House in Cayuga Lake, NY
14 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Enjoy lake views in the massive Cayuga cottage located on the east side of Cayuga lake on a quiet side street off the main road just minutes away from the quaint town of Aurora. The Cayuga Cottage is not your typical cottage, it’s a newer built high end two story vacation home with 5 bedrooms that comfortably sleeps 14. Large master suite with king bed and walk in closet. Attached master bathroom has double vanity, custom shower, and jacuzzi tub. This is the largest and by far best property on the street with a spacious yard and firepit. Waterfront covered patio with retractable awnings is perfect for outdoor dining with built in gourmet outdoor grill. Large eat in kitchen upstairs as well as lower level kitchen that leads to patio and also has a pool table. Watch the sunset on either the private dock or second story deck. Attached boat house with rail system. Whether you’re soaking up some sun with the family or hitting local wineries this house is the perfect getaway in the Finger Lakes!
Amenities at Beautiful, 5 bedroom, waterfront property on Cayuga lake!
Free WiFi/internet
Air conditioning
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
TV
Coffee/tea maker
Refridgerator
Kitchen
Balcony/Terrace
WiFi/Internet
Hot tub/Jacuzzi
Microwave
Dishwasher
Washing machine
Dryer
Patio
Kitchenware
Garden
Oven
Stove
Laundry services
Fireplace
Towels
Desk
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Nov 2025
We loved this house! It was even more beautiful in person. The kitchen and layout of the home was amazing. It had everything that we needed and more.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Oct 2025
We had a wonderful time! The house is incredibly spacious and has everything you need. We were warned about water limitations but had 10 adults and 3 kids and had no issue with water during our stay. We were conscious of it- but the showers were hot and pressure was good, we even did laundry. The reviews regarding toilet issues shouldn’t worry anyone, the issue was definitely resolved before our stay and we didn’t run into any problems. The house was clean , the fenced in yard was amazing for kids and dog, and the beds were very comfortable. We really enjoyed our stay and hope to come back to enjoy this house in the summer as it is the perfect location for that.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
This was the perfect house for 14 people . Large kitchen and living room area. The bedrooms were the perfect size. The outdoor area was great and the fenced in yard was a bonus
6.0 / 10.0Average·Aug 2023
This was once a beautiful property and could be again. As stated before, there are severe health and safety issues that should be addressed immediately. Rusted bolts sticking out of dock to be stepped on. An active water leak from the master bathroom into the basement ceiling with black mold. Another hole in the ceiling from water leaking in hallway in basement with black mold. The black mold in the coffee maker caused us to go out an purchase a new coffee maker for the house even though there was a Keurig, we wanted drip coffee. Most disturbing was the instability of the upper deck and rail system. I am concerned that with a bit of pressure it may give way. There was a bedroom ceiling can light that was hanging and the air conditioning stopped working for the main part of the house halfway through our stay. The exterior was filthy. The outdoor kitchen was not usable and the replacement grill had a buildup of grease and debris that when cooking hotdogs flared up and filled the house with smoke. A quick leaf blower would have removed all the dead lake bugs and spiderwebs that were everywhere. There were piles of miscellaneous items on the patio and the gate locks were broken or missing and had twine used to keep gates closed. I paid over $11,000 for the week and had to buy paper towels, garbage bags, dish soap, and water for the house. Please be aware of these items when you go to this house. Again, I think it could be a wonderful place with some maintenance.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(36 Ratings)
"We loved this house! It was even more beautiful in person. The kitchen and layout of the home was amazing. It had everything that we needed and more. "
Judy W.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
