Apartment in Fire Island, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this apartment rental
Memories are waiting to be made at this lovely 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom Bay Shore vacation rental. The delightful apartment offers a well-stocked kitchen, inviting furnishings, 4 Smart TVs, a shared, fenced backyard, and even an additional vacation rental on-site for larger groups. Explore the hiking trails in Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve, share laughs at Schmitt’s Family Farm, or learn about the history of the gilded age at the Museum of American Armor.
-- THE PROPERTY --
Modern, Inviting Furnishings | Smart TV in Each Bedroom | Free Shared WiFi (880-940 Mbps)
SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS
- Bedroom 1: 1 king bed
- Bedroom 2: 1 queen bed
- Bedroom 3: 1 queen bed
INDOOR LIVING
- 4 Smart TVs w/ cable & Netflix, 3 laptop-friendly workspaces & modern furnishings
KITCHEN
- Dishwasher, refrigerator, oven, 4-burner stovetop & microwave
- Drip coffee maker, blender, toaster, ice maker & water filter
- Dishware/flatware & cooking basics
GENERAL
- Free shared WiFi, central heating & A/C
- Linens/towels, complimentary toiletries, iron/board, hair dryer & hangers
- Trash bags & paper towels
SHARED AMENITIES
- Fenced backyard, washer & dryer (accessed via yard)
ACCESSIBILITY
- 2nd-floor apartment, stairs required to access
PARKING
- Driveway (2 vehicles, tandem parked)
ADDT’L ACCOMMODATIONS
- An additional 1-bedroom property for 4 guests is available on-site w/ a separate nightly rate. If you would like to reserve both rentals, please inquire for more information prior to booking
-- THE LOCATION --
- HOT SPOTS: The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia (4 miles), Seatuck Environmental Association (5 miles), American Airpower Museum (11 miles), Museum of American Armor (14 miles) & Fire Island Lighthouse (14 miles)
- ESCAPE TO NATURE: Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve (4 miles), Shipwreck Cove Spray Park (5 miles), Islip Beach (6 miles), Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve (7 miles) & Sweet Briar Nature Center (11 miles)
- FUN FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY: Tanger Outlets Deer Park (3 miles), Xplore Commack (4 miles), Monster Mini Golf (4 miles), The Adventure Park at Long Island (8 miles), Schmitt's Family Farm (11 miles) & Adventureland (13 miles)
- AIRPORTS: 33 miles to John F. Kennedy International Airport & 38 miles to LaGuardia Airport
-- REST EASY WITH US --
Evolve makes it easy to find and book properties you'll never want to leave. You can relax knowing that our properties will always be ready for you and that we'll answer the phone 24/7. Even better, if anything is off about your stay, we'll make it right. You can count on our homes and our people to make you feel welcome — because we know what vacation means to you.
-- POLICIES --
HOUSE RULES
- No smoking, vaping, or cannabis use permitted anywhere on the property
- No pets allowed
- Strict max occupancy of 6 guests
- Visitors permitted w/ prior Guest Contact approval
- No events, parties, or large gatherings of any kind
- Quiet hours (10:00 PM-8:00 AM)
- Photo ID may be required upon check-in
- Additional fees and taxes may apply
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
- Another bookable vacation rental on-site; laundry, WiFi & outdoor amenities are shared (other travelers may be present)
- Garage & shed not available for guest use
SECURITY CAMERA INFORMATION
- 4 exterior devices
- Location: front door, garage, side door, yard gate
- Coverage: front entry, basement entry, yard & street
-- THE PROPERTY --
Modern, Inviting Furnishings | Smart TV in Each Bedroom | Free Shared WiFi (880-940 Mbps)
SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS
- Bedroom 1: 1 king bed
- Bedroom 2: 1 queen bed
- Bedroom 3: 1 queen bed
INDOOR LIVING
- 4 Smart TVs w/ cable & Netflix, 3 laptop-friendly workspaces & modern furnishings
KITCHEN
- Dishwasher, refrigerator, oven, 4-burner stovetop & microwave
- Drip coffee maker, blender, toaster, ice maker & water filter
- Dishware/flatware & cooking basics
GENERAL
- Free shared WiFi, central heating & A/C
- Linens/towels, complimentary toiletries, iron/board, hair dryer & hangers
- Trash bags & paper towels
SHARED AMENITIES
- Fenced backyard, washer & dryer (accessed via yard)
ACCESSIBILITY
- 2nd-floor apartment, stairs required to access
PARKING
- Driveway (2 vehicles, tandem parked)
ADDT’L ACCOMMODATIONS
- An additional 1-bedroom property for 4 guests is available on-site w/ a separate nightly rate. If you would like to reserve both rentals, please inquire for more information prior to booking
-- THE LOCATION --
- HOT SPOTS: The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia (4 miles), Seatuck Environmental Association (5 miles), American Airpower Museum (11 miles), Museum of American Armor (14 miles) & Fire Island Lighthouse (14 miles)
- ESCAPE TO NATURE: Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve (4 miles), Shipwreck Cove Spray Park (5 miles), Islip Beach (6 miles), Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve (7 miles) & Sweet Briar Nature Center (11 miles)
- FUN FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY: Tanger Outlets Deer Park (3 miles), Xplore Commack (4 miles), Monster Mini Golf (4 miles), The Adventure Park at Long Island (8 miles), Schmitt's Family Farm (11 miles) & Adventureland (13 miles)
- AIRPORTS: 33 miles to John F. Kennedy International Airport & 38 miles to LaGuardia Airport
-- REST EASY WITH US --
Evolve makes it easy to find and book properties you'll never want to leave. You can relax knowing that our properties will always be ready for you and that we'll answer the phone 24/7. Even better, if anything is off about your stay, we'll make it right. You can count on our homes and our people to make you feel welcome — because we know what vacation means to you.
-- POLICIES --
HOUSE RULES
- No smoking, vaping, or cannabis use permitted anywhere on the property
- No pets allowed
- Strict max occupancy of 6 guests
- Visitors permitted w/ prior Guest Contact approval
- No events, parties, or large gatherings of any kind
- Quiet hours (10:00 PM-8:00 AM)
- Photo ID may be required upon check-in
- Additional fees and taxes may apply
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
- Another bookable vacation rental on-site; laundry, WiFi & outdoor amenities are shared (other travelers may be present)
- Garage & shed not available for guest use
SECURITY CAMERA INFORMATION
- 4 exterior devices
- Location: front door, garage, side door, yard gate
- Coverage: front entry, basement entry, yard & street
Amenities at Bay Shore Vacation Rental w/ Shared Yard!
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Fire Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
Great place. great communication. Couldn't have been better
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
My family and had an amazing stay for the holiday week
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2024
Very comfortable for a family vacation. Clean and nice home. Had great communication with the property manager.
6 / 10Average·Jan 2026
Lack of Amenities: no broom, no swiffer, no snow shovel no snow brush, no snow salt. No access to laundry room. False ad stated whole house w/washer and dryer turns out it was an upstairs 2nd floor apartment with permanent tenants living downstairs that lied and complained on the very first night stating us adults were awake at 3am making noise when in fact we were so tired from all the holidays to do’s and travels that once we picked up the last traveler from the airport at midnight we were all showered exhausted all sleeping-house quiet by 12:30am Let’s not to forget to mention the only child in that home is a six-year-old that goes to bed by nature daily by 8 PM!! Sharp!! we got snowed in pretty badly and had no amenities whatsoever to clean up to get out safely one adult in crutches fresh post op from surgery we were all very concerned had to cancel our paid planned events-reached out to the host whom promised that night that in the morning, a snow company would come to clean up the property and salt down for safety when I reached out the following morning to the host she seem bothered attitude told us to deal with customer service. Thankfully, we got a very helpful representative-promptly reached out to the host and by late that afternoon we had a snow removal crew come and clean up the property as it was indeed her duty as the owner.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(15 Ratings)
"Great place. great communication. Couldn't have been better"
James C.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
