House in Key West, FL
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Welcome to Papaya Place by AvantStay! This great 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom, Key West condo located at 1800 Atlantic Condominiums offers you a wonderful relaxing garden view overlooking the nature preserve. While the condo does not have an ocean view, the large heated swimming pool and Jacuzzi look right over the Atlantic Ocean.
The open living area flows from the full kitchen into the dining and living areas which exude an old Key West style. Sliding glass doors open to the balcony and sitting area overlooking the nature preserve.
The primary bedroom has a king size bed and a large en suite full bathroom. The second bedroom has two twin beds with a full bathroom across the hall. The balcony runs the full length of the condo with access from both the living room and the second bedroom.
The condo offers free WIFI, 3 flat-screen TVs, a brand new smart TV in the living area and primary bedroom, and expanded cable for those who still want to connect with the rest of the world. The condo looks over the nature preserve while the condo complex is situated on the Atlantic Ocean. There is a shared BBQ area, an Olympic size saltwater pool, Jacuzzi, clay tennis courts, and access to the gym with cardio and weight resistance machines.
Located about 1.5 miles from downtown, just a quick bike ride to downtown Key West shopping, restaurants, and bars. 1800 Atlantic is located right next door to Smather's Beach within walking distance of the condo where you can rent paddle boards, kayaks, beach chairs, and umbrellas.
Key West is the place to visit the lively nightlife and relax in the historic charm, flamboyance, and conch-style architecture that early Bahamian settlers made famous. It embodies a clash of the past and the present, and every building (including this rental) in Key West reflects this eclectic ambiance!
AvantStay provides a personalized hospitality experience to elevate your stay. With our Concierge Service, guests have access to our tech-enabled services like fridge stocking, private chefs, massages, transportation, special occasion celebrations, baby gear rentals, ski gear, beach gear, and more. For anything you need, we’re at your fingertips!
*Home Truths:*
- Please note that this unit is located in one of the oldest complexes in the area, and is not upscale.
- Balcony resurfacing is taking place in sections throughout the building. This work is expected to continue for several months.
- This home has access to a shared pool and hot tub.
- The tennis courts have to be reserved in advance, available on a first-come, first-serve basis. Directions on how to reserve are available in your Home Manual.
- This home features a sleeper sofa.
- We allow service animals at this home. If undisclosed pets are brought into the home without AvantStay's approval there is a fine of $500 per pet.
- Any reservations 28 days or longer will require additional clean/cleans to be scheduled. Additional payment will be collected and the amount of cleans will depend on the length of your stay.
- All bookings 28 days or longer require a security deposit to be charged after booking.
- The jets in the master bathroom are currently not working. Please do not use the jets and do not operate it as a tub or fill it with water.
- The twin beds can not be converted into a king.
- This home is on a monthly pest control schedule. The area of Key West is home to many insects such as termites, no-see-ums, and mosquitos. Pest control can not eliminate these insects during the swarming season. You may also encounter geckos, lizards, iguanas, frogs, and chickens during your stay in the area.
- Key West is a resort island where renovation of existing historic properties, new construction, and road repair sometimes occur without forewarning. AvantStay is not liable for any guest inconveniences caused due to construction in the area.
- Please note that max occupancy includes infants.
- Please be advised that documentation may be necessary for ESA/service animals to gain entry.
Parking Details:
One parking space in a covered garage
Vehicles/Golf carts using the A garage (West side) must be less than 6’4” in height.
---
The room configuration is as follows:
Primary Bedroom / King bed w/ ensuite
Bedroom 2 / Two twin beds
Sleeper sofa
---
This is a smoke-free property. Violation of the no-smoking policy will result in forfeiture of the security deposit, a $300 smoking fee, and liability for any fire or property damage costs.
As part of our commitment to being good neighbors, occupancy limits and quiet hours (9pm-8am) are strictly enforced. No speakers or sound systems will be provided for use in our properties. Violation of any noise ordinances will be subject to fines that can reach up to $10,000 per violation.
Events or parties are not allowed without prior written approval and an additional fee. Any unauthorized parties or events will be shut down and a fine will be assessed. Please inquire for more information about our event policies and fees.
There is nothing more important to us at AvantStay than the health, safety, and experience of our guests & staff. We've enhanced our cleaning and sanitation protocols and are taking extra care to disinfect all surfaces between reservations with hospital-grade disinfecting solutions.
As a reminder, we do work with 3rd party vendors to maintain the property, and although we adhere to the strictest CDC guidelines and advise all contractors to wear PPE equipment, we can not always enforce. We strongly advise guests to please deny access if any vendors fail to meet and adhere to these standards.
IDs will be requested for verification after booking.
We report and prosecute all Credit Card Fraud.
The open living area flows from the full kitchen into the dining and living areas which exude an old Key West style. Sliding glass doors open to the balcony and sitting area overlooking the nature preserve.
The primary bedroom has a king size bed and a large en suite full bathroom. The second bedroom has two twin beds with a full bathroom across the hall. The balcony runs the full length of the condo with access from both the living room and the second bedroom.
The condo offers free WIFI, 3 flat-screen TVs, a brand new smart TV in the living area and primary bedroom, and expanded cable for those who still want to connect with the rest of the world. The condo looks over the nature preserve while the condo complex is situated on the Atlantic Ocean. There is a shared BBQ area, an Olympic size saltwater pool, Jacuzzi, clay tennis courts, and access to the gym with cardio and weight resistance machines.
Located about 1.5 miles from downtown, just a quick bike ride to downtown Key West shopping, restaurants, and bars. 1800 Atlantic is located right next door to Smather's Beach within walking distance of the condo where you can rent paddle boards, kayaks, beach chairs, and umbrellas.
Key West is the place to visit the lively nightlife and relax in the historic charm, flamboyance, and conch-style architecture that early Bahamian settlers made famous. It embodies a clash of the past and the present, and every building (including this rental) in Key West reflects this eclectic ambiance!
AvantStay provides a personalized hospitality experience to elevate your stay. With our Concierge Service, guests have access to our tech-enabled services like fridge stocking, private chefs, massages, transportation, special occasion celebrations, baby gear rentals, ski gear, beach gear, and more. For anything you need, we’re at your fingertips!
*Home Truths:*
- Please note that this unit is located in one of the oldest complexes in the area, and is not upscale.
- Balcony resurfacing is taking place in sections throughout the building. This work is expected to continue for several months.
- This home has access to a shared pool and hot tub.
- The tennis courts have to be reserved in advance, available on a first-come, first-serve basis. Directions on how to reserve are available in your Home Manual.
- This home features a sleeper sofa.
- We allow service animals at this home. If undisclosed pets are brought into the home without AvantStay's approval there is a fine of $500 per pet.
- Any reservations 28 days or longer will require additional clean/cleans to be scheduled. Additional payment will be collected and the amount of cleans will depend on the length of your stay.
- All bookings 28 days or longer require a security deposit to be charged after booking.
- The jets in the master bathroom are currently not working. Please do not use the jets and do not operate it as a tub or fill it with water.
- The twin beds can not be converted into a king.
- This home is on a monthly pest control schedule. The area of Key West is home to many insects such as termites, no-see-ums, and mosquitos. Pest control can not eliminate these insects during the swarming season. You may also encounter geckos, lizards, iguanas, frogs, and chickens during your stay in the area.
- Key West is a resort island where renovation of existing historic properties, new construction, and road repair sometimes occur without forewarning. AvantStay is not liable for any guest inconveniences caused due to construction in the area.
- Please note that max occupancy includes infants.
- Please be advised that documentation may be necessary for ESA/service animals to gain entry.
Parking Details:
One parking space in a covered garage
Vehicles/Golf carts using the A garage (West side) must be less than 6’4” in height.
---
The room configuration is as follows:
Primary Bedroom / King bed w/ ensuite
Bedroom 2 / Two twin beds
Sleeper sofa
---
This is a smoke-free property. Violation of the no-smoking policy will result in forfeiture of the security deposit, a $300 smoking fee, and liability for any fire or property damage costs.
As part of our commitment to being good neighbors, occupancy limits and quiet hours (9pm-8am) are strictly enforced. No speakers or sound systems will be provided for use in our properties. Violation of any noise ordinances will be subject to fines that can reach up to $10,000 per violation.
Events or parties are not allowed without prior written approval and an additional fee. Any unauthorized parties or events will be shut down and a fine will be assessed. Please inquire for more information about our event policies and fees.
There is nothing more important to us at AvantStay than the health, safety, and experience of our guests & staff. We've enhanced our cleaning and sanitation protocols and are taking extra care to disinfect all surfaces between reservations with hospital-grade disinfecting solutions.
As a reminder, we do work with 3rd party vendors to maintain the property, and although we adhere to the strictest CDC guidelines and advise all contractors to wear PPE equipment, we can not always enforce. We strongly advise guests to please deny access if any vendors fail to meet and adhere to these standards.
IDs will be requested for verification after booking.
We report and prosecute all Credit Card Fraud.
Amenities at Beachfront 2BDR Condo, Pool & Hot Tub w/ Ocean Views | Papaya Place by AvantStay
Non-smoking
Family friendly
Map of Key West, FL
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
Clean, and communication with host was excellent.
10 / 10Outstanding·Dec 2025
The host was very welcoming. They checked in a number if times to see if we needed anything, gave great suggestions on places to eat, attractions, night life, etc. The place was very clean, comfortably, and had pretty much everything needed.When I had any questions, they responded rather quickly.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2025
While the condo could use a bit of updating, the complex and outdoor pool area vast, with a beautiful pool and out door space.
6 / 10Average·May 2022
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was clean.
I was more than happy with the location.
I was somewhat dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
We liked the location of this place. It was right on the water and close enough to duvall st to have fun, but far enough away from the crowds. Pool, tennis courts, and other amenities were really nice. Our unit (papaya place), however, was very dated. The TVs were tiny. Beds very firm (i liked ok, wife didnt). Also, the building is old and they were doing maintenance on it all week. So every morning they were jack hammering away directly below our unit. I think this place has a lot of potential, but its not there yet. We loved key west tho. Did a lot of really fun things.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
8.7Excellent
(57 Ratings)
"Clean, and communication with host was excellent. "
Jeremiah Y.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
