House in Cayuga Lake, NY
6 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
Fabulous rustic lake property on Cayuga Lake (circa 1890) only 2.5 miles from downtown Ithaca. 330 feet of frontage with full sun all day and awesome sunsets. Huge dock! Hot tub! Deep water! Incredible lawns and surprisingly private. Age requirement for guests (excluding kids) is 30+.
In case it is not clear in the booking process, our nightly rate is for 2 people and it is an additional $75 per night per person over 2 people, up to our maximum of 6 people.
Our lake house has 5 bedrooms:
Queen Master bedroom downstairs.
King Master bedroom upstairs.
2 Queen bedrooms upstairs.
1 Full size bedroom upstairs.
And we have 2.5 baths (one downstairs, one upstairs and 1/2 bath in third floor attic).
Our hot tub sits on the water's edge and our dock is HUGE, with a covered seating portion and water slide.
Ithaca is a wonderful small town in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Home to Cornell University, Ithaca College, many wineries and a rich culture, Ithaca is a great town to visit!
We have plenty of room for parking (another bonus)! Can fit 5 cars pretty easily. Public transportation does not make its way up the lake. But you an always walk down the railroad tracks 2 miles right into town. Or, you can paddle your way to the Ithaca Farmer's Market, to Stewart Park, Cass Park or Allan Treman State Park.
In case it is not clear in the booking process, our nightly rate is for 2 people and it is an additional $75 per night per person over 2 people, up to our maximum of 6 people.
Our lake house has 5 bedrooms:
Queen Master bedroom downstairs.
King Master bedroom upstairs.
2 Queen bedrooms upstairs.
1 Full size bedroom upstairs.
And we have 2.5 baths (one downstairs, one upstairs and 1/2 bath in third floor attic).
Our hot tub sits on the water's edge and our dock is HUGE, with a covered seating portion and water slide.
Ithaca is a wonderful small town in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Home to Cornell University, Ithaca College, many wineries and a rich culture, Ithaca is a great town to visit!
We have plenty of room for parking (another bonus)! Can fit 5 cars pretty easily. Public transportation does not make its way up the lake. But you an always walk down the railroad tracks 2 miles right into town. Or, you can paddle your way to the Ithaca Farmer's Market, to Stewart Park, Cass Park or Allan Treman State Park.
Amenities at Wonderful Rustic Lake House On Cayuga Lake only 2.5 Miles From Downtown Ithaca!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
We were in Ithaca for a family memorial and needed a nice big place for us to be together. This was absolutely perfect! A little too chilly for lake activity, but the accommodations are wonderful with plenty of room for everyone. We felt very comfortable there and Zach is an amazing host! Hopefully we can go back at a warmer time and get out on Lake Cayuga. So beautiful!
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
House was as described! Plenty of space and bedrooms for everyone. Only slight things not talked about are the stairs going from 1st to 2nd floor, they are tight and very low ceiling at one spot (I'm on the taller side at 5'8" and grazed my head a few times) and the clawfoot tub upstairs is awkward to get in and out of, just being so high. So we mostly showered downstairs which was fine! But overall we loved sitting on the dock with a drink and enjoying the views. Driveway is very short and steep coming in, but can be done going in slow with caution. Zach was easy to communicate with!
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
This was our second time staying at Zach’s lake house and we love it so much! The house is beautiful and comfortable and Zach is a great host.
5 / 10·Mar 2022
Beautiful house incredibly spacious with very friendly host. Thank you so much we loved our stay!!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(51 Ratings)
"We were in Ithaca for a family memorial and needed a nice big place for us to be together. This was absolutely perfect! A little too chilly for lake activity, but the accommodations are wonderful with..."
Cate S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
