House in Cayuga Lake, NY
15 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
We still have some Fall 2026 Availability!
Fall Availability:
September Limited Availability
October Week 1
November Week 3 and 4
December wide open
We have early booking specials for 2027 and 2028, so take a look!
This farmhouse, situated right on Cayuga Lake, was built in 1826 at Kidders Landing. The home was renovated to provide modern comforts. The house has 200 ft of gently sloping waterfront lawn and a new 100' dock with a swim ladder and a large platform for fishing and jumping into the water.
The house sleeps 8-10 adults comfortably and can be adapted to house more (up to 16 if at least 6 are children.) In addition to being located on the lake and in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Country, The Painted Porch Cayuga Lake Vacation Rental is also about 200 yards from a fun little log cabin lodge/restaurant/bar. So, while the house is fully equipped for dining at home, you can also make a last minute change of plans and go next door for a glass of wine and a nice dinner!
There are two bedrooms upstairs and two bedrooms downstairs. Two of the rooms have alcoves with additional bunks, making a multi-family stay more comfortable. There are ceiling fans in all of the bedrooms as well as additional window fans and air conditioners in all 4 bedrooms. We recently added air conditioning to the kitchen, living room and dining room.
There are tons of fun games in the house. And the kitchen, despite being simple, has all the tools to make a great family feast. From baking tools to roasting pans, steamer pots & zesters to a waffle iron, popcorn machine and a crock pot. The gas grill is also a great tool for summer cooking.
On the three acres, there are big trees and big lawns, perfect for bird watching, croquet and badminton!
Between the house and the lake is a small two lane road, which has few cars and serves primarily as a walking, jogging and biking trail. On the bright side, it is also maintained throughout the winter! We also provide little yellow "crossing markers" to create a safer environment for crossing, in the event a car goes by. In the winter, this road is maintained by the county.
The lawn slopes down to a shale beach. The dock is new and goes 100' out into the lake. Mid-simmer, the water is over 6' deep before you get to the large platform at the end of the dock. We have a large patio area down by the dock, with dining and lots of seating. We also have a fire ring at the edge of the beach.
There is a biergarten outside on the patio off the kitchen. Bar tables and bar stools. It is fun to watch for cool birds and the local white deer from there while dinner is being prepared! We have also added a patio on the south side of the house, for another shady option on late afternoon.
PLEASE ALSO NOTE: This simple farmhouse has NO TV but does have fast fiber-optic internet. You can have access to free wifi at O'Malley's also. Major sporting events are shown on the TV there. There are also 4-5 bars of phone service in the front of the house with ATT. Please also note. We have RING doorbells for security purposes; to protect the house and YOU, our guests. We also have a RING camera behind the house to monitor the bird feeders. We do not look at these unless our guests ask us to or if we are waiting for a package to be delivered. And we look when the house is not rented. We value YOUR PRIVACY.
A few more things: About half of our guests bring dogs. After each dog there is an extensive cleaning process. We do suggest (for the sake of cleanliness) that dogs don't go upstairs. If you bring a dog: The neighborhood is full of dog walkers. All of them are very respectful of the leash law in our area. They get really really frustrated if a dog is loose in our unfenced front yard and runs out to their dogs. Not all of their dogs play well with others. :( Please keep yours on a leash.
BedRooms & Bed Configurations:
Upstairs Queen/Twin Bunk/Twin Bed/Twin Sofabed
Upstairs Queen/Full
Downstairs Full/Twin Bunk
Downstairs Queen/ Twin Sofabed
We also have a pack & play stored in the library.
Finally, we have 4 bikes which are kept in the shed. And kayaks, a canoe and paddle boards stored on the rack at the lake. We have many life jackets stored in the deck boxes on the porch, but we always recommend bringing your own, just in case.
Fall Availability:
September Limited Availability
October Week 1
November Week 3 and 4
December wide open
We have early booking specials for 2027 and 2028, so take a look!
This farmhouse, situated right on Cayuga Lake, was built in 1826 at Kidders Landing. The home was renovated to provide modern comforts. The house has 200 ft of gently sloping waterfront lawn and a new 100' dock with a swim ladder and a large platform for fishing and jumping into the water.
The house sleeps 8-10 adults comfortably and can be adapted to house more (up to 16 if at least 6 are children.) In addition to being located on the lake and in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Country, The Painted Porch Cayuga Lake Vacation Rental is also about 200 yards from a fun little log cabin lodge/restaurant/bar. So, while the house is fully equipped for dining at home, you can also make a last minute change of plans and go next door for a glass of wine and a nice dinner!
There are two bedrooms upstairs and two bedrooms downstairs. Two of the rooms have alcoves with additional bunks, making a multi-family stay more comfortable. There are ceiling fans in all of the bedrooms as well as additional window fans and air conditioners in all 4 bedrooms. We recently added air conditioning to the kitchen, living room and dining room.
There are tons of fun games in the house. And the kitchen, despite being simple, has all the tools to make a great family feast. From baking tools to roasting pans, steamer pots & zesters to a waffle iron, popcorn machine and a crock pot. The gas grill is also a great tool for summer cooking.
On the three acres, there are big trees and big lawns, perfect for bird watching, croquet and badminton!
Between the house and the lake is a small two lane road, which has few cars and serves primarily as a walking, jogging and biking trail. On the bright side, it is also maintained throughout the winter! We also provide little yellow "crossing markers" to create a safer environment for crossing, in the event a car goes by. In the winter, this road is maintained by the county.
The lawn slopes down to a shale beach. The dock is new and goes 100' out into the lake. Mid-simmer, the water is over 6' deep before you get to the large platform at the end of the dock. We have a large patio area down by the dock, with dining and lots of seating. We also have a fire ring at the edge of the beach.
There is a biergarten outside on the patio off the kitchen. Bar tables and bar stools. It is fun to watch for cool birds and the local white deer from there while dinner is being prepared! We have also added a patio on the south side of the house, for another shady option on late afternoon.
PLEASE ALSO NOTE: This simple farmhouse has NO TV but does have fast fiber-optic internet. You can have access to free wifi at O'Malley's also. Major sporting events are shown on the TV there. There are also 4-5 bars of phone service in the front of the house with ATT. Please also note. We have RING doorbells for security purposes; to protect the house and YOU, our guests. We also have a RING camera behind the house to monitor the bird feeders. We do not look at these unless our guests ask us to or if we are waiting for a package to be delivered. And we look when the house is not rented. We value YOUR PRIVACY.
A few more things: About half of our guests bring dogs. After each dog there is an extensive cleaning process. We do suggest (for the sake of cleanliness) that dogs don't go upstairs. If you bring a dog: The neighborhood is full of dog walkers. All of them are very respectful of the leash law in our area. They get really really frustrated if a dog is loose in our unfenced front yard and runs out to their dogs. Not all of their dogs play well with others. :( Please keep yours on a leash.
BedRooms & Bed Configurations:
Upstairs Queen/Twin Bunk/Twin Bed/Twin Sofabed
Upstairs Queen/Full
Downstairs Full/Twin Bunk
Downstairs Queen/ Twin Sofabed
We also have a pack & play stored in the library.
Finally, we have 4 bikes which are kept in the shed. And kayaks, a canoe and paddle boards stored on the rack at the lake. We have many life jackets stored in the deck boxes on the porch, but we always recommend bringing your own, just in case.
Amenities at Waterfront Cayuga Lake Farmhouse - Lower 2027 Rates & Early Booking Specials
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests had a wonderful stay at The Painted Porch, praising its lovely farmhouse, stunning lake views, spacious property, and comfortable amenities. The porch swing and rocking chairs were perfect for enjoying the lake, and the host, Alison, was responsive and accommodating.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
This was the second time we've stayed at this property for a multi-generational get-together, with dogs. We had a great time again. The lake beach with dock, across a usually quiet road, is great for kids (and dogs), though you'll want water shoes. The yard is big--kids and dogs spent a lot of time there-- and so is the house, which is set up so that people can have their own spaces or everyone can be together. The kitchen is spacious and well stocked. We enjoyed the bench swing on the porch, too. The porch is also big enough to be a good play space for kids. Lots to like, and nothing to complain about. The renovated downstairs bathroom is nice.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
A renovated historic lakefront home, beautifully decorated with plenty of room for our family of seven adults, two toddlers and two dogs. Close to wineries and a short drive to Ithaca and Seneca Falls.We spent a lovely week exploring the area.Our hosts could not have been more generous and gracious.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
The house is amazing. It's very clean, great location with the lake access, pet friendly. Allison communicated very well. She took care of a fallen tree during the storm in such a quick amount of time that didn't impact our stay. I would definitely recommend this place and would stay again in the future.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
House was extremely clean. Kitchen is spacious. Front porch is wonderful for relaxing and nice views of the lake. Boat launch up the road is convenient. The owner was very responsive. Would definitely stay there with the family again.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.9Outstanding
(122 Ratings)
Guests had a wonderful stay at The Painted Porch, praising its lovely farmhouse, stunning lake views, spacious property, and comfortable amenities. The porch swing and rocking chairs were perfect for enjoying the lake, and the host, Alison, was respo...
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
