House in Key Colony Beach, FL
4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Welcome to Keys to the Sea! This private gem offers an escape with stunning open water views on both sides. Immerse in Key Colony Beach waking to sunrises and winding down with sunsets. Relax by the palm tree watching boats glide by; embrace the tropical vibe. Boating is a breeze with lift and dock. Guests have exclusive Cabana Club access for poolside relaxation or ocean dips. Walk to Sunset Park, dinner and embrace the Keys. Book your stay for a blend of luxury, relaxation and natural beauty!
Welcome to Keys to the Sea, your perfect retreat in Key Colony Beach!
***Please note that Key Colony Beach requires a minimum booking of 7 days***
If booked, check out our sister property next-door - Keys to the Sea & Cabana Club - Seahorse.
Need more space? Reach out about booking both Seahorse and Sea Turtle for 4 total bedrooms!
As you step into our charming two-bedroom, two-bathroom vacation home, you`ll be greeted by an inviting open floor-plan seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining area, and a cozy leather couch living/TV room overlooking the breathtaking views of Shelter Bay. Step outside to discover a fenced-in grass yard, offering a serene space to unwind beneath the swaying palm trees.
For outdoor enthusiasts, our property provides direct access to a beautiful dock where you can enjoy fishing, bird watching, and the possibility of spotting playful manatees and dolphins!
Don`t miss our sunrises from our backyard and sunsets from the front yard!
Boaters will appreciate dockage for up to a 40` LOA Boat! There is also a brand-new bait freezer for your next fishing adventure!
Keys to the Sea offers 2 bedrooms and can accommodate up to 4 guests! We also have 2 bedrooms and 2 baths next door so bring your family!
The primary bedroom offers a tranquil escape with its water views, queen bed, private entrance, ensuite bathroom, and ample closet space. In the second bedroom, we cater to the preferences of our guests—option for two Twin XL beds OR we can combine the beds into a sumptuous King bed. Each bedroom is equipped with a dedicated split AC and ceiling fans, ensuring your comfort during your stay.
When booking, please let us know your preference for the secondary bedroom layout—2 Twin XLs or the luxurious King bed. We look forward to hosting you at Keys to the Sea, where relaxation and enjoyment meet the beauty of Key Colony Beach!
You will have access to the full house, backyard and washer/dryer. Guests will also have access to dock and boatslip with amazing views of Bonefish Bay. All guests will also have access to the world famous Cabana Club! The Cabana Club, Your Private Keys Swim Club, has a 65` pool, hot tub, private sandy beach. Relax in the pool while staff bring your Pina Coladas or wade out into the amazing Atlantic Ocean!
Key Colony Beach (KCB) is a charming and relaxed community that attracts those seeking a quieter and more intimate experience in the Florida Keys. Its proximity to both Key West and the mainland makes it a convenient yet serene destination. Its close to Marathon with access to grocery stores, great restaurants and beaches, yet KCB is removed, quiet and calm to feel a world away!
Key Colony Beach is very walkable, with a few restaurants and of course the Cabana Club only a few minutes walk away! Marathon is right there with larger stores and more fabulous restaurants!
Welcome to Keys to the Sea, your perfect retreat in Key Colony Beach!
***Please note that Key Colony Beach requires a minimum booking of 7 days***
If booked, check out our sister property next-door - Keys to the Sea & Cabana Club - Seahorse.
Need more space? Reach out about booking both Seahorse and Sea Turtle for 4 total bedrooms!
As you step into our charming two-bedroom, two-bathroom vacation home, you`ll be greeted by an inviting open floor-plan seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining area, and a cozy leather couch living/TV room overlooking the breathtaking views of Shelter Bay. Step outside to discover a fenced-in grass yard, offering a serene space to unwind beneath the swaying palm trees.
For outdoor enthusiasts, our property provides direct access to a beautiful dock where you can enjoy fishing, bird watching, and the possibility of spotting playful manatees and dolphins!
Don`t miss our sunrises from our backyard and sunsets from the front yard!
Boaters will appreciate dockage for up to a 40` LOA Boat! There is also a brand-new bait freezer for your next fishing adventure!
Keys to the Sea offers 2 bedrooms and can accommodate up to 4 guests! We also have 2 bedrooms and 2 baths next door so bring your family!
The primary bedroom offers a tranquil escape with its water views, queen bed, private entrance, ensuite bathroom, and ample closet space. In the second bedroom, we cater to the preferences of our guests—option for two Twin XL beds OR we can combine the beds into a sumptuous King bed. Each bedroom is equipped with a dedicated split AC and ceiling fans, ensuring your comfort during your stay.
When booking, please let us know your preference for the secondary bedroom layout—2 Twin XLs or the luxurious King bed. We look forward to hosting you at Keys to the Sea, where relaxation and enjoyment meet the beauty of Key Colony Beach!
You will have access to the full house, backyard and washer/dryer. Guests will also have access to dock and boatslip with amazing views of Bonefish Bay. All guests will also have access to the world famous Cabana Club! The Cabana Club, Your Private Keys Swim Club, has a 65` pool, hot tub, private sandy beach. Relax in the pool while staff bring your Pina Coladas or wade out into the amazing Atlantic Ocean!
Key Colony Beach (KCB) is a charming and relaxed community that attracts those seeking a quieter and more intimate experience in the Florida Keys. Its proximity to both Key West and the mainland makes it a convenient yet serene destination. Its close to Marathon with access to grocery stores, great restaurants and beaches, yet KCB is removed, quiet and calm to feel a world away!
Key Colony Beach is very walkable, with a few restaurants and of course the Cabana Club only a few minutes walk away! Marathon is right there with larger stores and more fabulous restaurants!
Amenities at Keys to the Sea + Cabana Club!
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Key Colony Beach, FL
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2026
The floor plan is a little awkward, but overall, everything was as described. Access to the beach club was a very nice feature. The house was clean. Check-in was easy, and the owner was quick to respond to questions. The kids enjoyed fishing off the dock and caught lots of species of fish.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(1 Rating)
"The floor plan is a little awkward, but overall, everything was as described. Access to the beach club was a very nice feature. The house was clean. Check-in was easy, and the owner was quick to respo..."
Sarah U.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
