House in North Fork, NY
7 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Enjoy this newly renovated home on Shelter Island. A gorgeous, well-stocked gourmet kitchen with vaulted ceiling great room allows the chef(s) to be a part of the fun. Sliders out to the pool and tons of outdoor seating provide plenty of options for a relaxing experience. The outdoor shower makes for an easy post-beach or pool refresher. Primary king bedroom with en suite bathroom gives everyone their own space.
Indoor dining options feature 4 seats at the counter and a dining table that expands to seat 8. Outdoor dining with table & umbrella along with a Weber grill.
Private backyard, large 20x40 heated gunite pool with Hollywood steps and a deep water bench make pool days a dream. Stroll to the beach to watch the sunset in less than 5 minutes. Biking, kayaking, boating, golf and beaching are the joys of Shelter Island, along with it's farmers markets, local shopping and wonderful local seafood, casual and fine dining restaurants. Brief ferry rides to Greenport or Sag Harbor give you plenty of "off-island" entertainment options, too! Summer by the sea never looked better than from this clean, comfortable home.
* Other amenities:
Bose wireless stereo system
Nespresso coffee maker
Fully stocked kitchen
Washer & Dryer / Separate Laundry Room
Free WiFi / Internet
Smart TVs in 3 bedrooms & LR
Twin bedroom easily converts or doubles as an office
Extra full-size fridge in the attached garage
Small drinks fridge on lower level, Bicycles, beach chairs and cooler provided
Room in the attached garage to store and protect the toys
you bring with you.
Driveway (off-street) parking
Indoor dining options feature 4 seats at the counter and a dining table that expands to seat 8. Outdoor dining with table & umbrella along with a Weber grill.
Private backyard, large 20x40 heated gunite pool with Hollywood steps and a deep water bench make pool days a dream. Stroll to the beach to watch the sunset in less than 5 minutes. Biking, kayaking, boating, golf and beaching are the joys of Shelter Island, along with it's farmers markets, local shopping and wonderful local seafood, casual and fine dining restaurants. Brief ferry rides to Greenport or Sag Harbor give you plenty of "off-island" entertainment options, too! Summer by the sea never looked better than from this clean, comfortable home.
* Other amenities:
Bose wireless stereo system
Nespresso coffee maker
Fully stocked kitchen
Washer & Dryer / Separate Laundry Room
Free WiFi / Internet
Smart TVs in 3 bedrooms & LR
Twin bedroom easily converts or doubles as an office
Extra full-size fridge in the attached garage
Small drinks fridge on lower level, Bicycles, beach chairs and cooler provided
Room in the attached garage to store and protect the toys
you bring with you.
Driveway (off-street) parking
Amenities at Private heated pool and spacious yard. 5 minute walk to the beach.
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of North Fork, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
We had a wonderful holiday here. The pool and surrounding outdoor space was perfect. The kitchen is v well equipped and there was lots of space to in the dining living area too! LK is a wonderful host and always available for any queries. I would highly recommend it.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Of the many vacation homes we’ve rented over the years, 4 Penny’s path has been the closest to ideal. In an immaculate, well-equipped house, with a large garage and beautifully landscaped backyard with a pool, we enjoyed long summer evenings surrounded by birds and other wildlife; especially welcome were visits from Sparkles and Goose, two charming and friendly chickens who live next door. We were usually able to dine and grill outside, weather permitting, or sit under the generous pergola when the sun was intense. The grounds and the pool are scrupulously maintained with many umbrellas for shade, while the neighborhood is quiet and lush with greenery. An outdoor shower is a particular treat. The kitchen is large and very well equipped with spices, household supplies and three coffee makers, a rarity in rental homes. A powerful generator instantly restores power in case of outages. A word of caution for anyone with mobility issues, as one of us has: the master bed, though comfortable, is abnormally high (to allow for drawers underneath), so it is difficult to enter and dismount. Also, the guest bedrooms, bath and washer/dryer are in the basement, down a steep flight of stairs, a challenge for older folks or handicapped. That being said, the rental has our highest recommendation. Lynn Kay was an exceedingly responsive host who was there in a flash whenever anything was needed.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2024
We enjoyed a wonderful nine night stay at the property in August 2024. We are a family of five - two adults and three kids aged 10, 8 and 1. The house was spacious, comfortable and very well equipped - particularly the kitchen. The highlight was certainly the pool area - which is private, with a large heated pool and plenty of seating areas. The neighbourhood was quiet and nowhere on the island is far away. Lynn was a great host, very welcoming and responsive to any queries. We would highly recommend and hope to return when next in the area. Overall a great house to experience the unique charm of Shelter Island.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2024
This house was absolutely perfect for our family! The house was spotless, beautifully decorated, and had everything we needed for a relaxing vacation--beach chairs, coolers, beach umbrella, bikes, towels, pool floats and a well-stocked kitchen…I could go on! The host was attentive and made sure we had everything we needed. We can’t wait to return next year—highly recommend!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(13 Ratings)
"We had a wonderful holiday here. The pool and surrounding outdoor space was perfect. The kitchen is v well equipped and there was lots of space to in the dining living area too! LK is a wonderful..."
Simone M.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
