House in Keuka Lake, NY
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Tiki on the Lake – A One-of-a-Kind Pet-Friendly Finger Lakes Escape!
Looking for a spacious lake getaway with plenty of room for family, friends, and your furry companions? Tiki on the Lake has it all – breathtaking views, multiple living areas, an incredible tiki bar, and a massive dock for all your water adventures!
Inside the Home – Space, Comfort & Relaxation
Entry-Level Features:
2 Living Rooms – Plenty of space to relax & unwind.
3 Bedrooms | 2 Full Bathrooms – Comfortable and inviting.
Master Suite – Queen-size bed, TV, window A/C, large soaking tub, and shower – your private retreat after a day on the lake.
Well-Equipped Kitchen – Stunning lake views while you cook, sip Finger Lakes wine, and make lasting memories.
Dining Room – Gather around for family meals and great conversations.
Lower-Level Features:
2 Additional Sleeping Spaces | ½ Bathroom
Room 1: Twin-over-full bunk bed + comfy pull-up sofa bed (more comfortable than a pull-out couch!).
Room 2: Queen-size bed – a cozy and private retreat.
Can Sleep Up to 7 Guests on This Level!
The Star of the Show – Your Own Tiki Bar!
Enormous Bar & Lounge Area – Complete with a piano, games, and plenty of space to entertain!
Step Outside to Your Lower Patio – Charcoal barbecue grill + smoker for amazing outdoor feasts.
1+ Acre Yard – Spacious outdoor space to enjoy yard games & relaxation.
Lakeside Fun & Private Dock Access!
Just Across the Road – Follow the driveway to your personal T-shaped, 84-ft dock.
Perfect for Hanging Out, Fishing, or Docking Your Boat.
Boat Launch Nearby for Easy Access to the Water!
Pet-Friendly Perks
Bring Your Furry Friends! Well-behaved pets are welcome for an additional fee.
Plenty of Outdoor Space for your pet to roam and explore!
Important Notes
No Smoking – This is a smoke-free property.
Docking Capabilities May Vary – Water levels change seasonally and may impact docking.
Outdoor Amenities (furniture, fire pits, watercraft) Available May 15 – October 15.
Ideally Located Near:
Watkins Glen International Speedway
Finger Lakes Wineries & Breweries
State Parks, Hiking Trails & More!
Book your unforgettable lakeside getaway at Tiki on the Lake today – and bring your pets along for the adventure!
When booking the property, we require a valid email address to send your rental agreement to, as well as a copy of the reservation holder's valid identification. To rent from Between the Lakes Vacation Rental, the reservation holder must be at least 25 years old.
Looking for a spacious lake getaway with plenty of room for family, friends, and your furry companions? Tiki on the Lake has it all – breathtaking views, multiple living areas, an incredible tiki bar, and a massive dock for all your water adventures!
Inside the Home – Space, Comfort & Relaxation
Entry-Level Features:
2 Living Rooms – Plenty of space to relax & unwind.
3 Bedrooms | 2 Full Bathrooms – Comfortable and inviting.
Master Suite – Queen-size bed, TV, window A/C, large soaking tub, and shower – your private retreat after a day on the lake.
Well-Equipped Kitchen – Stunning lake views while you cook, sip Finger Lakes wine, and make lasting memories.
Dining Room – Gather around for family meals and great conversations.
Lower-Level Features:
2 Additional Sleeping Spaces | ½ Bathroom
Room 1: Twin-over-full bunk bed + comfy pull-up sofa bed (more comfortable than a pull-out couch!).
Room 2: Queen-size bed – a cozy and private retreat.
Can Sleep Up to 7 Guests on This Level!
The Star of the Show – Your Own Tiki Bar!
Enormous Bar & Lounge Area – Complete with a piano, games, and plenty of space to entertain!
Step Outside to Your Lower Patio – Charcoal barbecue grill + smoker for amazing outdoor feasts.
1+ Acre Yard – Spacious outdoor space to enjoy yard games & relaxation.
Lakeside Fun & Private Dock Access!
Just Across the Road – Follow the driveway to your personal T-shaped, 84-ft dock.
Perfect for Hanging Out, Fishing, or Docking Your Boat.
Boat Launch Nearby for Easy Access to the Water!
Pet-Friendly Perks
Bring Your Furry Friends! Well-behaved pets are welcome for an additional fee.
Plenty of Outdoor Space for your pet to roam and explore!
Important Notes
No Smoking – This is a smoke-free property.
Docking Capabilities May Vary – Water levels change seasonally and may impact docking.
Outdoor Amenities (furniture, fire pits, watercraft) Available May 15 – October 15.
Ideally Located Near:
Watkins Glen International Speedway
Finger Lakes Wineries & Breweries
State Parks, Hiking Trails & More!
Book your unforgettable lakeside getaway at Tiki on the Lake today – and bring your pets along for the adventure!
When booking the property, we require a valid email address to send your rental agreement to, as well as a copy of the reservation holder's valid identification. To rent from Between the Lakes Vacation Rental, the reservation holder must be at least 25 years old.
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
Very unique. The 7 and 11 year old loved the Tiki bar. Made lots of money off of uncle serving finger food and mystery drinks at outrageous prices.enjoyed every minute.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9Outstanding
(2 Ratings)
"Very unique. The 7 and 11 year old loved the Tiki bar. Made lots of money off of uncle serving finger food and mystery drinks at outrageous prices.enjoyed every minute."
jd m.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
