House in Shelter Island, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
Welcome to your private retreat in the perfect blend of comfort, space, and relaxation. With 9 years of hosting experience at this property, we’ve thoughtfully created a stay that feels welcoming, easy, and memorable from the moment you arrive.
Situated on a spacious .8-acre lot, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers an exceptional sense of privacy and tranquility. The property sits directly across from a preserve and beside an unbuilt plot, giving you peaceful natural surroundings and extra privacy.
Inside, we have an open floor kitchen/dining/den area with plenty of space. Also, the bedroom floor is recently renovated. Pets welcome!
Situated on a spacious .8-acre lot, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers an exceptional sense of privacy and tranquility. The property sits directly across from a preserve and beside an unbuilt plot, giving you peaceful natural surroundings and extra privacy.
Inside, we have an open floor kitchen/dining/den area with plenty of space. Also, the bedroom floor is recently renovated. Pets welcome!
Amenities at Relaxing Private Retreat Near Preserve. Pets Welcome!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Great spot for some time to explore Shelter Island. Close to everything and a cute place! Communication was great and the house had everything we needed.
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
This house has everything you need for a great vacation - very comfortable and inviting. The two bathrooms were recently renovated. The location is excellent for heading to Hay Beach in particular or anywhere else on the Island. We also enjoyed walking and hiking from the house, without needing to get in the car, and the neighborhood has beautiful natural areas. We highly recommend this home!
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2025
Comfy space to chill in.
10 / 10Outstanding·Nov 2024
This house has everything you need! 3 bedrooms downstairs, 2 bath, kitchen and a super cozy living room / common space. The main attraction is the spacious front yard! We really enjoyed taking the bikes out and how close this property is to town (a 5 minute drive). Highly recommend!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(56 Ratings)
"Great spot for some time to explore Shelter Island. Close to everything and a cute place! Communication was great and the house had everything we needed."
Gabe G.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
