House in Bay Islands Department
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Step out onto your private dock and soak in the beauty of the Caribbean Sea. The dock is outfitted with a charming thatched palapa, bench seating, and a hammock—perfect for morning coffee with the sunrise, sunbathing under tropical skies, an afternoon massage, or sunset cocktails while waves lap gently below.
The open-concept main level boasts a fully equipped kitchen, breakfast bar, and dining area, all cooled by a ceiling fan and air conditioning. The living room features two plush sofas, Starlink Wi-Fi, and Amazon Prime for evenings in. Slide open the glass doors to your covered deck—ideal for al fresco dining or simply relaxing to the rhythm of the nearby reef. There’s even an outdoor shower for rinsing off after a swim, and a hammock waiting for your midday siesta. Evening strolls on the beach or gathering around the fire pit under the stars create unforgettable memories.
The main-level master bedroom, just off the living room, is private and peaceful. It includes a king bed, twin bed, and panoramic ocean views through oversized windows. Enjoy ample closet space, an overhead fan, A/C, and a shared beautifully remodeled bathroom with tiled shower.
Take either the front or back staircase to the second master suite, a sanctuary with a king pillowtop bed, twin bed, and stunning sea views. The suite also includes a private ensuite bath with a shower and tub, dual closets, A/C, and a fan. Step out onto your private upper deck with 180-degree ocean views and constant breezes—your own personal perch in paradise.
For water lovers, enjoy two stand-up paddleboards, four single kayaks, and one tandem kayak to explore the clear, calm waters. Local dive shops are happy to arrange diving, snorkeling, or fishing excursions, and may even offer dockside pickup and drop-off. After your adventures, indulge in a locally prepared island meal—available upon request.
Whether you're paddling the reef, diving among vibrant coral, or simply lounging with a drink on the dock, Starfish Beach House offers the perfect blend of comfort, luxury, and unspoiled nature.
*Electric additional, collected at check out*
The property is located on a private point accessed by a gated wooden bridge. Although measures are taken to combat sandflies they still may be encountered. We provide spray but always a good idea to bring some.
- No smoking in home
- Quiet time 10pm
- Electric Additional
The open-concept main level boasts a fully equipped kitchen, breakfast bar, and dining area, all cooled by a ceiling fan and air conditioning. The living room features two plush sofas, Starlink Wi-Fi, and Amazon Prime for evenings in. Slide open the glass doors to your covered deck—ideal for al fresco dining or simply relaxing to the rhythm of the nearby reef. There’s even an outdoor shower for rinsing off after a swim, and a hammock waiting for your midday siesta. Evening strolls on the beach or gathering around the fire pit under the stars create unforgettable memories.
The main-level master bedroom, just off the living room, is private and peaceful. It includes a king bed, twin bed, and panoramic ocean views through oversized windows. Enjoy ample closet space, an overhead fan, A/C, and a shared beautifully remodeled bathroom with tiled shower.
Take either the front or back staircase to the second master suite, a sanctuary with a king pillowtop bed, twin bed, and stunning sea views. The suite also includes a private ensuite bath with a shower and tub, dual closets, A/C, and a fan. Step out onto your private upper deck with 180-degree ocean views and constant breezes—your own personal perch in paradise.
For water lovers, enjoy two stand-up paddleboards, four single kayaks, and one tandem kayak to explore the clear, calm waters. Local dive shops are happy to arrange diving, snorkeling, or fishing excursions, and may even offer dockside pickup and drop-off. After your adventures, indulge in a locally prepared island meal—available upon request.
Whether you're paddling the reef, diving among vibrant coral, or simply lounging with a drink on the dock, Starfish Beach House offers the perfect blend of comfort, luxury, and unspoiled nature.
*Electric additional, collected at check out*
The property is located on a private point accessed by a gated wooden bridge. Although measures are taken to combat sandflies they still may be encountered. We provide spray but always a good idea to bring some.
- No smoking in home
- Quiet time 10pm
- Electric Additional
Amenities at Starfish Beach House, On The Ocean's Edge
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Map of Bay Islands Department
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
Location was lovely, right on the water, with a dock you could swim from. The kayaks and paddle boards are great amenities. Snorkeling is a way out off shore though, a bit too far to swim, but you can kayak out then snorkel, but recommend using one of the buoys to anchor your kayak.The kitchen could have been a bit more clean -- fishy odor in the refrigerator, otherwise things were OK. The property and beach is cleaned and maintained by local staff, as well as having night security. Local kids play around the area but we did not mind -- they politely asked to borrow the extra kayak on most days and it was fun to see them out there having fun too.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
We enjoyed our stay at the starfish beach house. Daisy was amazing meeting us at the airport and making sure we found the house. She took us to a grocery store and showed us around a bit before we got to the house so we knew where things were. Daisy was Very responsive to any questions and information we needed. She was very sweet and friendly. We enjoyed chatting with her and learning about the island. The house was amazing. It was much nicer than it showed on the pictures. The dock was the best part of the stay. We spent most of our time out at the end of the dock. We ate our meals there. We went snorkeling and use the paddle boards. Everything was perfect. The house was very comfortable. We especially enjoyed having both suits on different levels so we all had privacy.The kitchen was adequately equipped with equipment to make our own meals. There was even a blender there so I could have my morning smoothies. There was a young man that came and picked the coconuts off of the tree in our backyard and open them for us so we could have a delicious snack. overall, the day was amazing and we are very happy with our experience.Burly and her daughters came out and prepared two meals for us. It was really nice having some local food and traditional meals on the island. They were a lot of fun chat, chatting with us telling us about their life on the island. Daisy gave us a few phone numbers for people who did boat tours. We selected Dewey Woods. He was fantastic.
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2025
We loved being tucked away from the busy tourist spots—exactly what we were looking for! Every morning started with coffee on our private deck, enjoying a stunning view that never got old.We took full advantage of the kayak provided and explored the nearby mangroves. When we felt like a bit more action, we paddled over to Turquoise Bay Resort—such a fun adventure!Daisy was incredible from the start. She met us at the airport, helped us pick up our rental car, and even stopped at the grocery store with us on the way to the house.She truly went above and beyond when we got turned around trying to find a restaurant. She came to where we were, helped us out with a warm smile and calm energy, and made sure we still made it to dinner on time. Total lifesaver!We highly recommend the Starfish Beach House to anyone wanting a peaceful, beautiful escape—with the added bonus of knowing Daisy has your back.
10 / 10Outstanding·Feb 2025
Communication from the beginning to end was outstanding! Daisy was incredibly helpful throughout! She met us at the airport, drove us to the home, answered all questions quickly (including general island questions during out stay), and made checking out a breeze. The location is beautiful and is accurately represented in the advertisement. The groundskeeper (Jerry) kept the place in good condition and also will deliver fresh lobster (if requested) at a very reasonable rate. The place also comes with nightly security, which I think is more for peace of mind of the travelers as we experienced zero crime on the island. Even so, it is a nice touch. The home is nicely appointed, has very comfortable mattresses, and has the best showers ever experienced on any island (have visited many). The kayaks, paddleboards, dock, and A/C were fantastic amenities. I would highly recommend the Starfish Beach House and if you do stay here I will also highly recommend Lone Star Fishing and Diving, Sandra's, Kristi's Overlook, Sandy Buns (West side), Lotos, Ikigai, Aqua Adventures (diving on South side), Pirates Canopy and Ziplining, and Camp Bay Beach. After nearly three weeks on the island and traveling/experiencing much of it I can say there is no place I would have rather stayed and these are the best of our experiences
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(38 Ratings)
"Location was lovely, right on the water, with a dock you could swim from. The kayaks and paddle boards are great amenities. Snorkeling is a way out off shore though, a bit too far to swim, but you can..."
Sharon S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
