Historic Home at Sheldrake in the Finger Lakes.

Top rated by guests
Terrace/patio
Interior
Private kitchen
Private kitchen
Dining
review stars
10Outstanding
(20 Ratings)
"The pictures don't do this place justice - it's so, so beautiful. The hosts we're extremely welcoming and the house had absolutely everything we could have needed. I would give it more stars if I coul..."
Emily B.
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
10 / 10
Outstanding(20 Ratings)

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this house rental

“The Gables” is a historic 1851 home in the heart of New York’s Finger Lakes region and a short walk to the shores of Cayuga Lake. Named one of the "Landmarks of Seneca County," this beautiful home has been family owned for over 100 years and four generations. Relax in this spacious and comfortable Gothic Revival home with beautiful interior and a large wraparound front porch. Enjoy the charm and elegance of an 1800s home with its beautiful woodwork, formal dining room, living room and parlor. A winding staircase greets you as you walk in the front door.

A large stained glass light fixture hangs over the table in the dining room. The living room invites you to sit in front of the fireplace and read your favorite book. The front parlor is a great place to play your favorite card game, board game or put together a challenging jigsaw puzzle. It even has an electric piano which you can play or have it automatically play for you.

Upstairs are four comfortable bedrooms (one king and three queen) and, as a bonus, another cozy living room to relax, enjoy your favorite TV show or read. The front porch has rocking chairs and tables to dine al fresco. This home has more than enough room for everyone to have their own space or gather together. The property is surrounded by a large lawn, beautiful trees and has a large paved circular driveway for vehicle parking.

Located perfectly for your vacation while visiting the Cayuga and Seneca Lake Wineries, Taughannock Falls, Watkins Glen, Ithaca, Cornell, Ithaca College, Geneva, or Hobart and William Smith Colleges.

Conveniently located near Cayuga Shoreline event center for your family wedding or event.

This is your starting place to get out and enjoy the heart of the Finger Lakes. You will be amazed how uncrowded and wonderful it is. Walk along beautiful County Road 153 as it follows the shores of Cayuga Lake passing many stately old lake houses as well as award winning Sheldrake Point Winery. Not far down the road is O’Malley’s Cabin on the Lake restaurant.

Just a 3 minute walk to public beach and boat launch enabling you to enjoy the waters of Cayuga Lake.

Also, just down the street, you can board a boat for the “Water to Wine” tour which takes to you to wineries located on Cayuga Lake. If you would rather go by car, hire the “Main St. Driver”, a chauffeur who uses your car to take you to any of the more than 200 Finger Lakes wineries and brings you home safely.

A short drive can also take you to the famous Lively Run Goat Dairy, where delicious local cheese is crafted, and you can meet the fun- loving goats!

If you are a hiker, you’ll love the many local hiking and walking trails at Taughannock, Watkins Glen, Ithaca and Hector. If you’re a bird watcher, you can see Canada Geese, wild ducks, Loons, Herons, Osprey, and even Bald Eagles on or along the shores of Cayuga. You can also visit the Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge at the northern end of Cayuga Lake. A short drive will take you to Deer Haven Park, the official site of the Seneca White Deer tours to see rare white deer.

We provide literature about these exciting adventures.

Get the idea? Relax… or go see…. or do both!

Here is what we offer at The Gables:

• Individual air conditioners in each bedroom and large air conditioner downstairs.

• Laundry room with washer, dryer, iron and ironing board.

• Kitchen with dinner ware, silver ware, cookware, dish washer, drip and Keurig coffee makers, gas cooktop, electric oven and two refrigerators.

• WiFi included.

• Two TVs (with streaming), One in the upstairs living room, one in a bedroom.

• Pamphlets and information about local recreation, tours and entertainment and dining.

• Outside gas grill.

• Three full bathrooms, two up and one down.



PLEASE NOTE:

ELECTRIC VEHICLES - Public recharging stations are available in nearby Trumansburg NY. There are no convenient outside outlets on the property for recharging. Use of extension cords from the house to your vehicle are prohibited for safety purposes.

NO PETS POLICY- NO exceptions

NO SMOKING IN HOUSE OR ON PREMISES – No exceptions

NOT SUITABLE FOR WEDDINGS, RECEPTIONS, PARTIES OR GATHERINGS including outside guests. Property is for the use and enjoyment of registered guests only unless prior approval from owners given.

DON’T GET US WRONG! – We love, Pets, Children, Weddings and Parties. We establish these rules simply to keep our property in the best possible condition for your arrival and stay with us. Thank You, and we look forward to your visit.

Amenities at Historic Home at Sheldrake in the Finger Lakes.

Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY


Ratings and reviews

10 / 10
Outstanding(20 Ratings)
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
The pictures don't do this place justice - it's so, so beautiful. The hosts we're extremely welcoming and the house had absolutely everything we could have needed. I would give it more stars if I could, our group loved it!
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
Good, convenient.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
Loved how well taken care of this wonderful historic home was.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
Fantastic stay!! We were in the finger lakes for a wedding and the location perfect. The owners of the house were delightful- highly recommend staying there.

$$$$
vrbo logo

FAQs

Is parking included with this house?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at Historic Home at Sheldrake in the Finger Lakes.. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Historic Home at Sheldrake in the Finger Lakes. pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Historic Home at Sheldrake in the Finger Lakes.?

We found 3 amenities for this rental. This includes non-smoking, no pets allowed, and family friendly.


Explore similar stays in Cayuga Lake

Explore all stays