History By Day Heaven By Night Waterfront Pool Oasis, Kayaks/Bikes Make Memories

Top rated by guests
Beautiful, Private, Backyard Oasis
Fully Stocked Kitchen
Open kitchen for conversation and view.
Pool
Seating area and firepit with palm coverage for shade.
review stars
10Outstanding
(99 Ratings)
"Ginny was very communicative, friendly and helpful. The house was spotless and so welcoming when we arrived. Beds, linens and pillows were so comfortable. House was supplied with everything you cou..."
Monica C.
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
10 / 10
Outstanding(99 Ratings)

House in Butler Beach, FL

8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area

About this house rental

Want a mix of your toes in the sand during the day and restaurants galore at night with a little history mixed in? Come visit the Nation's Oldest City! Enjoy the unmatchable variety of activities during the day and return for a swim in the large private pool, enjoy games in the gameroom, a kayak adventure or soak in the hot tub by sunset to relax the nights away.

Perfect vacation found at Reel Treasure St Augustine! Canal front, private pool, spa & outdoor oasis complete with seating areas under decks and palms, kayaks, bikes, fishing and game room all within a short walk, drive or bike ride to the beach. Situated for stunning sunsets nightly.

As private owners. our goal is to give our guests exactly what we want for our own personal guests and family, a home away to forge lasting memories with your loved ones. We strive to and truly enjoy providing a space where you can relax, unwind and make the most out of your precious vacation time.

Our community has a private beach access within walking/biking distance (.3 miles) or you can drive on the beach and pick your spot. Cooking is wonderful in our fully updated kitchen or enjoy many of the wonderful local restaurants of the area.

Enjoy watching beautiful sunsets on either of two decks or while relaxing in the hot tub while being on one of the very few canals in St Augustine.

Our home is a wonderful place for a family vacation.

Where you will sleep:

Bedroom 1: King Bed, 1st floor, full bathroom just outside of bedroom, private door to deck by pool and outdoor oasis.

Bedroom 2: King Bed, 2nd floor with full ensuite bathroom and private deck sitting area overlooking pool and canal.

Bedroom 3: Queen Bed, 2nd floor, full bathroom in hallway shared with bedroom 4.

Bedroom 4: Queen Bed, 2nd floor, full bathroom in hallway shared with bedroom 3.

We love families and our home is wonderful for families with older children with all the great amenities inside as well as right outside the front and back doors. However It is not optimal for families with young children as it is not childproofed and the pool and canal are right outside the back door. Please contact us through an inquiry or an email to discuss whether or not Reel Treasure will be a good fit for your family before requesting to book.

Please review all requirements in house rules and expectations before booking.

No Extra Guests on Property:
For insurance purposes, only guests on the reservation are permitted on the property at any time unless prior approval is given and names added to reservation.
Immediate cancellation without refund for not adhering to this policy. We take this very seriously for your safety, our neighbors' comfort and safety, and insurance purposes.

Dogs:
On a case by case basis, we allow up to two (2) dogs, from the same household, for an additional $100 cleaning fee PER DOG. Allowing dogs is at our discretion (size, breed, etc). Puppies under 12 months old are not permitted. Dogs cannot be left alone without a kennel and must always be with their human and on a leash at all times when outside. Dogs must be included in your booking request and registered at the time of your reservation and be included on the signed rental agreement. Guests with dogs will be required to agree to basic home pet care and good neighbor rules. Please ask to see these rules before booking if you would like to bring dogs.
If dogs are not added to your initial reservation, you will need to add them, re-sign rental agreement and fee will be collected.

Pool and Spa Heat:
Although we do not charge a pool heating fee, we keep the pool heated to 85° in the cooler months and the spa at 102°. As with any property that has electric pool and spa heat, pool and spa temperatures can not be maintained or guaranteed if temperatures drop below 55°.

*We have instant booking turned on. Please read all rules before booking and make sure you are comfortable. If you have any questions about anything in our listing, please feel free to submit an inquiry to get those answered before booking *

Cancellation Policy: Please review our cancellation policy as our calendar will be blocked once you make your reservation and as individual owners, we cannot afford to refund outside of our policy. *** Hurricane season is June-November every year. We especially encourage purchasing travel insurance for your trip if your reservation falls within these dates as we can only refund if there is an official, mandatory evacuation (not a state of emergency) called for the island. ***

Required within 24 hrs of booking: Signed rental agreement, $1500 refundable damage deposit, Photo Id (state issued driver’s license of primary renter, complete names of all adults on reservation, totaling no more than 8 people including any children all to be completed within 24 hours of reservation. The State issued driver’s license is required to be on file by our municipality.

Amenities at History By Day Heaven By Night Waterfront Pool Oasis, Kayaks/Bikes Make Memories

Non-smoking
Pets allowed

Map of Butler Beach, FL


Ratings and reviews

10 / 10
Outstanding(99 Ratings)
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Ginny was very communicative, friendly and helpful. The house was spotless and so welcoming when we arrived. Beds, linens and pillows were so comfortable. House was supplied with everything you could wish for and more! Lots of toys and games to play with- both in and out of the water! Pool and backyard were wonderful. Only thing I wished for was a handrail to get in and out of the hot tub. I wanted to get in and enjoy but could not get in without fear of falling! Absolutely great home and would highly recommend!
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
The house was exactly as listed. Very clean, great communication. Everything was lovely.
10 / 10Outstanding·Feb 2026
This house is absolutely beautiful! From the stunning interior design to the resort-style pool and spa, Reel Treasure is truly immaculate and exceptionally clean. Every detail has been thoughtfully considered. From the many games and books to the upscale shampoo, conditioner, and shower gel (no need to bring your own!).All the amenities you could think of and even ones you wouldn’t have thought of are provided. Ginny went above and beyond to make sure our needs were met, with fast and friendly communication for any questions we had.I truly can’t say enough about this wonderful experience and the comfort of this home. Do not hesitate! Book now!
10 / 10Outstanding·Feb 2026
Our family loves this home! It is beautifully decorated and maintained with lots of extras provided. Ginny is a very attentive and welcoming host as well! We plan to return again in the near future!

$$$$
expedia logo

FAQs

Is parking included with this house?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at History By Day Heaven By Night Waterfront Pool Oasis, Kayaks/Bikes Make Memories. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is History By Day Heaven By Night Waterfront Pool Oasis, Kayaks/Bikes Make Memories pet friendly?

Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at History By Day Heaven By Night Waterfront Pool Oasis, Kayaks/Bikes Make Memories?

We found 2 amenities for this rental. This includes non-smoking, and pets allowed.