Cottage in Baiting Hollow, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this cottage rental
This coastal oasis is tucked away amidst North Fork’s scenic farmlands. A quaint little colonial at the end of a country road leading to a beautiful Long Island sound beach, a mere two minutes walk down the road. A family friendly, bright and airy tranquil home base for your perfect North Fork vacation. Vineyards, breweries, farm stands, Long Island aquarium, lavender field, farm to table restaurants, fresh seafood all a few minutes drive away.
We are located at the start of North Fork, with easy access to either further East or to south fork (Hamptons). It’s a very low key and quiet neighborhood. Many folks have lived here for a long time and are full time residents. Everyone is friendly, and says hi to each other. We ask our guests to be respectful of that and not cause any unnecessary ruckus or problem for anyone. Street parking is not encouraged, please use the driveway.
A car is needed to get around!
Please note we have a ring door camera and another camera just for the driveway, looking away from the house.
Thing’s around here
Groceries:
Lots of farm fresh produce (seasonal) within just 5 miles - Schmitt’s farm (0.6 miles), Briermere farms (2.9 miles), Anderson’s farm stand (3.4 miles), Reeve farm (2.1 miles), Goodale farm (4.5 miles), Rottkamp fox hollow farm stand (2.9 miles)
Regular groceries - Target (3.3 miles), Stop and Shop (3.5 miles), ShopRite (3.2 miles), Aldi (3.5 miles)
Wine shops: Michael’s wines and liquors (4.7 miles), Roanoke plaza liquors (3.8 miles), wine mart (3.7 miles)
Restaurants:
Personal favs within 10 mins drive - Barrow Food House (4.8 miles), farm country restaurant (4.9 miles), Maple Tree BBQ (5.2 miles), Little Lucharitos (4.8 miles), Turquaz Grill (4.8 miles), Dark Horse Restaurant (5 miles), Jerry and the mermaid (5 miles), Preston Hotel and Restaurant (5 miles), Taco bout it (4.8 miles), Funchos certified tacologists (4.2 miles), Sarikopa coffee house
A little further out (15 - 20 mins drive) - Main Road Biscuit (8.6 miles), Jamesport Manor Inn (7.7 miles), Grana (8 miles), love lane kitchen (10 miles), Jedediah Hawkins Inn ( 8.5 miles), Windamere (10 miles), Red rooster Bistro (13 miles), the Watershed Kitchen and Bar (8.8 miles)
Additionally Greenport village is 30 mins away with plenty more options
Vineyards plenty, but top all time personal favorites - croteaux (18 miles), mattabella (17 miles), rose hill (12 miles), Bedell Cellars (15 miles), sparkling pointe (17 miles), macari (8.3 miles)
Cider house/breweries/distilleries - Riverhead cider house(2 miles), north fork brewing (4.9 miles), Jamesport farm brewery (6.6 miles)
Peconic County brewing (5.1 miles)
Twin fork beer company (3.6 miles), Long Island spirits (2.4 miles), twins still moonshine (5.2 miles)
Beaches - may be subject to parking restrictions, check before going: Reeves beach (sound beach) (down the road), iron pier beach(sound beach) (7.1 miles), wading river beach (sound beach) (9.7 miles), south Jamesport beach (bay beach) (9.5 miles), meschutt beach (12 miles), Orient State Beach Park (27 miles)
Long Island aquarium (5.6 miles)
Long Island Game farm and wildlife and children’s zoo (14 miles)
Animal Farm petting zoo (15 miles)
Splish Splash water park (3.7 miles)
We are located at the start of North Fork, with easy access to either further East or to south fork (Hamptons). It’s a very low key and quiet neighborhood. Many folks have lived here for a long time and are full time residents. Everyone is friendly, and says hi to each other. We ask our guests to be respectful of that and not cause any unnecessary ruckus or problem for anyone. Street parking is not encouraged, please use the driveway.
A car is needed to get around!
Please note we have a ring door camera and another camera just for the driveway, looking away from the house.
Thing’s around here
Groceries:
Lots of farm fresh produce (seasonal) within just 5 miles - Schmitt’s farm (0.6 miles), Briermere farms (2.9 miles), Anderson’s farm stand (3.4 miles), Reeve farm (2.1 miles), Goodale farm (4.5 miles), Rottkamp fox hollow farm stand (2.9 miles)
Regular groceries - Target (3.3 miles), Stop and Shop (3.5 miles), ShopRite (3.2 miles), Aldi (3.5 miles)
Wine shops: Michael’s wines and liquors (4.7 miles), Roanoke plaza liquors (3.8 miles), wine mart (3.7 miles)
Restaurants:
Personal favs within 10 mins drive - Barrow Food House (4.8 miles), farm country restaurant (4.9 miles), Maple Tree BBQ (5.2 miles), Little Lucharitos (4.8 miles), Turquaz Grill (4.8 miles), Dark Horse Restaurant (5 miles), Jerry and the mermaid (5 miles), Preston Hotel and Restaurant (5 miles), Taco bout it (4.8 miles), Funchos certified tacologists (4.2 miles), Sarikopa coffee house
A little further out (15 - 20 mins drive) - Main Road Biscuit (8.6 miles), Jamesport Manor Inn (7.7 miles), Grana (8 miles), love lane kitchen (10 miles), Jedediah Hawkins Inn ( 8.5 miles), Windamere (10 miles), Red rooster Bistro (13 miles), the Watershed Kitchen and Bar (8.8 miles)
Additionally Greenport village is 30 mins away with plenty more options
Vineyards plenty, but top all time personal favorites - croteaux (18 miles), mattabella (17 miles), rose hill (12 miles), Bedell Cellars (15 miles), sparkling pointe (17 miles), macari (8.3 miles)
Cider house/breweries/distilleries - Riverhead cider house(2 miles), north fork brewing (4.9 miles), Jamesport farm brewery (6.6 miles)
Peconic County brewing (5.1 miles)
Twin fork beer company (3.6 miles), Long Island spirits (2.4 miles), twins still moonshine (5.2 miles)
Beaches - may be subject to parking restrictions, check before going: Reeves beach (sound beach) (down the road), iron pier beach(sound beach) (7.1 miles), wading river beach (sound beach) (9.7 miles), south Jamesport beach (bay beach) (9.5 miles), meschutt beach (12 miles), Orient State Beach Park (27 miles)
Long Island aquarium (5.6 miles)
Long Island Game farm and wildlife and children’s zoo (14 miles)
Animal Farm petting zoo (15 miles)
Splish Splash water park (3.7 miles)
Amenities at Bright and tranquil north fork coastal oasis - 2 mins walk to beach!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Baiting Hollow, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
This is a comfortable, clean, well-appointed home with every consideration thought through, and implemented by the hosts.The owners have put a lot of effort into making sure this vacation property is family-friendly, beautiful, restful, spacious, tranquil and easy to relax in. Even the landscaping and general outside ambiance is beyond lovely. The Kitchen is well-stocked and the dining room is welcoming. This means that cooking a family dinner, baking a cake, or enjoying summer board games just comes naturally. This home contains exactly what our family loved about visits to the East End when we were growing up.There is a quick walk to the beach. And, on a clear night, the large bedroom windows look right up into the western sky, so that one can see the stars quite clearly. Better yet, during a nap on a summers' afternoon, one can look out the windows and watch the clouds go by. That is precisely what July & August vacations are for! Beach-going, Cloud-watching, star-gazing, ......and PLAY!Children of all ages will love the large bin in the backyard which has boogie boards and other beach equipment. "The adults" can make delicious food on the grill. But then, maybe, all food is delicious after a hike and a swim in the Long Island Sound? We'll definitely be back next year to study this important theory. Wild horses couldn't keep us away.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(1 Rating)
"This is a comfortable, clean, well-appointed home with every consideration thought through, and implemented by the hosts.The owners have put a lot of effort into making sure this vacation property is..."
Ali K.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
