House in Penn Yan, NY
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this house rental
Welcome to our charming space located in the heart of Penn Yan, NY! This historic building, formerly the Penn Yan police department, has been transformed into a cozy and unique accommodation for our guests. Step outside and you're just a stone's throw away from a variety of restaurants, shops, and the famous Keuka Outlet trail. And for those seeking a bit of local history, you can even find the original jail cell preserved inside!
But the excitement doesn't stop there - our patio is an absolute gem, complete with a fire pit, dart boards, and a relaxing ambiance perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. Inside, you'll find a wall of board games to keep you entertained, ensuring there's never a dull moment during your stay.
Whether you're looking to enjoy the local attractions or simply relax and soak in the unique atmosphere, our space has everything you need for a memorable and comfortable stay in Penn Yan.
But the excitement doesn't stop there - our patio is an absolute gem, complete with a fire pit, dart boards, and a relaxing ambiance perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. Inside, you'll find a wall of board games to keep you entertained, ensuring there's never a dull moment during your stay.
Whether you're looking to enjoy the local attractions or simply relax and soak in the unique atmosphere, our space has everything you need for a memorable and comfortable stay in Penn Yan.
Amenities at Stay in the Heart of Penn Yan: Center of the Village
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Penn Yan, NY
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Oct 2025
Great location
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
Perfect. We’re from the area so it was perfect for our stay for large family wedding.
8.0 / 10.0Excellent·Sep 2025
Location was perfect! Less than a block from an amazing coffee place and many other restaurants were within 2 blocks. I would have given this place 5 stars if it had curtains or blinds to cover the fully glass doors. There wasn't any privacy as one of the doors overlooked the street. There was another glass door on the side of the building that overlooked an alleyway.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jul 2025
This has to be one of the BEST places we have ever stayed. Hands down. The property owner is absolutely friendly and helpful. The apartment itself is top notch. Perfect amount of space. The kitchen is super cute and fully furnished with anything you'll ever need. Absolutely loved the wall of board games. We took a couple of photos of the doggy/jail cell. We didn't bring any animals with us this trip, but may bring our dog the next trip. The outdoor patio was probably our favorite part about it. We spent most nights out there playing darts and relaxing. Perfect walking distance to breakfast, lunch, dinner and downtown Penn Yan. We will 100% be staying here again for our next visit to Penn Yan. Only suggestion I have would be to possibly put some pull down blinds on the two exterior doors. During the day, you can't see inside because of the privacy film, but at night, when the inside lights are on, anyone outside can see all the way through to the inside.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.2Outstanding
(14 Ratings)
"Great location "
Kim B.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
