Cottage in Baiting Hollow, NY
4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this cottage rental
SUMMER IS FINALLY HERE - come enjoy the northfork beach, farms and wineries.
5 minute walk to private beach on Long Island Sound! Enjoy the small town country/rustic feel on the north fork - and everything from fabulous wineries for couple and singles fun to country charm in farm stands with veggie's and pies and fun for the whole family. Our cottage is up on the bluff of a rustic, quiet private community. Cute, “brand new” 2 BR, 1 Bath Cottage on ground floor, Sleeps 4, plus cot.
Full kitchen, one bathroom with shower, Master BR w/queen bed; 2nd BR w/bunk bed. Living room with a/c, flat screen, Cable TV, Wireless Internet, on ground floor.
Small deck to relax in the evening, gas grill, parking. Just minutes from several local farm stands - boasting glorious local fruits and vegetables, Tanger Outlets, 10 mins to Splish Splash Water Park, fine dining and wineries, 5 minutes to ocean beaches, East Wind Day Spa, Steps from Baiting Hollow Club - 18 Hole Golf Course and many local wineries. Come and spend time with the family, get to know our friendly locals. Play on the private beach or just bask in the sun with a book. Girl's weekends, family getaways, beach vacations or any reason, who doesn't want to spend time close to the beach for the same rate as a hotel?
Steps to the beach. Summer rental available on a long term basis. Available most weeks from 4/15-10/15. Contact me for details.
Please bring your own beach towels.
5 minute walk to private beach on Long Island Sound! Enjoy the small town country/rustic feel on the north fork - and everything from fabulous wineries for couple and singles fun to country charm in farm stands with veggie's and pies and fun for the whole family. Our cottage is up on the bluff of a rustic, quiet private community. Cute, “brand new” 2 BR, 1 Bath Cottage on ground floor, Sleeps 4, plus cot.
Full kitchen, one bathroom with shower, Master BR w/queen bed; 2nd BR w/bunk bed. Living room with a/c, flat screen, Cable TV, Wireless Internet, on ground floor.
Small deck to relax in the evening, gas grill, parking. Just minutes from several local farm stands - boasting glorious local fruits and vegetables, Tanger Outlets, 10 mins to Splish Splash Water Park, fine dining and wineries, 5 minutes to ocean beaches, East Wind Day Spa, Steps from Baiting Hollow Club - 18 Hole Golf Course and many local wineries. Come and spend time with the family, get to know our friendly locals. Play on the private beach or just bask in the sun with a book. Girl's weekends, family getaways, beach vacations or any reason, who doesn't want to spend time close to the beach for the same rate as a hotel?
Steps to the beach. Summer rental available on a long term basis. Available most weeks from 4/15-10/15. Contact me for details.
Please bring your own beach towels.
Amenities at Relaxing Cottage -- Walk to private Beach!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Map of Baiting Hollow, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Very pleasant.
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2023
The property was cute and clearly effort was put into the aesthetic Maria was a good communicator and invited us to arrive early and stay late. That said, it really needed a dehumidifier as it smelled musty. They should give you advance notice that toilet paper cannot be flushed. Water pressure was iffy and we were advised not to drink from the tap. Neighbors are right on top of you and it can be loud at night. Beach is narrow, but beautiful. Location is great. We had a nice stay despite quirks, but this place is not for everyone.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2022
My wife came to visit while I was out of town working and this cottage was so nice and just a short walk to the beach. Nice friendly neighborhood
6 / 10Average·Jun 2026
We stayed at this location for 3 nights with our dog.Pros- dog friendly, great communication, friendly, easy check-in, everything was very clean and the furniture was in good condition, location was good. Cons- did not disclose in listing that you can’t flush toilet paper and the trash can in the bathroom doesn’t have a lid. If I had known this I would not have booked. When we arrived there was an incredibly strong perfume smell and we discovered several glade plugins that were being used to mask a musty smell. We had to remove the plugins as they are not safe for animals and give us headaches. There was a soft spot in the floor of the bedroom- I did flag it for the owner as I was truly concerned I was going to fall through the floor. It is listed as a cottage rental but you are actually renting the converted garage on the bottom of the cottage. It was fine but I didn’t feel it was as advertised. Also the air conditioner is a window unit in the living room, if you close the bedroom door the bedroom gets very hot at night.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
8.6Excellent
(27 Ratings)
"Very pleasant."
Barbara P.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
