Newly Renovated Apartment in the heart of Edgartown on the Bike Path!

All was great and it was the perfect landing spot for my trip. Only feedback I have is the light out back was really dim or out in general so it was dark at night and the mini split didn’t seem to cooperate with changes. Overall it was fine because I wasn’t there much other than to sleep and get ready for my day but wanted to provide that feedback. Thanks so much!

Just a quick stay... but the location was great. Just a 10 min walk to Edgartown. We did have a car but the weather was so perfect we walked. Bed was comfortable. Many great restaurants close- We loved Rockfish!

Perfect location - very easy walk into town, the grocery store, etc. The listing was as advertised, simple check-in process, clean.

I was amazed at the number of 10/10 reviews for this property, but the devil is in the detail, and the reviews from Patrick W in June 2023 and Rachel L in September 2024 paint a more accurate picture. First the positives, excellent communication throughout, flexible bag drop, a powerful shower, and a helpful shop manager Steve downstairs to address the problems we had. Upon arrival, you are greeted by a pile of old sports equipment outside the accommodation, see the photos below. We booked the property for 3 adults, it is marketed for up to 4, but on arrival, only the double bed was made up, there is a small sofa bed, but no sheets, this certainly couldn’t fit two more people. Secondly the property is described as newly renovated, it seems this is no longer the case, as the wood in the bathroom was rotting away. Finally, there were very few basics in the apartment, let alone the personal touches you expect from a host. Toilet paper and soap would be the minimum you should expect in a VRBO, shower gel, shampoo and given the price, perhaps coffee for the machine wouldn’t go a miss either. The apartment would suit a young couple looking for a no frills base on the island, but VRBO should remove “newly renovated” from the description and the host could consider cleaning up the outside entrance - first impressions - and adding a few welcome touches. It has potential, but currently leaves a lot to be desired.