south ferry and within walking distance to Vine Street Cafe. We loved every second of our time spent at this home and are counting down ‘till next summer.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(35 Ratings)
"The house was perfect! It felt like being at a friend’s house. "
Cathy V.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
