Lake Michigan Retreat | Private Beach & Lawn

Summary:

Welcome to the Lake Michigan Retreat, a beautifully renovated historic lakefront escape set on 2.5 private acres overlooking Lake Michigan. With 7 bedrooms, 500+ feet of private beach, gorgeous views, and a separate 2-bedroom guest suite, this one-of-a-kind home was made for truly unforgettable getaways on the lakeshore.



Located conveniently to many destinations, the home has easy access to the nearby towns of South Haven, Benton Harbor, Coloma, and St. Joe's, all less than 20 minutes away.



The Space:

With a history tracing back to the Roaring Twenties, our Lake Michigan Retreat blends remarkable 1920s character with new renovations and coastal comfort. Long associated through local lore with having been built and owned by Al Capone, the home features elaborate woodwork sourced from two grand residences in Chicago’s historic Gold Coast, along with rich hardwood floors, intricate millwork, and beautifully preserved period details. Expansive windows frame stunning Lake Michigan views, while elegant gathering spaces and seven spacious bedrooms provide an exceptional setting for time together.



Outside, you'll have multiple private lakefront acres perched on the bluff overlooking Lake Michigan. A spacious lawn and outdoor space invites everything from sunny afternoons by the water to dinner overlooking the lake and evenings gathered together beneath sunsets. Newly constructed stairs lead directly from the bluff down to 500+ feet of private beach, creating an extraordinary setting for swimming, shoreline walks, and long days with your toes in the sand.



**For wedding inquiries and any events, please contact us prior to booking. There is a $10K minimum venue fee in addition to lodging**



Why Guests Love The Lake Michigan Retreat

🌊 More than 500+ feet of private Lake Michigan beach for swimming, sunbathing, shoreline walks, and days on the water (newly constructed stairs lead directly down to the water's edge)

🌳 Expansive 2.5-acre, tree-lined setting offering incredible privacy along the Lake Michigan bluff

🌅 Stunning lakeside sunset views throughout the home and outdoor living spaces

🔥 Large lakefront lawn with a firepit for evenings together overlooking the water

🌿 Multiple decks with outdoor dining, lounge seating, a grill, and incredible views

✨ Top-floor master suite with a sitting area, ensuite bathroom, stunning vistas, and private deck access

🏡 Separate, completely renovated two-bedroom guest suite on the lower-level with its own private exterior entrance, full kitchen, living room, and dining area

🎹 Gathering spaces filled with historic character, including a baby grand piano

🍳 Renovated main kitchen with a large island and breakfast bar, plus a second full kitchen in the guest suite



Accommodations 🛏️ (7 private bedrooms, including the lower level guest suite)

• The top-floor master suite features a king bed, private sitting area, ensuite bathroom, stunning Lake Michigan views, and private deck access

• The second bedroom features a king bed, dedicated workspace, and beautiful Lake Michigan views

• The third bedroom features a queen bed surrounded by classic style and gorgeous lake views

• The fourth bedroom features an antique iron double bed and charming historic character

• The fifth bedroom offers a queen bed and twin bed, providing flexible sleeping space for up to three guests

• The lower-level guest suite includes the sixth and seventh bedrooms (queen bed and twin-over-double bunk bed, respectively)

• Multiple full bathrooms throughout the home include spacious walk-in showers for added convenience



The Guest Suite 🏡

• Completely renovated two-bedroom lower-level guest suite accessed through its own private exterior entrance

• Open-concept living room with comfortable seating, a piano, and Smart TV

• Full kitchen with stainless steel appliances and generous counter space

• Breakfast bar seating and separate dining area

• Queen bedroom plus a second bedroom with a twin-over-double bunk bed

• Full bathroom with a walk-in shower

• A private space ideal for extended families or groups who want to stay together while enjoying a little extra room and independence



Kitchen & Dining 🍳

• Renovated main floor kitchen with stainless steel appliances and generous counter space

• Large center island and breakfast bar seating for casual meals and gathering while dinner is prepared

• Formal dining room with seating for eight and beautiful Lake Michigan views

• Lower-level guest suite features its own full kitchen with stainless steel appliances

• Guest suite breakfast bar and dining table provide additional space for meals and morning coffee



📍 Nearby Attractions

• Lake Michigan – steps from your front door, with direct shoreline access via the property’s private stairs

• DiMaggio’s Pizza & Burgers – 5 minutes • casual local favorite for pizza, burgers, and sandwiches

• Hagar Park & Beach – 6 minutes • scenic Lake Michigan beach with stair access, a playground, and shaded picnic areas

• Kathy’s Riverside Tavern – 6 minutes • laid-back neighborhood tavern known for burgers and classic bar food

• Downtown Coloma – 9 minutes • welcoming small-town downtown with local restaurants and shops

• El Asadero – 9 minutes • Mexican restaurant in downtown Coloma serving tacos, fajitas, burritos, and other favorites

• Lake Michigan Hills Golf Club – 9 minutes • scenic public golf course with rolling terrain and a challenging layout

• Easy Street Inn Food & Spirits – 9 minutes • casual hometown restaurant serving American comfort food, burgers, sandwiches, and hearty dinners

• Contessa Wine Cellars – 11 minutes • Italian villa-inspired tasting room with a terrace overlooking orchards and the Coloma Valley

• Fruit Acres Farm Market & U-Pick – 11 minutes • seasonal farm market and U-pick experiences featuring cherries, peaches, and apples

• Benton Harbor Arts District – 12 minutes • creative downtown destination with galleries, studios, local restaurants, and arts venues

• Filkins Vineyards – 12 minutes • scenic winery with a welcoming tasting room, outdoor seating, and panoramic vineyard views

• Jollay Orchards – 14 minutes • family-owned orchard offering seasonal U-pick fruit, farm-market treats, and family activities

• St. Joseph – 14 minutes • lively lakeside town with downtown boutiques, restaurants, Silver Beach, a carousel, and historic lighthouses

• South Haven – 19 minutes • classic Lake Michigan beach town with shops, restaurants, sandy beaches, and its iconic red lighthouse



Guest Access:

Guests have access to the entire home, private outdoor living spaces, 2.5-acre grounds, and more than 500 feet of private Lake Michigan frontage. The lower-level guest suite is accessed separately through its own private exterior entrance, providing additional privacy for guests staying in that portion of the home.



The Neighborhood:

Perched along a private bluff, our Lake Michigan Retreat offers a secluded lakeshore setting surrounded by expansive natural grounds. Spend your days along your own private shoreline, then explore the beaches, restaurants, wineries, shops, and waterfront communities of Southwest Michigan, including nearby South Haven, Coloma, St. Joseph, and Benton Harbor.



Getting Around:

A vehicle is recommended for exploring the local wineries, restaurants, shops, and other Southwest Michigan attractions.



Other Things to Note:

The Lake Michigan Retreat is a truly special historic home, and we invite guests to enjoy everything that makes this Lake Michigan property so unique. Spend your days on the private beach, take in the sunsets, and make lasting memories while treating the home, its historic details, and surrounding grounds with care and respect.



We strictly do not allow smoking or parties. Any weddings or events must be pre-approved prior to booking. There is a $10K minimum venue fee in addition to lodging for weddings.