House in New York
8 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
Love at first sight! Voted "the best view on the Bay" by longtime locals. Supreme sunrises flood light through a bank of windows overlooking the largest bay on Lake Ontario. Experience Mid Century charm with First Class amenities including: premium cable channels, ceiling fans throughout to catch the breezes, pillow-top beds with goose down pillows, top brand appliances & fixtures with vintage surprises such as an original Hamilton Beach blender in avocado green, of course, and Sunbeam Electric Can Opener.
The huge deck overlooking the bay and our garden descending to the waterfront features barstools, dining table and chairs; daylong shady and sunny patches.
Boat from our dock or drive to our favorite spots. Gastronomic delights such as homemade fruit pies, Imprint Coffee roasters, locals; 3 miles to historic Sodus Point with lifeguarded sandy beaches on the Bay and Lake Ontario; dining Key West style at Bay Street or burgers & barbecue with live music on the Bay at Captain Jacks; Waterfront dining around the Bay; Sunday concerts on the lawn of the historic Lighthouse museum on Lake Ontario; free outdoor movies on the baseball diamond with ice cream and 'hots' across the street. Tastings at breweries, wineries, and distilleries nearby and throughout the Finger Lakes region; Rochester offers world-renowned museums and art Galleries; endless dining choices... This area is renowned for its charming canal towns along the Erie River, which provide an enchanting day trip that will lead to the inimitable Niagara Falls with forever memories. Farmer's markets, price-conscious antiquing. Gorgeous hiking, biking and disc golf trails are ubiquitous throughout the county's waterways, parklands, orchards, and lanes lined with wildflowers.
Our classic 1952 lake cottage has been completely restored and updated, keeping the best of design enhanced with modern convenience. Adorned with period proper treasures: original Fitz and Floyd rattan sectional seating circa 1950, sea captain's trunk, nautical Rock Maple bedroom suites, Heywood Wakefield dining ensemble seats 10. New meets 20th century with original heart pine floors, an expansive Great Room with cathedral ceiling lit by a c.1949 French country chandelier and accented by a vast hand-built lake stone fireplace. Our gourmet kitchen features granite countertops and a breakfast bar with a convection oven, Cuisinart processor, KitchenAid mixer, coffee bean grinder, French press & traditional coffeemaker. Our two bathrooms showcase showers with tumbled marble, hi-gloss subway tile, glass block wall, glass shower door, and Kohler fixtures.
The spacious deck overlooking stunning Great Sodus Bay is the perfect gathering spot for morning coffee, bird watching, Happy Hour, barbecue, star gazing.. endless photo ops. What's not to love?
Keywords: Waterfront Home
The huge deck overlooking the bay and our garden descending to the waterfront features barstools, dining table and chairs; daylong shady and sunny patches.
Boat from our dock or drive to our favorite spots. Gastronomic delights such as homemade fruit pies, Imprint Coffee roasters, locals; 3 miles to historic Sodus Point with lifeguarded sandy beaches on the Bay and Lake Ontario; dining Key West style at Bay Street or burgers & barbecue with live music on the Bay at Captain Jacks; Waterfront dining around the Bay; Sunday concerts on the lawn of the historic Lighthouse museum on Lake Ontario; free outdoor movies on the baseball diamond with ice cream and 'hots' across the street. Tastings at breweries, wineries, and distilleries nearby and throughout the Finger Lakes region; Rochester offers world-renowned museums and art Galleries; endless dining choices... This area is renowned for its charming canal towns along the Erie River, which provide an enchanting day trip that will lead to the inimitable Niagara Falls with forever memories. Farmer's markets, price-conscious antiquing. Gorgeous hiking, biking and disc golf trails are ubiquitous throughout the county's waterways, parklands, orchards, and lanes lined with wildflowers.
Our classic 1952 lake cottage has been completely restored and updated, keeping the best of design enhanced with modern convenience. Adorned with period proper treasures: original Fitz and Floyd rattan sectional seating circa 1950, sea captain's trunk, nautical Rock Maple bedroom suites, Heywood Wakefield dining ensemble seats 10. New meets 20th century with original heart pine floors, an expansive Great Room with cathedral ceiling lit by a c.1949 French country chandelier and accented by a vast hand-built lake stone fireplace. Our gourmet kitchen features granite countertops and a breakfast bar with a convection oven, Cuisinart processor, KitchenAid mixer, coffee bean grinder, French press & traditional coffeemaker. Our two bathrooms showcase showers with tumbled marble, hi-gloss subway tile, glass block wall, glass shower door, and Kohler fixtures.
The spacious deck overlooking stunning Great Sodus Bay is the perfect gathering spot for morning coffee, bird watching, Happy Hour, barbecue, star gazing.. endless photo ops. What's not to love?
Keywords: Waterfront Home
Amenities at Autumn is Spectacular! Luxury Waterfront Sodus Bay, dogs welcome
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
Lovely spot for a relaxing get away. We spent several days going to the Finger Lakes for wine and cider tasteing and the rest chilling on the deck. Local family visited and everyone enjoyed swimming and floating in the bay. The local Sodus Point beach was a nice change and uncrowded.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
The owners were very responsive to our needs. Great vacation. Steps were a challenge for grand parents.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2024
We loved the view of the bay! The house was lovely.
6 / 10Average·Sep 2022
I just want to list out the facts here. Pros: great location，close to beach for sunset; easy access to lake; great for sunrise; charming house; have tons of cooking equipment; close to Niagara Falls and finger lakes. Cons: the house hasn’t been taken cared of carefully. generally not clean, smells, lots of bugs in the small bathroom and the sink is clogged. One bathroom door was accidentally locked and 7 of us had to share one tiny bathroom until the owner responded to us 11 hours later . Neighbor’s big dogs leashed free came to the front door and backyard deck. We were terrified since we don’t know them. One of them pooped right by the entrance, the owner did not proactively think a way to clean it up even though they seems lived minutes away from the house or knows the owner of the dog. At least do something. The backyard stairs to the lake wiggles a lot and very slippery. There is a safety concern. No access to washer and dryer which is not convenient.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(50 Ratings)
"Lovely spot for a relaxing get away. We spent several days going to the Finger Lakes for wine and cider tasteing and the rest chilling on the deck. Local family visited and everyone enjoyed swimming..."
Phyllis E.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
