House in New York
12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
Step back in time and call our large,1880's Carriage House your chosen spot for some family time! We raised our 5 daughters in this expansive home and love to share our unique home with guests.
Lovingly updated and restored with all the amenities of home including central air conditioning,a chefs kitchen with high-end appliances, 2 dishwashers, 6 burner gas stove and double oven.
Our home has a total of 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths for you. Three bedrooms are located on the first floor and then our Game Room downstairs offers sleeping areas for all the cousins! The home has ducted heat, central AC and a lovely fireplace that is professionally maintained every year.
The house offers 2800 sq ft of space which includes a 1200+ sq ft Great Room with plenty of seating for guests, a wood burning fireplace,game board center/second dining area, large smart television with DVD, and Netflix etc.
There is an eat-in kitchen with large table that can seat 10-12+.
A large wooden fold out table is also available for Holiday or large family dinners to extend the table or create a large eating space in the Great Room.
The large Game Room in the finished basement hosts a gas fireplace, TV/DVD, foosball table, darts, air hockey, a sleeper sofa with upgraded mattress and sleeping areas for the kids (or adults). The Game Room features two full size beds,a twin trundle bed and a queen sleeper sofa bed. When we are home, we have all the kids and Teens sleep here :) They are loud and we can't hear them from upstairs :) :)
A fully fenced yard with doggy door, an in-ground pool with extensive decking, a 4 person hot tub, a campfire pit and propane grill are provided outside.
Plenty of parking for up to 6+ vehicles plus street parking.
The Carriage House is located in the Village of Palmyra close to all village amenities and a 5 minute drive to Hill Cumorah (4 miles) and all LDS sites. Short 15 minutes to the Finger Lakes and 20 minute drive to all the Rochester area has to offer. We are 6 minutes from I-90.
Bedrooms are as follows:
Bedroom #1- Master bedroom with Queen Bed and crib. Main full bath with bathtub attached.
Bedroom #2- Double bed with twin trundle and a pack-n-play.
Bedroom #3- Queen bed and en-suite full bath, with shower.
Bedroom #4- Game Room Area- Pull out queen sofa bed, 2 full beds, 2 twin beds.
Our goal is for the home to be a comfortable gathering place for your family to relax and connect with each other. The Carriage House comfortably fits at least 2/3 families.
We keep this home very clean and clean ALL linens & ALL bedding after each guest. We supply all laundry supplies, paper products, dish tabs, dish soap, kitchen wipes, baggies, foil, spices, basic cooking items ( flour, sugar, oil etc) trash bags and pool toys for you during your stay. Just bring your food and relax!!!
* Please note that the carriage house is a duplex. You will occupy the first floor and the finished basement . That is approximately 2800 square feet . The upper apartment on the property is occupied by our daughter and her pup. This apartment is completely separate from the carriage house rental space with no shared services, or space. It has a private entrance. She helps us take care of the property and our guests and it works out perfectly.
Yes the house is very, very large :)
Lovingly updated and restored with all the amenities of home including central air conditioning,a chefs kitchen with high-end appliances, 2 dishwashers, 6 burner gas stove and double oven.
Our home has a total of 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths for you. Three bedrooms are located on the first floor and then our Game Room downstairs offers sleeping areas for all the cousins! The home has ducted heat, central AC and a lovely fireplace that is professionally maintained every year.
The house offers 2800 sq ft of space which includes a 1200+ sq ft Great Room with plenty of seating for guests, a wood burning fireplace,game board center/second dining area, large smart television with DVD, and Netflix etc.
There is an eat-in kitchen with large table that can seat 10-12+.
A large wooden fold out table is also available for Holiday or large family dinners to extend the table or create a large eating space in the Great Room.
The large Game Room in the finished basement hosts a gas fireplace, TV/DVD, foosball table, darts, air hockey, a sleeper sofa with upgraded mattress and sleeping areas for the kids (or adults). The Game Room features two full size beds,a twin trundle bed and a queen sleeper sofa bed. When we are home, we have all the kids and Teens sleep here :) They are loud and we can't hear them from upstairs :) :)
A fully fenced yard with doggy door, an in-ground pool with extensive decking, a 4 person hot tub, a campfire pit and propane grill are provided outside.
Plenty of parking for up to 6+ vehicles plus street parking.
The Carriage House is located in the Village of Palmyra close to all village amenities and a 5 minute drive to Hill Cumorah (4 miles) and all LDS sites. Short 15 minutes to the Finger Lakes and 20 minute drive to all the Rochester area has to offer. We are 6 minutes from I-90.
Bedrooms are as follows:
Bedroom #1- Master bedroom with Queen Bed and crib. Main full bath with bathtub attached.
Bedroom #2- Double bed with twin trundle and a pack-n-play.
Bedroom #3- Queen bed and en-suite full bath, with shower.
Bedroom #4- Game Room Area- Pull out queen sofa bed, 2 full beds, 2 twin beds.
Our goal is for the home to be a comfortable gathering place for your family to relax and connect with each other. The Carriage House comfortably fits at least 2/3 families.
We keep this home very clean and clean ALL linens & ALL bedding after each guest. We supply all laundry supplies, paper products, dish tabs, dish soap, kitchen wipes, baggies, foil, spices, basic cooking items ( flour, sugar, oil etc) trash bags and pool toys for you during your stay. Just bring your food and relax!!!
* Please note that the carriage house is a duplex. You will occupy the first floor and the finished basement . That is approximately 2800 square feet . The upper apartment on the property is occupied by our daughter and her pup. This apartment is completely separate from the carriage house rental space with no shared services, or space. It has a private entrance. She helps us take care of the property and our guests and it works out perfectly.
Yes the house is very, very large :)
Amenities at Cumorah Carriage House-Hot Tub,Pool,Game Room, Family Fun!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Our large group was about to stay here comfortably. The kids loved the pool and small hot tub! The air hockey machine was a big hit too. The hosts were quick to respond to our communications while we were there. The house is an older house, but it is close to the sites we visited. We would stay here again!
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2026
This delightfully unique house was perfect for our large family. Plenty of (comfortable!) beds and lots of spaces to hang out. The kitchen was well stocked (a crockpot, skillets, and plenty of spices) and we loved all the games and things to do. The hot tub was pretty small but our kids still enjoyed it. Plus it’s just a fun house with all the history. Our only real issue is that the owner’s daughter lives directly above. It’s a separate entrance, and she didn’t seem to be home most of the time (and when we did see her she was quite friendly!) but either she or her dog walked around all night- and the house is extremely creaky and noisy. I’d recommend ear plugs; even with a white noise app going those of us who slept on the main floor didn’t get much sleep. (Those in the basement were fine.) With ear plugs I’m sure it would have been fine. Owners were wonderful and we really did enjoy the house; we’d stay here again with proper preparation.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Beautiful home walking distance from the middle of Palmyra. Lots of room for everyone, and a beautiful kitchen. The teens loved the pool and hot tub. The hosts were great. Every detail was considered. I felt like a guest in their treasured home. I highly recommend to families visiting the area!
6 / 10Average·Jul 2026
Clean house, great location, but the pool was unusable while we were there. A month before my stay I tried to adjust my checkout day to one day early and the host never responded. Tried again a couple of weeks later, and still nothing. I would love to recommend this property as it was just what we wanted, but can't quite do it.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(15 Ratings)
"Our large group was about to stay here comfortably. The kids loved the pool and small hot tub! The air hockey machine was a big hit too. The hosts were quick to respond to our communications while we ..."
Tiffany H.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
