Cottage in Keuka Lake, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this cottage rental
Life just keeps getting better at Rusticana! This year's updates include an updated tiled tub and fixtures, fully renovated kitchen, and dishwasher, making big family gatherings a breeze!
Are you ready to make life-long family memories? Grab your kids, your grandkids, and a glass of wine, and head for your spot on the beach or the deck, and you’re on your way. Just five miles from the quaint town of Hammondsport, this is one of the best spots on Keuka Lake. This charming gem has created generations of memories and is ready for yours! Follow us on Instagram @rusticana_keuka!
The Homes
Rusticana consists of two buildings, an original Cottage built in the 1950s, and the Main House added in 1979.
THE MAIN HOUSE: Cute and cozy with plenty of natural light, the main house boasts spectacular views of the lake from the two huge sliding glass doors in the main room. The doors lead onto a 30-foot-long deck that overlooks the shoreline just a few feet away. Two deck tables plus a gas grill make for a spectacular all-day hangout spot. You will never tire of watching the sun sink over the western hillside while enjoying a glass of local wine, or watching the kids frolic in the crystal clear water. On rainy days or cool evenings, stream your favorite programs, surf the Internet, or lose yourself in a great book. Plenty of card games, board games, and puzzles are available for old fashioned fun. At night, let the soothing sound of the water lapping on the shore lull you to sleep.
Main House features:
2 Bedrooms
1 Queen bed
1 Twin/Full bunk
1.5 Baths
Refrigerator
Oven/Stove
Microwave
Dishwasher
2 coffee pots and all utensils
Double sink
Living room facing deck windows
Smart TV for streaming
High-speed Internet
Land-line phone
Lakefront Deck
Gas grill
THE COTTAGE: Lovingly built by the original property owner, but has many recent updates. The wood frame and wood interior cottage boasts a quaint bedroom (the “honeymoon suite” with a small deck facing the lake), a full bath, an enclosed porch, a seating area, and a kitchenette. Grab your coffee mug from the Hoosier cabinet and get ready to embrace the joy of a day at the lake!
The Cottage features:
1 Bedroom with full-size bed
1 full Bath
Storage room
Private deck off bedroom
Seating area
Half-size Refrigerator
Kitchen sink
Coffee maker
Dishes, mugs, and silverware
Antique Hoosier cabinet
High-speed Internet
Enclosed porch
Are you ready to make life-long family memories? Grab your kids, your grandkids, and a glass of wine, and head for your spot on the beach or the deck, and you’re on your way. Just five miles from the quaint town of Hammondsport, this is one of the best spots on Keuka Lake. This charming gem has created generations of memories and is ready for yours! Follow us on Instagram @rusticana_keuka!
The Homes
Rusticana consists of two buildings, an original Cottage built in the 1950s, and the Main House added in 1979.
THE MAIN HOUSE: Cute and cozy with plenty of natural light, the main house boasts spectacular views of the lake from the two huge sliding glass doors in the main room. The doors lead onto a 30-foot-long deck that overlooks the shoreline just a few feet away. Two deck tables plus a gas grill make for a spectacular all-day hangout spot. You will never tire of watching the sun sink over the western hillside while enjoying a glass of local wine, or watching the kids frolic in the crystal clear water. On rainy days or cool evenings, stream your favorite programs, surf the Internet, or lose yourself in a great book. Plenty of card games, board games, and puzzles are available for old fashioned fun. At night, let the soothing sound of the water lapping on the shore lull you to sleep.
Main House features:
2 Bedrooms
1 Queen bed
1 Twin/Full bunk
1.5 Baths
Refrigerator
Oven/Stove
Microwave
Dishwasher
2 coffee pots and all utensils
Double sink
Living room facing deck windows
Smart TV for streaming
High-speed Internet
Land-line phone
Lakefront Deck
Gas grill
THE COTTAGE: Lovingly built by the original property owner, but has many recent updates. The wood frame and wood interior cottage boasts a quaint bedroom (the “honeymoon suite” with a small deck facing the lake), a full bath, an enclosed porch, a seating area, and a kitchenette. Grab your coffee mug from the Hoosier cabinet and get ready to embrace the joy of a day at the lake!
The Cottage features:
1 Bedroom with full-size bed
1 full Bath
Storage room
Private deck off bedroom
Seating area
Half-size Refrigerator
Kitchen sink
Coffee maker
Dishes, mugs, and silverware
Antique Hoosier cabinet
High-speed Internet
Enclosed porch
Amenities at Reserve your space now to celebrate Fall in the Finger Lakes!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests loved the well-equipped property, perfect for family vacations by the lake with ample activities, great views, and responsive hosts. A relaxing and enjoyable experience.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
My family had a wonderful time at the house. We rented a boat from Jake’s Marina, they were great to work with! And we brought a jetski. Both were tied up at the dock. The water is gradual to get into the lake and very nice for swimming. We also enjoyed fishing at the dock and off the boat. There’s several nice spots for food around the lake as well. We also had our dogs with us and they loved it. Lovely home would definitely recommend.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Super clean & neat. Great sitting areas indoors, on the deck and at waterfront. Kitchen has lots of tools you'd find at home.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
clean property with easy check-in and stunning views!
5 / 10·Oct 2021
It's a beautiful house with a cottage along side, lots of room inside, and your right by the water, a very relaxing time.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.7Outstanding
(74 Ratings)
Guests loved the well-equipped property, perfect for family vacations by the lake with ample activities, great views, and responsive hosts. A relaxing and enjoyable experience.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
