House in Shelter Island, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Downstairs: 3 bedrooms (1 Queen, 2 Twins and 1 full) and 2 full baths.
Stainless Steel appliances, marble floors and working fireplace.
Weber gas grill under a pergola.
Creek at the end of private road.
Front and back patios.
AC in all bedrooms.
Dining, kitchen and living room has a vaulted ceiling and fireplace.
Interior & exterior dining room seating.
Lots of light, skylights and windows.
Ample parking in driveway.
Close to town, beaches, restaurants, the marina and ferry.
Close to paddle boarding, golf, mini golf, clamming, and tennis courts. •Upstairs of house is not for rent
• A copy of a drivers license of the booker and first and last name of all guests is required before check in.
Stainless Steel appliances, marble floors and working fireplace.
Weber gas grill under a pergola.
Creek at the end of private road.
Front and back patios.
AC in all bedrooms.
Dining, kitchen and living room has a vaulted ceiling and fireplace.
Interior & exterior dining room seating.
Lots of light, skylights and windows.
Ample parking in driveway.
Close to town, beaches, restaurants, the marina and ferry.
Close to paddle boarding, golf, mini golf, clamming, and tennis courts. •Upstairs of house is not for rent
• A copy of a drivers license of the booker and first and last name of all guests is required before check in.
Amenities at 3 bed 2 bath • Upstairs of house is not for rent
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Wonderful experience! Everything was so easy and there were plenty of towels.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2024
We had a great time! The house is a good size with plenty of room for everybody. We were two couples and we had our small dogs with us. Very nice the house is dog friendly and has a fenced in yard. It is also very close to lots of things to do on not only shelter island, but in the surrounding towns, highly recommend.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2024
Second time we have stayed at Christina’s and we love it. Outdoor space is great for grilling, dining al fresco, relaxing on front porch with a tray of freshly shucked oysters from nearby shops! Bedrooms are comfortable, clean and get a lovely breeze in the evenings. House is great, Christina responds quickly to any inquiries. Would highly recommend
6 / 10Average·Aug 2018
I wouldn’t stay there again. The ac is an issue with me.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(13 Ratings)
"Wonderful experience! Everything was so easy and there were plenty of towels. "
Kate C.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
