House in Penn Yan, NY
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Step back in time at this beautifully restored Victorian home in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country, where classic charm meets modern comfort — and where staying feels a bit like stepping onto the set of the movie "It’s a Wonderful Life." Located just minutes from the Seneca and Keuka Lake wine and beer trails, and within walking distance to shops, dining, and nightlife in downtown Penn Yan, this home offers the rare combination of history, space, and unbeatable walkability.
Comfortably sleeping a larger group, the home is especially well suited for girls’ weekends, family gatherings, and relaxed group getaways, with plenty of room to gather and unwind.
>> Why Guests Love this Victorian Home:
- Walk to Penn Yan shops, restaurants, wine bars, and nightlife
- Private hot tub for relaxing evenings
- Fire pit, grill, rear patio, and front porch for outdoor living
- Large private yard
- Minutes to Seneca & Keuka Lake wine and beer trails
- Two parlors ideal for group conversations
- Large eat-in kitchen perfect for shared meals
- Fireplace and beautifully refinished original hardwood floors
- Two stairways that add to the home’s historic character
>>Other things to note:
Interested in enhancing your stay? We can provide recommendations for local services to make your trip even more special. Please note that these services are arranged directly with local providers and have additional costs:
- In-cottage massages
- Private wine tours
- Kayak and canoe rentals
- Boat rentals
- Bike rentals
- Horseback riding
This cottage is part of the Savannah House Wine Country Inn and Cottages, so you'll enjoy the same level of hospitality and service that we've extended to all of our guests for almost 20 years!
*Pets are not allowed at this property. No exceptions.
Comfortably sleeping a larger group, the home is especially well suited for girls’ weekends, family gatherings, and relaxed group getaways, with plenty of room to gather and unwind.
>> Why Guests Love this Victorian Home:
- Walk to Penn Yan shops, restaurants, wine bars, and nightlife
- Private hot tub for relaxing evenings
- Fire pit, grill, rear patio, and front porch for outdoor living
- Large private yard
- Minutes to Seneca & Keuka Lake wine and beer trails
- Two parlors ideal for group conversations
- Large eat-in kitchen perfect for shared meals
- Fireplace and beautifully refinished original hardwood floors
- Two stairways that add to the home’s historic character
>>Other things to note:
Interested in enhancing your stay? We can provide recommendations for local services to make your trip even more special. Please note that these services are arranged directly with local providers and have additional costs:
- In-cottage massages
- Private wine tours
- Kayak and canoe rentals
- Boat rentals
- Bike rentals
- Horseback riding
This cottage is part of the Savannah House Wine Country Inn and Cottages, so you'll enjoy the same level of hospitality and service that we've extended to all of our guests for almost 20 years!
*Pets are not allowed at this property. No exceptions.
Amenities at It's A Wonderful Life -Main St Penn Yan-Hot Tub-Seneca/Keuka, Restored Victorian Home-Nightlife
Air conditioning
Non-smoking
Coffee/tea maker
Refridgerator
Kitchen
WiFi/Internet
Microwave
Dishwasher
Washing machine
Dryer
Patio
Kitchenware
No pets allowed
Oven
Stove
Laundry services
Bathtub
Ironing facilities
Towels
Hairdryer
Map of Penn Yan, NY
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Oct 2025
We absolutely loved our stay. Such a beautiful house. The attention to detail was appreciated. We felt like princesses in the beautiful tall, comfortable beds. The house was so well appointed. We enjoyed the hot tub, front porch, patio area and various sitting areas. We walked downtown for dinner which was amazing. Loved watching the Amish ride up and down the street on the fronch porch. Would highly recommend.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
The property was beautiful and just as depicted in photos. It was private and perfect for a ladies getaway. The host was very responsive and we had the best time.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Aug 2025
This was a girls weekend away (for ‘girls’ in their 60’s, 70’s and 90’s, lol). The home was absolutely lovely, with a lot of attention to details. We had a wonderful time! We would not hesitate to stay at this property again and highly recommended it. Please note that the beds and bedrooms are beautiful, and the beds are very high up off the ground. Step stools are provided and needed to get in and out of bed.
6.0 / 10.0Average·Aug 2022
Great property! Pat the local manager did not txt the passcode at 4:00. Had to call him several times to get an answer. Great place, need to have a more responsive point of contact for this amount $$ per night.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(40 Ratings)
"We absolutely loved our stay. Such a beautiful house. The attention to detail was appreciated. We felt like princesses in the beautiful tall, comfortable beds. The house was so well appointed. We enjo..."
Tammy K.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
