Rustic meets Modern Downtown Retreat with Air hockey table

Huge house! Casey, the host was very accommodating to any of our needs. We have stayed at this property multiple times and will continue to use the property in the future.

First of all, I’m not sure how this property has a 9.4 rating. This place is not as it seems on the listing. It says it sleeps up to 30 and it barely fit our group of 25. There are only 3 bathrooms with one of them being in the upstairs bedroom, which is not enough for 25 people let alone 30. When we arrived at the property I needed sheets and blankets for our guests sleeping on the futons in the basement. We arrived late and were all ready to get to bed. I messaged the host because we could not find any extra sheets/pillow cases/blankets for our guests. They did not respond to me for 18 hours and the sheets were behind a pad locked door in the kitchen along with extra toilet paper. We ended up having to strip all the actual beds of their flat sheet to have something for our guests to sleep on. When they did respond to me, they told me they didn’t know I had that many guests or it would have been ready for them (I’ll upload screenshots of my convo for you to read the rude response I received to not take space here.)The basement is dark, dingy and smells musty and full of jumping spiders. When guests were showering we noticed water leaking on the basement. I again messaged the host and it took days for them to respond back to me (see screenshot for their response & pics)The washer had mold all in the rubber lining. The pots/pans/cooking utensils and cabinets were filthy. Overall, I would NOT recommend this place for anymore than 20 guests at most. Horrible experience.

The house was huge and had a great space for everyone to sleep. Beds were comfortable and rooms were spacious.It was easy to find and had plenty of parking for a large group. The only things missing were dish soap for hand washing dishes and the beds had only fitted sheets with comforters, which I think a lot of people prefer these days.Thanks for a great stay!

Nice house. Very clean. More than enough room for all of us. We were in Indianapolis for the graduation of our son at IU in Bloomington. Only thing we needed that we could not find was a hairdryer.

We had a wonderful stay for Christmas! Thank you!

I had a nice time it was clean n had enough rooms and i appreciate for letting me n my mom n kids do cookies n Christmas things thanks

We competed at U of Indy and we were less than 5 minutes from Nicoson Hall. It was perfect for wrestling team and the house was great! A couple minor maintenance issues but nothing worth bringing down our rating. We will definitely stay there again for next years event if it is available!

for starters the house is not really meant for number of guests it supposedly holds. only 3 bathrooms. for our 25 guests to get enough linens in a locked closet i had to ask for code. futons in basement were dirty, basement super cold no extra blankets, only one outlet for six beds. spied on by neighbors, host contacted me twice about things we’d done wrong. not enough parking for number of guests it holds. the host’s suggestion was to park across the street at the grocery, and when asked about the safety concern of that and whether or not the grocery is ok with that he responded “i do it all over the country in my rv.” as a woman that did not reassure my safety. even if it is “just across the street” you have to walk through a parking lot and cross a busy street with no sidewalks to get back. (past a gas station that was robbed the night before we left!) you can also tell this house was purchased recently and flipped, as many things are just…not quite right. loose handles, janky locks, wobbly stools, some of the basement decor still had tags, that sort of thing. additionally, when asked about some accommodations for our jewish friend, host responding with “that’s above my pay grade, google it,” which was not helpful. spent the whole weekend wondering what would go wrong next, honestly.