Spacious Culloden house

This is a great rental. My group spent 10 days here and loved it. The owner is extremely communicative and always helpful. The house is clean and even bigger than the photos. The location is very close to beaches and great restaurants. Also a quick drive into the main town of Montauk. Will come back next year!

The owner was extremely communicative and very helpful throughout our stay. We loved the location as we were able to walk to the beach and only a short drive to some of our favorite Montauk restaurants. The house was clean and good for a larger group.

My wife and I spent 1 week at Elizabeth’s home this August along with our 3 adult children and their significant others. The home fit us perfectly and included a 5 star kitchen with every utensil, appliance, pot and pan you can imagine. We cooked everything from shrimp scampi with linguini to a sheet cake for my daughter’s birthday. The bedrooms were a nice size and very simple and clean. The 3 bathrooms are nicely appointed and super clean. The overall layout of the house was perfect for hanging out as a group - the large kitchen combines with a spacious living area - great for playing board games with refreshments and snacks always nearby. The modern washer/dryer combo is a great convenience when you stay for a week like we did. We made use of the outdoor deck and gas grill on a couple of occasions - it’s very private and a great location for stargazing at night. Although we had no urgent needs while we were there, Elizabeth was super responsive via text message for the few questions we did have. The location of the home can’t be beat - it’s a quiet neighborhood with the sound beach at the end of the block, and lots of restaurants and markets within walking distance. We hope to stay here again the next time we’re in Montauk.

The house was in a great location as described and the bathrooms were very nice and clean. We were a group of 5 couples, and selected this house based on the location and 5 bedroom availability. Prior to arrival I double checked that there in fact was a fifth bedroom as half the group was from California and wanted to make sure everyone had a place to sleep and was comfortable. I was assured there was a fifth bedroom. When we arrived the “fifth bedroom” was a very small room with no door and no windows (old closet?) with a couch only this was obviously incredibly disappointing for the price we paid. The washing machine smelled of mold, there was no soap anywhere (not even hand soap in bathrooms), no beach items so we went out to buy chairs and umbrellas. There was no propane for the grill. There was a peloton but it was locked from using it.Pictured is the “5th bedroom”.Overall I think with a few updates (soap, propane, legit clean of the washing machine, beach chairs) this would be an excellent rental as a 4 BEDROOM, not 5. The other bedrooms were big and nice, the kitchen was good for entertaining, and the location really is great.