MAGICAL, PRIVATE, FORESTED LAKEFRONT/ SWEEPING LAKE VISTAS, EASY ACCESS IN ITHA

Top rated by guests
Entrance steps from driveway to main house
Property grounds
Property grounds
RELAX ON THE DECK
Outdoor dining
review stars
9.7Outstanding
(96 Ratings)
Beautiful lakefront property with spacious rooms, excellent kitchen amenities, and stunning views. Perfect for family gatherings, offering outdoor activities like kayaking and a cozy fire pit. Ideal for a peaceful retreat.
From real guest reviews summarized by AI
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
9.7 / 10.0
Outstanding(96 Ratings)

House in Cayuga Lake, NY

12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

About this house rental

Just minutes from downtown Ithaca on the west shore of Lake Cayuga, this property has spectacular lake vistas and over 150 feet of EASILY ACCESSIBLE lake frontage. 1.4 acres of woods and majestic hemlock and oak trees frame a cottage originally built in the mid 1800's by a mayor of Ithaca and then lived in in the summers by his daughter, Belle, until 1922--one of Ithaca's original lakefront homes. We like to share the beautiful view and quaint, rustic vintage house with small gatherings of friends and families.
This is our home and we are usually present on the property, staying in our own self contained area which shares nothing with the main house except the driveway. Since it is our home, we ask that you treat it kindly and leave it in the exact condition you found it.
Due to the ecologically sensitive location, we don't rent to groups larger than 8 (possible 12, with our permission, if there are small ones). There is bed space for 8 and the 2200 SF house can accommodate another adult or 2 on an air mattress or couch, or a couple of little ones. We want your group to be comfortable so you should consult us if your group has more than 8 adults.
We have a strict NO PARTIES rule and do not allow visitors from off the property. Only the rental group is allowed on the property. Additional guest fees will be charged for each outside visitor on the property without the owner's permission. Maximum of 4 cars only in the driveway. There is a driveway camera.

The paved S-curved driveway leads through the woods down the hill to a large parking area with room to turn around and for up to 4 cars to park.. There is one flight of stairs to the main floor entrance but bedrooms can be accessed from the driveway level.

The 2200 sf of living space includes--on the main floor--an entrance room; a fully equipped kitchen with stainless appliances (dishwasher, large frig, freezer with ice maker/water, gourmet stove, microwave, coffee maker, toaster oven, electric tea kettle, etc.); a laundry room with front loading washer and dryer, iron, ironing board; a full bathroom with shower; a large open living/dining room with a charming arts-and-craftsy 'inglenook' around the picturesque riverstone fireplace. The main floor has expansive lake views and opens out to an extensive deck area with plenty of outdoor seating, tables, gas grill, and views galore!

4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms as well as a screened porch are on the second floor. Two bedrooms have queensize beds; two have a fullsize bed. Additional living space in the walk-out basement level features a 5- 6-person sauna with a great view.

The 150 ft of lakefront is about half gently sloping shale beach; the other half is a grassy area with a sea wall and includes a fire pit, dock, and boathouse, with lots of outdoor seating and two hammocks as well as a table and umbrella for dock seating. The property comes with a canoe, three single kayaks, and a tandem kayak. There are water shoes and life vests in the boathouse.

Activities and Attractions : The Finger Lakes is renowned for its wineries and breathtaking gorges. Ithaca is a mecca of arts, science, film activities, artisan farming, world famous restaurants, etc. Ithaca's Farmers Market is rated one of the best in the country. However, alot of folks don't even want to leave the property, since the quiet of the majestic old growth forest and the mesmerizing lake vistas, along with swimming, kayaking, and just gazing at the ever-changing water is the best--an oasis of peace and beauty and privacy --yet so close to all the perks of civilization! 'Magical' is the word most frequently used by visitors to describe the setting.
Of the large lakehouses for rent in Ithaca this is one of the few that has easy water access (only 35 easy steps to the beach), no train tracks or cliff between you and the water, and a Wegman's, Trader Joe's, TJMaxx, etc., and other shopping only 3 miles away (compared to 20 miles).

In addition, there is a small, 2-bedroom cabin on the upper part of the property completely private from the main house that is available at Homeaway listing # 268870.

Amenities at MAGICAL, PRIVATE, FORESTED LAKEFRONT/ SWEEPING LAKE VISTAS, EASY ACCESS IN ITHA

Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY


Ratings and reviews

9.7 / 10.0
Outstanding(96 Ratings)
review starsSummary of reviews
Beautiful lakefront property with spacious rooms, excellent kitchen amenities, and stunning views. Perfect for family gatherings, offering outdoor activities like kayaking and a cozy fire pit. Ideal for a peaceful retreat.
From real guest reviews summarized by AI
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Nov 2025
We found our hosts to be much appreciative of beauty. Not only the general beauty of the interiors of our accommodations, but of the general understanding of beauty surrounding the accommodations. You can see this in how things are placed, how you travel through the spaces and how nature is intentionally framed by the windows, patios & decks. What stood out the most was the charming conversation I had with the host upon arrival who made me feel welcome and at home.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Oct 2025
Beautiful lake view. Great setting. House is a little quirky with old fashioned look and feel.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
Looking for a place for our family of 10 to celebrate our 50th anniversary. Turned out the place didn’t sleep what it advertised and we had to adapt and make the best of it. We did enjoy swimming, fishing, a campfire and dinners on the beautiful deck. We hiked each day at one of the various gorges nearby. We made some wonderful memories together.
8.0 / 10.0Excellent·Sep 2025
The property was very nice. The kitchen is wonderful & well equiped. Has lots of stairs which would be hard for anyone with a disability. Overall it was a wonderful stay.thank you.

$$$$
vrbo logo

FAQs

Is parking included with this house?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at MAGICAL, PRIVATE, FORESTED LAKEFRONT/ SWEEPING LAKE VISTAS, EASY ACCESS IN ITHA. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is MAGICAL, PRIVATE, FORESTED LAKEFRONT/ SWEEPING LAKE VISTAS, EASY ACCESS IN ITHA pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at MAGICAL, PRIVATE, FORESTED LAKEFRONT/ SWEEPING LAKE VISTAS, EASY ACCESS IN ITHA?

We found 3 amenities for this rental. This includes non-smoking, no pets allowed, and family friendly.


Explore similar stays in Cayuga Lake

Explore all stays