House in Shelter Island, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Year round retreat on your own private waterfront estate with a meticulously renovated 1816 cedar shake house. Water views from almost every room! You will enjoy a private 2 acre parcel with a private dock on Shelter Island's beautiful Coecles Harbor. A covered entry porch opens to a delightful living room with fireplace, newly renovated kitchen, dining area, sunporch and deck. There is also a main floor master bedroom suite with spacious marble bath. The second floor features a 2nd master bedroom with ensuite full bath and private waterside balcony deck, plus two additional bedrooms and full bath. Sweeping lawns with sheltering trees lead gracefully to the waterfront dock. This wonderful property is the perfect summer retreat for swimming, fishing and boating enthusiasts. Strong Wi-Fi on both floors. 5G extender.
Keywords: Two acres of beautiful waterfront with fully renovated waterfront house, with marble baths, large french doors facing the harbor, opening to a large deck. Very large yard to water 200 feet of waterfront in yard with dock.
PLEASE NOTE (SEVERE MEDICAL ALLERGY): The owner of this property suffers from life-threatening/severe medical allergies to animal dander and requires a completely allergen-free environment to safely maintain and service the home. Because of this severe health hazard, we cannot safely accommodate any animals, including service animals or emotional support animals. We kindly ask that you take this into consideration before booking.
NOTE: There is no lifeguard on duty at our property. Swimmers swim at their own risk
Keywords: Two acres of beautiful waterfront with fully renovated waterfront house, with marble baths, large french doors facing the harbor, opening to a large deck. Very large yard to water 200 feet of waterfront in yard with dock.
PLEASE NOTE (SEVERE MEDICAL ALLERGY): The owner of this property suffers from life-threatening/severe medical allergies to animal dander and requires a completely allergen-free environment to safely maintain and service the home. Because of this severe health hazard, we cannot safely accommodate any animals, including service animals or emotional support animals. We kindly ask that you take this into consideration before booking.
NOTE: There is no lifeguard on duty at our property. Swimmers swim at their own risk
Amenities at Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests loved the peaceful location, beautiful views, well-equipped kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and responsive hosts. It was a memorable stay with great amenities for a perfect retreat.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
We had a wonderful time at Shelter Island. The ferry ride is easy from New London to Orient Point and then a short 5 minute ferry from Greenport to Shelter Island. If you’re looking for quiet beaches and beautiful views, this is the place. The property is serene with a lovely view of the harbor. It has beautiful bathrooms, cozy furniture to read a book and a great deck to watch boats go by. We were able to go crabbing right off the dock and had enough for a delicious crab corn chowder. We would definitely go back! Thank you for a wonderful vacation!
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2024
Staying on Shelter Island was pure bliss. Our family enjoyed a beautiful summer vacation together on shelter surrounded by beautiful nature, in a lovely house situated on Coecles Harbor. It was our first time on Shelter and we absolutely loved it. The beaches were beautiful, the saturday morning farmers market was great and the low key, relaxed vibe of the island were perfect. Edward the property owner was gracious and accommodating to our every need. We will definitely plan to return.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2024
Relaxing home in a quiet neighborhood providing just the kind of retreat we were looking for. We enjoyed the view of the Coecles Harbor and the chance to read books and catch up with family in a beautiful setting.
5 / 10·Dec 2017
We are old hats at the Home Away game and have stayed in many many homes over the years. Our trip of 4 nights during the Thanksgiving holiday to this lovely Shelter Island property was really amazing. This is property must be ranked as one of the best amongst some pretty tough competitors. Firstly, the owner Edward was absolutely fantastic to work with. He is a consummate professional, responsive, and so communicative, and simply said, so nice. Secondly, the home was exactly as described: clean, serene, functional, historic but cozy, relaxing, and so user-friendly. We spent time walking the grounds, cooking in the kitchen that overlooks the harbor, and sitting by roaring fires while sipping Irish Coffees, what could be better? To top it all off, the house truly feels like a home, not a rarely used second house.
Aside from the great photos and look of the property, part of the reason we wanted to stay at the home was all of the great previously written reviews. After our stay, I am happy to add to that roster and we will plan to surely be back again.
Edward - thank you again for all of the communications leading up to our trip, it was a blast!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(28 Ratings)
Guests loved the peaceful location, beautiful views, well-equipped kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and responsive hosts. It was a memorable stay with great amenities for a perfect retreat.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
