House in Anna Maria Island, FL
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Escape to a North End Waterfront Oasis
Discover the ultimate island retreat at Poinsettia Road, a sprawling estate nestled on an expansive waterfront lot at the prestigious northern tip of Anna Maria Island. Surrounded by lush, natural landscaping, this home offers a private sanctuary where the beauty of the island meets modern comfort.
The Space
Completely renovated in 2015 and 2024, this bright and airy home is designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living.
Spacious Layout: 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a large, open-concept chef’s kitchen.
Island Breeze: French doors in nearly every room open directly to the pool area, inviting the sunshine in.
Modern Comfort: Fully air-conditioned (dual units for total control), high-speed Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs in the living area and both master suites.
Outdoor Living & Amenities
Boater’s Dream: Enjoy effortless access to the AMI Bayside and the open Gulf right from your private boat dock.
Spend your days soaking up the Florida sun or retreating to the nearby sands.
Poolside Paradise: Enjoy a private pool area equipped with lounge chairs, outdoor seating, and a charcoal BBQ.
Al Fresco Dining: A large terrace table with seating for 8—perfect for sunset dinners.
Beach Ready: We provide pool and beach equipment so you can pack light and dive straight into vacation mode.
Prime Location: A short, scenic stroll puts you on the shores of both the pristine Gulf beaches and the tranquil Bimini Bay.
Transparent Pricing
We believe your vacation should be stress-free from the moment you book.
Our Rates: No surprises, no hidden costs—just pure relaxation.
Discover the ultimate island retreat at Poinsettia Road, a sprawling estate nestled on an expansive waterfront lot at the prestigious northern tip of Anna Maria Island. Surrounded by lush, natural landscaping, this home offers a private sanctuary where the beauty of the island meets modern comfort.
The Space
Completely renovated in 2015 and 2024, this bright and airy home is designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living.
Spacious Layout: 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a large, open-concept chef’s kitchen.
Island Breeze: French doors in nearly every room open directly to the pool area, inviting the sunshine in.
Modern Comfort: Fully air-conditioned (dual units for total control), high-speed Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs in the living area and both master suites.
Outdoor Living & Amenities
Boater’s Dream: Enjoy effortless access to the AMI Bayside and the open Gulf right from your private boat dock.
Spend your days soaking up the Florida sun or retreating to the nearby sands.
Poolside Paradise: Enjoy a private pool area equipped with lounge chairs, outdoor seating, and a charcoal BBQ.
Al Fresco Dining: A large terrace table with seating for 8—perfect for sunset dinners.
Beach Ready: We provide pool and beach equipment so you can pack light and dive straight into vacation mode.
Prime Location: A short, scenic stroll puts you on the shores of both the pristine Gulf beaches and the tranquil Bimini Bay.
Transparent Pricing
We believe your vacation should be stress-free from the moment you book.
Our Rates: No surprises, no hidden costs—just pure relaxation.
Amenities at Beach meets Bay: Your Private Poolside Beach-Boat-Bay-Paradise
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Anna Maria Island, FL
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
Nice location. Pool was perfect and the living area was spacious enough for the 8 of us to eat and hangout without being cramped.
10 / 10Outstanding·Feb 2026
I had a great time with my family. The home was beautiful and relaxing. My granddaughters loved spending time in the pool. Having all the extra pool and beach supplies was an added bonus. Looking forward to next year.
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2025
We have been visiting Anna Maria Island for many years, and this property is now a favorite. Located on the north end of the island, it sits right on the channel with dock access—ideal for relaxing by the water or launching a kayak. It is a nice walk in the evening to the City Pier and Two Scoops for ice cream.The house itself was clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully laid out, with everything on one floor—which we really appreciated. The pool area was a highlight: a great place to cool off during the day or enjoy dinner in the evening under the canopy-covered patio. The beach is just an easy walk away, making it perfect for being able to come back to the house if you forgot something. This home truly captures what we love about Anna Maria: peaceful, beautiful, and easy to enjoy. We would absolutely stay here again.
6 / 10Average·May 2026
House was as described but your certainly paying for the fact your on a canal at the north end. Pool is nice and heated more than others on the island so it made up for not having a hot tub.The property itself is lacking maintenance from the property manager. One of the bathroom doors always popped open luckily there was a sliding door to also close. The bathtub drain needed to be propped open otherwise it wouldn’t drain. Bugs were constantly getting in the house probably from some of the screens not fitting the windows appropriately, when we arrived it looked like the counters hadn’t been clean because bugs were all over it. I’ve never been at a rental that didn’t have cleaning solution so I couldn’t disinfect them. Microwave only worked if you slammed the door vs trying to close it quietly to not wake people up. The water level was low at the dock so no easy access to rent and use kayaks but we knew that might be an issue going into this property.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(86 Ratings)
"Nice location. Pool was perfect and the living area was spacious enough for the 8 of us to eat and hangout without being cramped."
Jessica K.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
