House in Cayuga Lake, NY
23 guests · 7 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
The Lake House Complex includes the 2,200 square foot Lake House, the Lake Cottage (brand new May 2019) and Bunk House (brand new May 2019). Situated next to each other on our beach (400 feet of frontage!), they're a great way for large groups to spread out and enjoy a beautiful site on scenic Cayuga Lake.
***May through Labor Day and Columbus Day weekend, we rent the Lake House, Bunk House and Lake Cottage as a single unit because of their close proximity. In the off-season (excluding Columbus Day weekend), they can be rented separately. Please message us for the listings for the units individually.***
Relax with friends or family on the deck after a day on Cayuga Lake! Perfect for entertaining large groups! Enjoy a fire on the beach or swim from the adjacent beach.
Lake House: 2-floor, 2,200 sq. ft. house boasts 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
Renovations over winter 2019 included a brand-new kitchen (including wine fridge!), new flooring, fresh paint, and hotel-quality bedding and towels!
Open-plan configuration with dining room, living room, and full kitchen on main (top) floor, along with a full bathroom and two bedrooms. (1 with a queen bed and 1 with king bed and a day bed w/pull out twin, sleeping 4.)
Lower floor has 3 bedrooms (king, queen and bunk beds), a full bathroom, and another area to relax. (One sofa has a full-size pull-out.)
Lake Cottage: 1 bedroom with spectacular lake views and a memory foam king bed. Full kitchen and bathroom, as well as a living room with air conditioning/heating, television, propane BBQ, outdoor furniture and fire pit. Gut renovation in spring 2019!
Bunk House: Includes 2 sets of bunk beds, air conditioning, and heating. (No separate bathroom in unit.)
The lake house is accessed down a flight of ~50 steps. Guests with limited mobility or who wish to drop off people and/or gear, can use our boat ramp that is adjacent to the Lake House Complex. Guests can be dropped on the beach and it is about 8 steps to the upper level of the Lake House. (The Lake Cottage is on one floor, 1 step above the beach.)
Spring, Summer and Fall guests: Lake house complex rental includes 1 electric boat hoist and a private dock. Additional docks with manual or electric hoists available for motor/sail boats at $200/boat/week.
Note: Fireplaces inside the units are not available for use. Electric heat provided.
Our property includes another house (Overlook Lodge) that sleeps 10, as well as 8 cabins and 2 yurts that each sleep between 4 and 6. This is the largest lakeside vacation rental property in the Ithaca area that can sleep 85 guests in 12 independent units! Ask about our discounts for renting multiple sites!
The Spotted Sandpiper is located in the woods with frontage on Cayuga Lake and bugs love the woods and water! They're savvy at finding their ways indoors. If the bugs are ever "bugging" you, we're always happy to help.
***May through Labor Day and Columbus Day weekend, we rent the Lake House, Bunk House and Lake Cottage as a single unit because of their close proximity. In the off-season (excluding Columbus Day weekend), they can be rented separately. Please message us for the listings for the units individually.***
Relax with friends or family on the deck after a day on Cayuga Lake! Perfect for entertaining large groups! Enjoy a fire on the beach or swim from the adjacent beach.
Lake House: 2-floor, 2,200 sq. ft. house boasts 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
Renovations over winter 2019 included a brand-new kitchen (including wine fridge!), new flooring, fresh paint, and hotel-quality bedding and towels!
Open-plan configuration with dining room, living room, and full kitchen on main (top) floor, along with a full bathroom and two bedrooms. (1 with a queen bed and 1 with king bed and a day bed w/pull out twin, sleeping 4.)
Lower floor has 3 bedrooms (king, queen and bunk beds), a full bathroom, and another area to relax. (One sofa has a full-size pull-out.)
Lake Cottage: 1 bedroom with spectacular lake views and a memory foam king bed. Full kitchen and bathroom, as well as a living room with air conditioning/heating, television, propane BBQ, outdoor furniture and fire pit. Gut renovation in spring 2019!
Bunk House: Includes 2 sets of bunk beds, air conditioning, and heating. (No separate bathroom in unit.)
The lake house is accessed down a flight of ~50 steps. Guests with limited mobility or who wish to drop off people and/or gear, can use our boat ramp that is adjacent to the Lake House Complex. Guests can be dropped on the beach and it is about 8 steps to the upper level of the Lake House. (The Lake Cottage is on one floor, 1 step above the beach.)
Spring, Summer and Fall guests: Lake house complex rental includes 1 electric boat hoist and a private dock. Additional docks with manual or electric hoists available for motor/sail boats at $200/boat/week.
Note: Fireplaces inside the units are not available for use. Electric heat provided.
Our property includes another house (Overlook Lodge) that sleeps 10, as well as 8 cabins and 2 yurts that each sleep between 4 and 6. This is the largest lakeside vacation rental property in the Ithaca area that can sleep 85 guests in 12 independent units! Ask about our discounts for renting multiple sites!
The Spotted Sandpiper is located in the woods with frontage on Cayuga Lake and bugs love the woods and water! They're savvy at finding their ways indoors. If the bugs are ever "bugging" you, we're always happy to help.
Amenities at Great Cayuga Lake House Complex for families, reunions, or just relaxing!
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
Beautiful location right along the lake. You cant beat the views! Highly recommend
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jul 2025
Our visit was perfect for our family gathering! The greatest asset was the nice beach with a gradual walk into the water. It was nice for small children (wearing the life vests WE brought with us) to play beach side. There were plenty of kayaks and floats for all of us to utilize.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jul 2025
The property was well appointed for our group of 19 adults, with an infant (there was a high chair!) There were enough kayaks and paddleboards with life jackets too, for our whole group to boat at once if they wanted! There was AC in all units - it was a very hot week, but we were comfortable. Kitchen was equipped for us to cook for 19 every night. Lots of hiking and waterfalls and other activities near by - grocery store just 10 minutes away. The owners were extremely responsive to our texts about what we needed and help came immediately (a wonderful guy! Sam is a gem.) Everyone was sad to go.
6.0 / 10.0Average·Oct 2025
They were easy to communicate with and check in was a breeze!!Great spot for family reunion and lovely right at the lake!! We enjoyed using the kayaks and canoe on the lake. This place is set up for a group of 18 people nicely. Cleaning is not a virtue at this place. That was our main downfall.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(30 Ratings)
"Beautiful location right along the lake. You cant beat the views! Highly recommend"
Kristen D.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
