House in Fire Island, NY
12 guests · 5 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Summary:
Designer beach cottage & studio with bikes, outdoor shower, deck - walk to beach
The Space:
Experience the laid-back island life at this beautifully styled beach home, located in the heart of Ocean Bay Park and within easy walking distance from the ocean and the bay. Explore the island on the provided bikes or walk less than 100 feet to Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop-shop for watersports lessons and parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals.
This unique property is comprised of a main home and detached studio, you'll love the brand-new furnishings, high ceilings, white shiplap walls, and plenty of designer touches. The well-equipped and updated kitchen comes with everything you need to prepare your favorite recipes, while resulting meals can be enjoyed at the breakfast counter, the stylish dining table, or alfresco on the wraparound deck. Kick back in the sun-soaked living area and stream TV shows, or relax on the deck with a cool drink and listen to the breezes playing through the high grasses. For sleeping options, the main house includes four well-appointed bedrooms, while the studio offers ultimate privacy and features a bed plus a TV. Extra perks include beach towels and an umbrella, an outdoor shower to rinse off the beach sand, a washer/dryer, and partial air conditioning for added comfort.
WHAT’S NEARBY
Ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. Downtown Ocean Bay Park features bay front dining at Schooners and Flynn's, a pizza parlor, ice cream shop, bagel store and deli, a grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop. And when you want to hit the beach, this home is just a short walk from the surf and sand.
THINGS TO KNOW
- High-speed WiFi (speed can be impacted if several devices are accessing it at once).
- A wagon is available at the Ocean Bay Park ferry terminal.
- This home is only accessible via ferry.
- All guests shall abide by good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10 pm to 8 am
Other Things to Note:
Important Information
-There is a minimum age requirement to book this property. Please confirm eligibility prior to booking.
-The person booking the reservation must be present for the duration of the stay.
-A check-in form and rental agreement may be required prior to arrival.
Supplies
-Starter supplies are provided for your stay, including linens, towels, toiletries, paper products, soap, detergent, and basic kitchen essentials. Additional supplies may be needed depending on the length of your stay and are the responsibility of guests to purchase once the provided stock runs out.
General Rules
-Please respect quiet hours and be considerate of neighbors at all times.
-No parties, events, or unauthorized gatherings are permitted.
-Only registered guests are permitted at the property unless otherwise approved. Unauthorized guests may result in immediate removal from the property without refund.
-Smoking is prohibited inside the home. Evidence of smoking inside the property may result in forfeiture of deposits, additional cleaning charges, and smoking-related fees. Improper disposal of cigarette butts may also result in additional cleaning charges.
-Excessive cleaning, damages, missing items, unauthorized pets or guests, policy violations, or other issues requiring additional labor or remediation may result in additional charges depending on severity.
Check-In
-Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
-Early check-ins may be available upon request and subject to availability.
-Upon arrival, please inspect the property and report any concerns or damages promptly. Failure to report issues upon arrival may result in guest responsibility for unreported damages.
Check-Out
-Check-out is strictly at 10:00 AM.
-Approved late check-outs may be available for an additional fee.
-Unauthorized late departures that impact housekeeping or scheduling may result in additional charges, including charges equivalent to an additional night’s stay where applicable.
LocalSTR complies with applicable state and local lodging tax requirements. Taxes and applicable fees may be collected and remitted on reservations as required by law.
Designer beach cottage & studio with bikes, outdoor shower, deck - walk to beach
The Space:
Experience the laid-back island life at this beautifully styled beach home, located in the heart of Ocean Bay Park and within easy walking distance from the ocean and the bay. Explore the island on the provided bikes or walk less than 100 feet to Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop-shop for watersports lessons and parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals.
This unique property is comprised of a main home and detached studio, you'll love the brand-new furnishings, high ceilings, white shiplap walls, and plenty of designer touches. The well-equipped and updated kitchen comes with everything you need to prepare your favorite recipes, while resulting meals can be enjoyed at the breakfast counter, the stylish dining table, or alfresco on the wraparound deck. Kick back in the sun-soaked living area and stream TV shows, or relax on the deck with a cool drink and listen to the breezes playing through the high grasses. For sleeping options, the main house includes four well-appointed bedrooms, while the studio offers ultimate privacy and features a bed plus a TV. Extra perks include beach towels and an umbrella, an outdoor shower to rinse off the beach sand, a washer/dryer, and partial air conditioning for added comfort.
WHAT’S NEARBY
Ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. Downtown Ocean Bay Park features bay front dining at Schooners and Flynn's, a pizza parlor, ice cream shop, bagel store and deli, a grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop. And when you want to hit the beach, this home is just a short walk from the surf and sand.
THINGS TO KNOW
- High-speed WiFi (speed can be impacted if several devices are accessing it at once).
- A wagon is available at the Ocean Bay Park ferry terminal.
- This home is only accessible via ferry.
- All guests shall abide by good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10 pm to 8 am
Other Things to Note:
Important Information
-There is a minimum age requirement to book this property. Please confirm eligibility prior to booking.
-The person booking the reservation must be present for the duration of the stay.
-A check-in form and rental agreement may be required prior to arrival.
Supplies
-Starter supplies are provided for your stay, including linens, towels, toiletries, paper products, soap, detergent, and basic kitchen essentials. Additional supplies may be needed depending on the length of your stay and are the responsibility of guests to purchase once the provided stock runs out.
General Rules
-Please respect quiet hours and be considerate of neighbors at all times.
-No parties, events, or unauthorized gatherings are permitted.
-Only registered guests are permitted at the property unless otherwise approved. Unauthorized guests may result in immediate removal from the property without refund.
-Smoking is prohibited inside the home. Evidence of smoking inside the property may result in forfeiture of deposits, additional cleaning charges, and smoking-related fees. Improper disposal of cigarette butts may also result in additional cleaning charges.
-Excessive cleaning, damages, missing items, unauthorized pets or guests, policy violations, or other issues requiring additional labor or remediation may result in additional charges depending on severity.
Check-In
-Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
-Early check-ins may be available upon request and subject to availability.
-Upon arrival, please inspect the property and report any concerns or damages promptly. Failure to report issues upon arrival may result in guest responsibility for unreported damages.
Check-Out
-Check-out is strictly at 10:00 AM.
-Approved late check-outs may be available for an additional fee.
-Unauthorized late departures that impact housekeeping or scheduling may result in additional charges, including charges equivalent to an additional night’s stay where applicable.
LocalSTR complies with applicable state and local lodging tax requirements. Taxes and applicable fees may be collected and remitted on reservations as required by law.
Amenities at Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Fire Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
This home is beautiful inside and out. Boho chic design, lots of sunlight and a short walk to everything Ocean Bay Park has to offer!
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2024
This house was perfect for our weekend gathering with our adult children!! The house was very comfortable & had everything we needed for a great weekend!
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2024
This was our 3rd trip to Fire Island and this house was by far our favorite! Perfect size for group of 8 (3 families). All rooms were a good size with comfortable mattresses. 2nd half bathroom was helpful to have as well. Up to date kitchen with large table for dinners and games. Outside porch was also perfect for hanging out in the afternoons and evenings. Would definitely book again!
6 / 10Average·Jul 2024
Stayed here for a girls trip. We were a group of 11. Most of the beds are doubles so probably can’t actually sleep 12 unless you’re a kid or on the smaller side. The way the beds are arranged requires one person to crawl over the other to get out of bed since they’re pushed up against the wall. (Not a dealbreaker but something to consider for guest comfort).
As others have mentioned, feels bigger than it looks in the photos.
The bathrooms were ok. To break it down: there’s 1 half bath indoors, 1 full bath indoors, and 1 toilet in a shed with the laundry machine.
Reason for Lowe rating is Vacasa who are kind of the worst. Not sure I’ve ever had a good Vacasa experience, so wasn’t all that surprised that my stay here was more of the same. Half the rooms didn’t have pillowcases on the bed and none anywhere in the house. We had to call them late at night to get them and their response was, “if you checked in last night, why are you just calling about it now?” Nice, Vacasa.
For the price I would have expected pretty excellent host management, but communication was next to non-existent. But assuming you have no issues, you won’t need to contact them anyways
Great location near lots of restaurants.
More guidance on ferry details would’ve been helpful.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(23 Ratings)
"This home is beautiful inside and out. Boho chic design, lots of sunlight and a short walk to everything Ocean Bay Park has to offer!"
Stephanie A.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
