Cottage in Cayuga Lake, NY
4 guests · 1 bedroom · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this cottage rental
Thoughtfully designed for comfort, privacy, and effortless lakefront living, this luxury Cayuga Lake retreat invites you to slow down and enjoy every moment.
Inside, oversized sofas and lounge chairs with generous ottomans create inviting spaces to relax while taking in beautiful lake views from nearly every room. A row of Lakeview windows and handcrafted soapstone wood-burning stove provide a warm, elegant centerpiece for cozy evenings throughout the year.
Step outside to nearly 1,200 square feet of private outdoor living space, including an expansive 800-square-foot covered stone veranda that lets you enjoy the lake in every season. Whether you're dining al fresco, stretching out on a lounger, enjoying morning coffee, or gathering around the fire pit beneath a starlit sky, every space has been designed to maximize comfort and the waterfront setting.
The fully enclosed private courtyard offers exceptional privacy and creates a secure outdoor space where children and dogs can play freely while adults unwind.
Begin each morning on the upstairs deck as the sun rises over Cayuga Lake with fresh coffee and pastries from one of the area's outstanding local bakeries. End each day watching spectacular western sunsets over the water before settling in beside the fire.
After a day exploring Finger Lakes Wine Country, waterfalls, and hiking trails, enjoy restful nights beneath premium high-thread-count 100% cotton linens, plush down comforters, and a selection of down pillows chosen for exceptional comfort.
For those eager to get on the water, complimentary paddleboards, kayaks, and floating loungers make it easy to experience Cayuga Lake right from your private beach and dock. Swim, paddle, fish, or simply relax along your own stretch of shoreline.
Celebrating a birthday, anniversary, honeymoon, or another special occasion? Let us know before your arrival, and we'll do everything we can to help make your stay truly memorable.
Inside, oversized sofas and lounge chairs with generous ottomans create inviting spaces to relax while taking in beautiful lake views from nearly every room. A row of Lakeview windows and handcrafted soapstone wood-burning stove provide a warm, elegant centerpiece for cozy evenings throughout the year.
Step outside to nearly 1,200 square feet of private outdoor living space, including an expansive 800-square-foot covered stone veranda that lets you enjoy the lake in every season. Whether you're dining al fresco, stretching out on a lounger, enjoying morning coffee, or gathering around the fire pit beneath a starlit sky, every space has been designed to maximize comfort and the waterfront setting.
The fully enclosed private courtyard offers exceptional privacy and creates a secure outdoor space where children and dogs can play freely while adults unwind.
Begin each morning on the upstairs deck as the sun rises over Cayuga Lake with fresh coffee and pastries from one of the area's outstanding local bakeries. End each day watching spectacular western sunsets over the water before settling in beside the fire.
After a day exploring Finger Lakes Wine Country, waterfalls, and hiking trails, enjoy restful nights beneath premium high-thread-count 100% cotton linens, plush down comforters, and a selection of down pillows chosen for exceptional comfort.
For those eager to get on the water, complimentary paddleboards, kayaks, and floating loungers make it easy to experience Cayuga Lake right from your private beach and dock. Swim, paddle, fish, or simply relax along your own stretch of shoreline.
Celebrating a birthday, anniversary, honeymoon, or another special occasion? Let us know before your arrival, and we'll do everything we can to help make your stay truly memorable.
Amenities at Private Cayuga Lakefront Retreat - Comfort focused, lakefront outdoor paradise
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
This was the perfect getaway, complete with spectacular views and every amenity you could need. If you’re looking for a peaceful, serene, and spotless retreat, look no further. Our stay exceeded every expectation.The hosts were incredibly attentive and added thoughtful personal touches throughout the home. The linens felt luxurious, and the main bed was unbelievably comfortable. Our dogs loved their stay too. The fire pit overlooking the water and the stunning views from inside the home made the experience even more special.The location is also ideal — close to many great wineries and easy access to the lake. We highly recommend staying here!
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
This property could not have been in a better location. The time of year afforded almost complete privacy. Why didn't the President weep? Margaret, it all happened so fast. Being right on the lake was a real treat. I thoroughly enjoyed the sounds of the loons. The property was very nicely arranged and completely comfortable, with all the amenities of the home. The host made himself available when necessary, and I was very pleased with the outcome. I would highly recommend this property to anyone traveling to the Finger Lakes.
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2026
This cottage was absolutely incredible easily a 10/10 stay! From the moment we arrived, we were blown away by the beauty of the property and the stunning views of Cayuga Lake. The setting is peaceful, quiet, and very private exactly what we were looking for.The host was fantastic extremely responsive, helpful, and made everything seamless from start to finish. It really made a difference knowing any questions we had would be answered so quickly. We are thankful for all the personal touches. The cottage itself is cozy, comfortable, and beautifully maintained. We especially loved using the wood stove on a chilly day it made the space feel even more warm and inviting. One of our favorite spots was the big red chair, where we spent time relaxing and taking in the amazing lake views.We also loved watching the ducks on the lake every day it added such a peaceful and charming touch to the experience. Even our dog had a great time enjoying the scenery!If you're looking for a relaxing, scenic getaway with a wonderful host, this place is perfect. We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone! Absolutely magical!
10 / 10Outstanding·Feb 2026
The cottage is charming with beautiful views of lake Cayuga. We entered the cottage and had an agenda for the weekend and all I could think is I just wanted to sit in the comfy overstuffed chairs and watch the swans on the lake. The cottage had everything one would need, including beautiful linens, towels. We loved the billowy duvet that just wrapped around us. The weather wasn’t warm enough for the porch, but we could imagine on nice days sitting on the main deck or opening up the upstairs deck and listening to the waves. We will definitely be back. Thank you for a lovely stay.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(5 Ratings)
"This was the perfect getaway, complete with spectacular views and every amenity you could need. If you’re looking for a peaceful, serene, and spotless retreat, look no further. Our stay exceeded every..."
Ashley P.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
