House in North Captiva Island, FL
5 guests · 2 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Peters Beach House | Beachfront Living on North Captiva Island
Escape to Peters Beach House, a beautifully renovated beachfront retreat on North Captiva Island, where breathtaking sunrises, endless beach views, and the peaceful rhythm of island life await.
Located directly on the beach and bordering private undeveloped land, this home offers a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and direct access to one of Florida’s most unique coastal destinations. Spend your days fishing just steps from the house, searching for seashells along miles of uncrowded shoreline, or simply relaxing while dolphins frequently pass by offshore.
North Captiva Island is a secluded, bridgeless barrier island accessible only by passenger ferry, private boat, water taxi, or small aircraft. With no cars and no crowds, the island offers a truly tranquil escape where golf carts, bicycles, and sandy pathways replace busy roads and traffic.
Inside, Peters Beach House has been thoughtfully updated to provide all the comforts of home while preserving the relaxed atmosphere of island living. Guests will enjoy:
• Spectacular beachfront views
• Newly renovated interior
• Brand-new appliances
• High-speed Wi-Fi
• Smart TV with streaming capabilities
• Full-size washer and dryer
• Beach chairs for guest use
• Indoor and outdoor games for the whole family
Your stay also includes a complimentary guest membership to the Safety Harbor Club, providing access to:
• Resort-style swimming pool
• Pickleball courts
• Tennis courts
• Marina and boat slips
• Additional club amenities
To help you explore the island, your reservation includes a golf cart provided by Shally’s Seashells Property Management. Cruise to local favorites such as Mainstay, Barnacles Bar & Grill, and the Island Market, where you’ll find groceries, coffee, ice cream, and island essentials.
Need groceries waiting upon arrival? Shally’s Seashells also offers convenient grocery delivery and mid-stay replenishment services to make your vacation as effortless as possible.
North Captiva Island is served by a staffed fire department and EMS personnel. Emergency medical transportation is available when necessary via rescue boat, ferry, or helicopter.
Whether you’re planning a family vacation, fishing trip, romantic getaway, or simply looking to unplug and reconnect with nature, Peters Beach House offers the perfect setting to experience the unmatched beauty of North Captiva Island.
Wake up to the sunrise, fall asleep to the sound of the waves, and discover why so many guests return year after year.
Exclusively Managed by Shally’s Seashells Property Management
Escape to Peters Beach House, a beautifully renovated beachfront retreat on North Captiva Island, where breathtaking sunrises, endless beach views, and the peaceful rhythm of island life await.
Located directly on the beach and bordering private undeveloped land, this home offers a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and direct access to one of Florida’s most unique coastal destinations. Spend your days fishing just steps from the house, searching for seashells along miles of uncrowded shoreline, or simply relaxing while dolphins frequently pass by offshore.
North Captiva Island is a secluded, bridgeless barrier island accessible only by passenger ferry, private boat, water taxi, or small aircraft. With no cars and no crowds, the island offers a truly tranquil escape where golf carts, bicycles, and sandy pathways replace busy roads and traffic.
Inside, Peters Beach House has been thoughtfully updated to provide all the comforts of home while preserving the relaxed atmosphere of island living. Guests will enjoy:
• Spectacular beachfront views
• Newly renovated interior
• Brand-new appliances
• High-speed Wi-Fi
• Smart TV with streaming capabilities
• Full-size washer and dryer
• Beach chairs for guest use
• Indoor and outdoor games for the whole family
Your stay also includes a complimentary guest membership to the Safety Harbor Club, providing access to:
• Resort-style swimming pool
• Pickleball courts
• Tennis courts
• Marina and boat slips
• Additional club amenities
To help you explore the island, your reservation includes a golf cart provided by Shally’s Seashells Property Management. Cruise to local favorites such as Mainstay, Barnacles Bar & Grill, and the Island Market, where you’ll find groceries, coffee, ice cream, and island essentials.
Need groceries waiting upon arrival? Shally’s Seashells also offers convenient grocery delivery and mid-stay replenishment services to make your vacation as effortless as possible.
North Captiva Island is served by a staffed fire department and EMS personnel. Emergency medical transportation is available when necessary via rescue boat, ferry, or helicopter.
Whether you’re planning a family vacation, fishing trip, romantic getaway, or simply looking to unplug and reconnect with nature, Peters Beach House offers the perfect setting to experience the unmatched beauty of North Captiva Island.
Wake up to the sunrise, fall asleep to the sound of the waves, and discover why so many guests return year after year.
Exclusively Managed by Shally’s Seashells Property Management
Amenities at Beachfront Bliss at PETERS BEACH HOUSE - 2BR 2BA - Club Membership-Boat Dockage
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of North Captiva Island, FL
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Beautiful setting! Very helpful communication prior to check in and responsive replies whenever we needed anything. The house was nice and clean and well equipped. The use of a golf cart was a fun perk too!
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Excellent disconnect from the main land. Staff were amazing. Made accommodations for us and even help return my wallet I accidentally left behind. We will be staying at this house again.
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2026
My family and I really enjoyed our stay at Peter’s Beach House. All of the furnishings throughout the home were lovely and the equipped kitchen was a joy to cook in. The location simply could not be better, directly on the bay side of the island. It was very clean and communication with property management was great. I would be remiss if I didn’t mention the construction on the property next door. It was very loud every day from 8:30 am to 3:30 pm, and the construction barge takes up a large portion of that lovely view of the water. We absolutely loved this home and location, and we will be back, just after the construction is complete.
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2026
Enjoyed the house and the beach.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(8 Ratings)
"Beautiful setting! Very helpful communication prior to check in and responsive replies whenever we needed anything. The house was nice and clean and well equipped. The use of a golf cart was a fun per..."
Ann L M.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
