Cottage in Sag Harbor, NY
5 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this cottage rental
The rental is for the entire property.
This is a real country cottage - renovated with cathedral-style ceilings with finished exposed beams, clean all white interior, hardwood floors, with large skylights and screened-in porch!
The huge 30'+ x 40'+ L-shaped pool has a 10-foot deep end, diving board, and water slide.
Located just a mile from Main Street Sag Harbor and at the end of a private driveway the fenced-in 200 x 100 foot property is far from any roads and offers complete privacy.
Two bedrooms, one bath, a large kitchen/dining/living area, and a screened-in porch.
A separate a guest "bungalow" with sliding glass door, four double-hung windows, a ceiling fan, and full size futon bed is a third "bedroom" or can double as a pool house or office or studio (shown in last three photos). The bungalow provides a quiet and beautifully private space for teleworking or to hold online meetings.
Huge yard - an over-sized hammock and picnic table, Weber grill, lawn/pool furniture and a lot of room to play complement the large swimming pool.
Walking/biking distance to Sag Harbor Village (1 mile) and Long Beach, 10-minute drive (5 miles) to ocean beaches.
W/D, DW, WIFI, Cottage is also handicap accessible. Please feel free to reach out with any questions!
This is a real country cottage - renovated with cathedral-style ceilings with finished exposed beams, clean all white interior, hardwood floors, with large skylights and screened-in porch!
The huge 30'+ x 40'+ L-shaped pool has a 10-foot deep end, diving board, and water slide.
Located just a mile from Main Street Sag Harbor and at the end of a private driveway the fenced-in 200 x 100 foot property is far from any roads and offers complete privacy.
Two bedrooms, one bath, a large kitchen/dining/living area, and a screened-in porch.
A separate a guest "bungalow" with sliding glass door, four double-hung windows, a ceiling fan, and full size futon bed is a third "bedroom" or can double as a pool house or office or studio (shown in last three photos). The bungalow provides a quiet and beautifully private space for teleworking or to hold online meetings.
Huge yard - an over-sized hammock and picnic table, Weber grill, lawn/pool furniture and a lot of room to play complement the large swimming pool.
Walking/biking distance to Sag Harbor Village (1 mile) and Long Beach, 10-minute drive (5 miles) to ocean beaches.
W/D, DW, WIFI, Cottage is also handicap accessible. Please feel free to reach out with any questions!
Amenities at Secluded Sag Harbor Cottage - HUGE pool and separate bungalow/pool house
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Sag Harbor, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
Incredible! Stayed in October Everything was clean and in great shape. This house surpassed our expectations. The pool was magnificent and sitting in the enclosed front porch every morning with a cup of coffee, listening to the beautiful sounds of nature was what we needed. My husband and our boys had the most wonderful stay! From the moment we walked in, we felt at home. The home was well-equipped with everything we needed. I highly recommend this place, especially if you are looking to relax and be surrounded by nature and privacy. The total fenced in property put me at ease with our boys, so they were allowed to roam the yard. The location was perfect, close to everything. The hosts who felt like family were extremely responsive and friendly, answering any questions and provided us with recommendations for dinner, beaches and anything local. Downtown Sag Harbor is a quaint and charming waterfront village; we loved the stores and the waterfront walk. We can’t wait to stay again next year!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
My two friends and I had a lovely stay at this cottage. The pool is divine and Evan communicates so well! We had a plumbing issue and he sent out people to fix it within the hour. It's a 7 minute drive to Main Street and plenty of taxis and Ubers abound if you don't feel like driving. It's very secluded and quiet. Thank you for a lovely weekend!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Great location with amazing pool! Evan was just a pleasure to work with. He was very kind and assisted us with getting some great reservations at 2 nice restaurants. Evan was very quick with all responses to a few issues and was great to help them to get resolved. I would definitely rent from Evan again.
10 / 10Outstanding·Nov 2023
The owner was as helpful as possible. Communication and kindness was wonderful. Although we had some issues with accessibility, the owner followed through with solid communication and tried to resolve things. The cottage is so special and beautifully done. Nature is all around-- offering beauty and privacy. Dog friendly to boot! 5 stars !
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(10 Ratings)
"Incredible! Stayed in October Everything was clean and in great shape. This house surpassed our expectations. The pool was magnificent and sitting in the enclosed front porch every morning with a cup ..."
Regina S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
