House in Cape May, NJ
23 guests · 7 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
The Judson Bennett House Iconic Victorian Elegance Meets Modern Luxury in the Heart of Cape May
Welcome to the Judson Bennett House, where historic charm meets high end vacation living all set on one of the most stunning, tree lined streets in Cape May’s celebrated Historic District. This beautifully restored Victorian showpiece offers everything you dream of in a coastal getaway: location, luxury, and unforgettable character.
From the moment you arrive, the home’s grand wrap around front porch sets the tone for your stay perfect for your morning coffee, afternoon reading, or evening cocktails as the ocean breeze drifts by. With rare off street parking for four vehicles, you can park your car and explore the town entirely on foot.
Step inside to a home that captures the best of “the old meets new.” The first floor is open, airy, and designed for gathering, PLEASE NOTE: the fireplace in the home is decorative only and NOT available for guest use. featuring a modern open concept kitchen and dining area that flows effortlessly ideal for entertaining, family meals, or simply enjoying a glass of wine while cooking together.
You’ll love the original architectural details from restored moldings and hardwood floors to the high ceilings and elegant lighting seamlessly blended with stylish, updated finishes throughout. The entire home has been lovingly renovated to provide all the comforts of a luxury vacation while preserving the timeless character of Cape May’s historic past.
When it’s time to unwind there is
A crackling fire pit for cozy nights under the stars
A refreshing outdoor shower the ultimate post beach indulgence
Thoughtfully designed landscaping for laid back lounging
Location! It doesn’t get better. You're just a short stroll to the Washington Street Mall, world class restaurants, coffee shops, galleries, and the unbeatable beaches that make Cape May so magical. Even better your rental includes access to a Beach Cabana, fully stocked with chairs and umbrellas, so your beach days are carefree and fabulous.
Please Note:
An owner expense fee applies to all rentals.
Blankets are not provided Linens NOT provided
Whether you're planning a week of relaxation or a weekend of adventure, the Judson Bennett House delivers a one of a kind experience full of heart, history, and high end comfort. Come and see why this home is one of Cape May’s most cherished treasures.
Welcome to the Judson Bennett House, where historic charm meets high end vacation living all set on one of the most stunning, tree lined streets in Cape May’s celebrated Historic District. This beautifully restored Victorian showpiece offers everything you dream of in a coastal getaway: location, luxury, and unforgettable character.
From the moment you arrive, the home’s grand wrap around front porch sets the tone for your stay perfect for your morning coffee, afternoon reading, or evening cocktails as the ocean breeze drifts by. With rare off street parking for four vehicles, you can park your car and explore the town entirely on foot.
Step inside to a home that captures the best of “the old meets new.” The first floor is open, airy, and designed for gathering, PLEASE NOTE: the fireplace in the home is decorative only and NOT available for guest use. featuring a modern open concept kitchen and dining area that flows effortlessly ideal for entertaining, family meals, or simply enjoying a glass of wine while cooking together.
You’ll love the original architectural details from restored moldings and hardwood floors to the high ceilings and elegant lighting seamlessly blended with stylish, updated finishes throughout. The entire home has been lovingly renovated to provide all the comforts of a luxury vacation while preserving the timeless character of Cape May’s historic past.
When it’s time to unwind there is
A crackling fire pit for cozy nights under the stars
A refreshing outdoor shower the ultimate post beach indulgence
Thoughtfully designed landscaping for laid back lounging
Location! It doesn’t get better. You're just a short stroll to the Washington Street Mall, world class restaurants, coffee shops, galleries, and the unbeatable beaches that make Cape May so magical. Even better your rental includes access to a Beach Cabana, fully stocked with chairs and umbrellas, so your beach days are carefree and fabulous.
Please Note:
An owner expense fee applies to all rentals.
Blankets are not provided Linens NOT provided
Whether you're planning a week of relaxation or a weekend of adventure, the Judson Bennett House delivers a one of a kind experience full of heart, history, and high end comfort. Come and see why this home is one of Cape May’s most cherished treasures.
Amenities at Judson Bennett House
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cape May, NJ
Ratings and reviews
8.0 / 10Excellent·Oct 2024
The house is beautiful, even better than the pictures. So much charm and character. Very well renovated with an eye to keeping the integrity of the original architecture. The location is ideal, close to town, restaurants, shopping, the beach, parks, everything. The rooms are nice, the beds themselves comfortable. The porch and decorations are fabulous. Loved sitting rocking on the porch watching people stroll by. Easy walking distance to The Washington Inn - best Espresso Martini I’ve ever had.
A few things need improvement, though overall they are small in comparison to the house itself, but unless someone notes it, it won’t get any better for the next renters, right?
1) You have to rent sheets and linens. Some kind of hotel tax law thing. It wouldn’t be a big deal if the sheets that the rentals agency provides would actually fit the bed and didn’t sound and feel like paper bags. Constantly having the sheets pulling off the corners on multiple beds was annoying and uncomfortable. So, my suggestion is don’t rent the sheets from Homestead.
The toaster doesn’t work. The springs are gone and the toast has to be dug or shaken out, and is typically half burnt and half uncooked.
The cleaners leave something to be desired. The house was surface clean and the bathrooms were cleaned well. However, the
Dishwasher was full of dishes when we arrived. Also, it didn’t appear that anyone had really cleaned the wood floors in a few weeks.
10.0 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2024
We had a wonderful time at the Judson Bennett House! There was plenty of space for the 20 of us! We can’t wait to do it again next year.
10.0 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2023
This house was perfect for our large family gathering for a beach wedding. There were plenty of comfortable sleeping options, lots of room for dinners, brunch and game night, not to mention a living space large enough for the gang to watch football! The porch was relaxing with its swing and lovely rocking chairs overlooking a lush garden. The historical details nestled among the modern refurbishments were outstanding. The kitchen and dining area was amazing and a pleasure to use. The air conditioning was quite good considering how hot a weekend we had! Overall, this is a wonderful property on which to stay and we’ve already begun telling our friends about it!
10.0 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2023
The house is just a gorgeous in person as it is in the photos! And the historic momentos really added to the experience. There were 11 of us and the house more than accommodated. It was also within walking distance to all the shops and bars! Our only concern were the linens, which we rented with the house. Some just didnt fit the beds, which when youre making 11 beds, is quite annoying. Nonetheless, we would absolutely stay here again, just bring your own sheets and blankets.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(12 Ratings)
"We had a wonderful time at the Judson Bennett House! There was plenty of space for the 20 of us! We can’t wait to do it again next year."
Lisa S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
