House in Fire Island, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Gorgeous renovated 3 bedroom 3 bath plus two twin beds (loft area) in a compound located at Fire Island Pines, one block from the Atlantic Ocean and some of the most majestic beaches on the Eastern seaboard. High end brand new kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless appliances. Brand new solar heated inground pool, one of the largest in Fire Island, and 7 person hot tub. Propane bbq on each level. Outdoor kitchen/bar area with sink, DW and fridge with icemaker. Wireless two zone surround sound, one for the outdoors and one for the main living area. Three bedrooms, one with king bed and ensuite bath adjacent to pool deck (can be converted to two twin beds), one queen bed with private bath and balcony, and one adjacent to pool deck with queen bed. Two additional twin beds located on the loft …Extensive grounds, multiple decks and seating areas with a truly private feel. All brand new furnishings are sure to provide you with a high end vacation experience. Desirable east end location with an only 7 minute walk to the harbor where you can enjoy shopping, fine dining and nightlife. Enjoy views of the Great South Bay from the loft. This home will give you the feeling of your own private compound.
Rentals are from Thursday at 4 PM through Thursday at 10am
Rentals are from Thursday at 4 PM through Thursday at 10am
Amenities at Breathtaking secluded resort property one block from ocean
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Fire Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Everything was even better than my friends or I could have expected! Just from walking in off the main road, you can easily see how secluded and private the house and pool are because of the amazing landscaping. Upon checking in, we were warmly met by the owner and promptly given a good tour of the property. Our groceries had already been delivered to the house, which made us able to get our vacation started!Twice we had quick questions for the owners, and they responded immediately and were able to come check on the house promptly when needed, too. We had absolutely no problems with the wifi—or any of the electronics—during our stay. It was awesome being able to easily connect our own music to the pool and jacuzzi speakers; it made our house our favorite place to hang on the island. There's ample storage at the house, and the washing machine, dryer, air conditioning, and dishwasher all worked seamlessly. The beds were comfortable, and the entire house was extremely clean upon check-in. All of the bathrooms were spotless, and the showers all worked well. We cooked each night at the house and we were never without the proper utensils or dishware. 10/10 stay, and we would love to come back!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
House was perfect for our group of 6 friends. Host was extremely attentive. Would stay there again.
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2025
The good: This property was in a great location on the island. The living area is fun upstairs and was perfect for cooking, dinner together, talking, games, and hanging out. The hot tub worked well and it was fun to be able to cast music both inside and outside. Having grills upstairs and downstairs by the pool was very convenient and we used those every day. Things to know: The house does sleep 8, but note that the 4th bedroom is a loft area open to the main living area and doesn't have much privacy. The pool is heated by a solar heating system so if it's cold or cloudy, you won't get much from it. To improve: Photos show the property in a little better condition than it's in now. There is some maintenance, upkeep, and deep cleaning on the house that needs some TLC but it didn't detract too much from the trip. Kevin and Tom were nice to work with, but the communication leading up to the trip could have been more proactive. Overall, a nice stay on Fire Island.
6 / 10Average·Aug 2021
Numerous issues with poor cleaning prior to arrival with the exception of the pool and jacuzzi which were pristine. Clearly no Covid 19 sanitization was done prior to our arrival. Several kitchen appliances such as interior of refrigerator and housewares were filthy that had to be cleaned by us before use. Multiple dead bees and a collection of dust and hair behind the tv. Master bath electrical problems caused blown fuses at least once a day. Beds were uncomfortably hard and sheets in master bedroom were stained. Outside refrigerator was not working so could not be used. The bathroom in the garden bedroom had not been cleaned - hair from previous renters was on the floor and toilet. Enjoyed the setting but the lack of cleaning issues consumed a large part of our stay and detracted from full enjoyment of the property rental. Also the lack of sanitization is a major concern for safety.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(19 Ratings)
"Everything was even better than my friends or I could have expected! Just from walking in off the main road, you can easily see how secluded and private the house and pool are because of the amazing l..."
Wyatt R.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
