House in Menemsha, MA
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Delightful rustic intergenerational or multi-family compound with large pool. Main house has upstairs master BR with king bed, TV & sitting area; and full bathroom. Main house first floor has the main kitchen/dining area/living room and also has a second kitchen and a new bathroom with easy access from the pool. First floor has access to a large deck with two tables and 12 chairs.
Guest house has 4 br's--a queen room and a twin room on each floor. Each bedroom has its own sink and there is a separate toilet room and a separate shower room on each floor. There is an additional room with outside entrance on the first floor that we call the quiet room with a sofa and chairs for reading. We do not advise using it as a sleeping space.. Outdoor hot and cold showers, washer/dryer room, large deck with 2 grills (one charcoal and one gas) overlooking pool. There are many Adirondack chairs and three lounge chairs placed around the pool. There are two hammocks--one in front and one in back area. There is an equipent room with bocce, corn hole, floats, beach toys for children, and other outdoor equipment.
The house is in a very private setting but only 2+ miles from Lambert's Cove Beach .House is ideally situated, close to Cronig's up-island supermarket, and Tisbury and West Tisbury shopping areas. Being right in the middle of the island allows easy access to Menemsha sunsets, many art galleries, Ally's general story, West Tisbury library, farm stands, and equidistant from Oak Bluffs and Edgartown. This is the quiet part of the island and a wonderful retreat from the hustle and bustle of the Vineyard in the summer although you can easily access the crowds and shops.
No linens or beach towels are provided although beach chairs are available.
Keywords: 2 Houses
Guest house has 4 br's--a queen room and a twin room on each floor. Each bedroom has its own sink and there is a separate toilet room and a separate shower room on each floor. There is an additional room with outside entrance on the first floor that we call the quiet room with a sofa and chairs for reading. We do not advise using it as a sleeping space.. Outdoor hot and cold showers, washer/dryer room, large deck with 2 grills (one charcoal and one gas) overlooking pool. There are many Adirondack chairs and three lounge chairs placed around the pool. There are two hammocks--one in front and one in back area. There is an equipent room with bocce, corn hole, floats, beach toys for children, and other outdoor equipment.
The house is in a very private setting but only 2+ miles from Lambert's Cove Beach .House is ideally situated, close to Cronig's up-island supermarket, and Tisbury and West Tisbury shopping areas. Being right in the middle of the island allows easy access to Menemsha sunsets, many art galleries, Ally's general story, West Tisbury library, farm stands, and equidistant from Oak Bluffs and Edgartown. This is the quiet part of the island and a wonderful retreat from the hustle and bustle of the Vineyard in the summer although you can easily access the crowds and shops.
No linens or beach towels are provided although beach chairs are available.
Keywords: 2 Houses
Amenities at Great two house compound, inground pool, great privacy
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Menemsha, MA
Ratings and reviews
8 / 10Excellent·Jul 2025
Bob and Dottie were very responsive to our questions and concerns. If it says “ rustic” in the listing, this is accurate and depending on your expectations, fine. The pool and the toys are wonderful. Our 18 month old and 5 and 8 year old were well entertained. The kitchen(s) are well stocked. Be aware of scratched non stick pans that should be removed from use. There is no garbage disposal which can make for messy clean ups but is manageable. There is no ice maker so either get bags or plan on several daily “ice making” sessions. I grew up with the same amenities so this was not a shocker to me but depending on what you think the weekly rent should include, be prepared. There are issues in the house that should be addressed given the asking weekly rent but have not. Specifically issues with shower doors and some leaking even though specified directions were followed. Please know that we had a great week but I was disappointed with certain aspects of the house. There is no air conditioning. We were fine with the fans because our week was mild-70’s. If it was a Michigan 90 degree day.. not so much. The aesthetics could be improved. I’d love to see some attention to detail especially with the guest house and bathrooms. Martha’s Vineyard is rich in history and has an artistic, rustic vibe that could be expounded on here. Would I come again? I’d love to work with Bob and Dottie again but would like more attention to details.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2023
Very cute living room so comfortable. Stairs to second floor bedroom a little narrow. 2nd house with four bedrooms a little musty smelling as I guess all beach houses are! Pool and grounds lovely and comfortable. My family loved staying there. Well equipped. We had a great time!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2023
We loved staying at Bob and Dottie's place. It was perfect for our family and we really enjoyed the rustic vibe and more remote location. The whole crew loved the pool and were in and out all week. We got a pass for Lambert's Cove and had a great beach day there. We had a hot week and appreciated the fans provided. The owners were super communicative and a pleasure to work with! Thanks, Bob and Dottie!
5 / 10·Aug 2017
The house was organized, well designed and perfect for my family. There were board games like checkers, uno, connect four, etc.
The owner was thoughtful and even had games for the pool. I liked the layout of the guest house bathrooms. I would return every year.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(14 Ratings)
"Very cute living room so comfortable. Stairs to second floor bedroom a little narrow. 2nd house with four bedrooms a little musty smelling as I guess all beach houses are! Pool and grounds lovely and ..."
vicki m.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
