House in Fire Island, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Historic architect-designed home located directly on Fire Island, in a quiet residential setting just steps from the ocean and less than a 10-minute walk to the Fire Island Pines Harbor. Designed by renowned architect Horace Gifford, this Fire Island Pines home offers four air-conditioned bedrooms, curated art-filled interiors, a heated pool, outdoor hot tub, and expansive terrace—an exceptional Fire Island rental combining design, comfort, and location.
⸻
This historic Fire Island home, designed by iconic architect Horace Gifford, is located directly on Fire Island, just steps from the ocean and within a short walk (under 10 minutes) to the Fire Island Pines Harbor. This rare combination of beach proximity, village access, and architectural pedigree makes it one of the most desirable Fire Island Pines house rentals.
The home features four fully air-conditioned bedrooms, ensuring comfort throughout the summer season. In addition to two indoor bathrooms, guests enjoy two outdoor showers, a quintessential Fire Island experience—perfect after a day at the beach.
Inside, the house is beautifully styled with numerous works of art, curated furnishings, and elegant interior design, offering a refined yet relaxed atmosphere. Multiple living areas provide space to gather or unwind, while a wood-burning stove adds warmth and charm during spring and fall stays, extending the rental season beyond summer.
Outdoor living is a highlight of this Fire Island Pines home. A large, thoughtfully designed terrace surrounds the heated swimming pool and heated outdoor hot tub, with multiple outdoor lounge areas, a dedicated dining space, and a Weber barbecue—ideal for entertaining after a beach day or an evening in The Pines.
Being on Fire Island, guests can enjoy immediate access to the ocean, beaches, and natural beauty, while also reaching the Fire Island Pines Harbor, restaurants, and social scene on foot. The home remains tucked away in a peaceful residential area, offering privacy while staying close to everything that makes Fire Island Pines (The Pines) so sought after.
⸻
✔ Fire Island rental
✔ Fire Island Pines rental
✔ Steps from the ocean
✔ Walk to Pines Harbor
✔ Historic Horace Gifford home
✔ Fire Island house with heated pool & hot tub
✔ Design-forward Fire Island Pines home
⸻
This historic Fire Island home, designed by iconic architect Horace Gifford, is located directly on Fire Island, just steps from the ocean and within a short walk (under 10 minutes) to the Fire Island Pines Harbor. This rare combination of beach proximity, village access, and architectural pedigree makes it one of the most desirable Fire Island Pines house rentals.
The home features four fully air-conditioned bedrooms, ensuring comfort throughout the summer season. In addition to two indoor bathrooms, guests enjoy two outdoor showers, a quintessential Fire Island experience—perfect after a day at the beach.
Inside, the house is beautifully styled with numerous works of art, curated furnishings, and elegant interior design, offering a refined yet relaxed atmosphere. Multiple living areas provide space to gather or unwind, while a wood-burning stove adds warmth and charm during spring and fall stays, extending the rental season beyond summer.
Outdoor living is a highlight of this Fire Island Pines home. A large, thoughtfully designed terrace surrounds the heated swimming pool and heated outdoor hot tub, with multiple outdoor lounge areas, a dedicated dining space, and a Weber barbecue—ideal for entertaining after a beach day or an evening in The Pines.
Being on Fire Island, guests can enjoy immediate access to the ocean, beaches, and natural beauty, while also reaching the Fire Island Pines Harbor, restaurants, and social scene on foot. The home remains tucked away in a peaceful residential area, offering privacy while staying close to everything that makes Fire Island Pines (The Pines) so sought after.
⸻
✔ Fire Island rental
✔ Fire Island Pines rental
✔ Steps from the ocean
✔ Walk to Pines Harbor
✔ Historic Horace Gifford home
✔ Fire Island house with heated pool & hot tub
✔ Design-forward Fire Island Pines home
Amenities at Fire Island-pines-historic House-heated Pool AND HOT TUB
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Fire Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Had the absolute best time staying in this gorgeous and unique house! Thank you Antoine for making everything so seamless and enjoyable!!
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Antoine was very responsive with any questions that we had. The pool was wonderful.
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2025
This VRBO is an amazing property with heated outdoor showers. The kitchen had a full supply of food preparation items. The hot tub was fantastic.
6 / 10Average·Jun 2026
Unfortunately, our experience did not match expectations. There were multiple maintenance and condition issues during our stay that affected our ability to fully enjoy the property. Most significantly, the oven was unavailable to us for the duration of the trip. After maintenance visited, we understood that we should not use it and would be notified when it was ready again, but we never received any follow-up and therefore did not use it for the remainder of our stay. Since the issue was a strong gas smell and an open uncontrolled flame in the oven, this wasn’t something we were going to test out without clear go ahead.Additionally, the front gate—which serves as the main entrance to the property—did not have a handle installed during our stay, making access fairly inconvenient.More broadly, the house itself felt significantly more worn and in need of maintenance than expected from the listing. Several of the screen doors were ripped, some lights were not functioning, and overall the property gave the impression that upkeep had been deferred rather than isolated issues occurring during our visit.Antoine was polite and responsive in communication, and we appreciated that. However, between the maintenance issues and the overall condition of the home, the experience ultimately fell short of expectations.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
8.8Excellent
(13 Ratings)
"Had the absolute best time staying in this gorgeous and unique house! Thank you Antoine for making everything so seamless and enjoyable!!"
Michael F.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
