Pony Paradise by Seaside Vacations & Sales

Top rated by guests
Welcome to Pony Paradise!
Private Master Bath with huge Vanity.
Private Master Bath has Walk-in Shower.
Full Bath 2 has a Tub/Shower Combo.
Master Bedroom has a comfy King Bed and lovely Yard Views.
review stars
9.4Outstanding
(9 Ratings)
"Very quiet, great location to get anywhere on the island."
Jeff B.
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
9.4 / 10
Outstanding(9 Ratings)

House in Chincoteague Island, VA

6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths

Reasons to book

Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area

About this house rental

Are you all about ponies in paradise? If so, you will love comfy and cozy ‘Pony Paradise’ in the very heart of Chincoteague Island! Formerly ever-popular ‘Sunshine and Daydreams’, this Seaside Vacations’ fan-favorite is under New Ownership, and y’all are going to LOVE what they’ve done with the place! This adorable 3 Bedroom/2 Full Bath Cottage is located on Willow Street, just across from where our famous Wild Ponies are penned at the Carnival Grounds. Stroll to the Carnival weekends in July, the Historic Downtown District to shops and dining, or just skip across the street with your morning coffee to watch the ponies graze. What makes vacationing at Pony Paradise even more fun? You get to bring your favorite pup along with a $100 pet fee (Limit 2)! Your pup will especially appreciate the Fully Fenced-in yard for him to play safely in!

Pony Paradise has packed a lot of bang into your vacation buck. As you enter through the Screened Front Porch, you’re already thinking you’ll never want to leave. Just imagine curling up here with a good book and taking in that salty, sweet bay bay breeze. Watch the Ponies grazing just across the Street, and you can even enjoy your 4th of July Fireworks right from your Screened Porch!

Upon entering Pony Paradise, you’ll be warmly welcomed by serene Colors of Sand and Sea - just breathtaking. With gorgeous flooring reminiscent of a stroll on the Boardwalk and bright and beachy furnishings, you may never want to leave. There’s even a cozy Fireplace for those chilly off-season stays - one of our very favorite times on our Island. You’ll love relaxing after a fun-filled day exploring Assateague in the Living Area with Free WiFi and Flat Screen Streaming TV. There’s plenty of room for all to stretch out, yet still be together.

The Chef in your family will love the spacious Eat-in Kitchen with both a Breakfast Bar and Dining Table. Well-stocked with all you need - even a Waffle Maker - mealtime will be no chore. You can grill the Fresh Catch of the Day - which hopefully you caught - out back, while listening to the Tree Frogs sing. Dine indoors in the comfort of the AC, or wander to one of many great Restaurants nearby. After dinner, slip out to the back Deck to take in that salty, sweet sea breeze, or gather around the fire pit in the backyard and share stories of the day’s adventures. The spacious yard has two sections, with one that is fenced-in, making it just perfect for your furbaby to get some much needed exercise.

Pony Paradise sleeps 7 in total comfort and style. The Master Bedroom, with a Queen Bed, is dressed in beach blues and crisp whites. The Private Master Bath has a huge Vanity and Walk-in Shower. Down the Hall, Bedroom 2 has a Full Bed and is inviting with cheerful Lime and Vanilla - just like a piece of Key Lime Pie. Bedroom 3 is perfect for the kiddos with Twin Bunk Beds and sleeps 2. A Roll-a-way Twin Bed is available for the 7th member of your family. A 2nd Full Bath with a Tub/Shower Combo is shared. And while no one likes doing laundry while on vacation, the Full Size Washer and Dryer will sure come in handy.

LINENS NOT INCLUDED, BUT LINEN RENTAL IS AVAILABLE.

Friendly dogs welcome with $100 Pet Fee. Max 2 Dogs with Permission. Dogs MUST be current on Flea/Tick Preventative and Immunizations. No Cats.

Every effort is made to ensure that all information and photographs in Seaside Vacations' advertising are accurate and complete. Rate information for properties is subject to change and the quote provided online is only valid at the time of booking. Seaside Vacations cannot be held responsible for possible typographical errors; omissions; price changes; changes in taxes; changes to Terms and Conditions; or changes made by vacation home owners in furnishings, equipment, or bed arrangements. Vacation homes are privately owned and changes may be made to homes or their contents. Seaside Vacations reserves the right to correct any errors.

Amenities at Pony Paradise by Seaside Vacations & Sales

Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly

Map of Chincoteague Island, VA

city location on map

Ratings and reviews

9.4 / 10
Outstanding(9 Ratings)
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Very quiet, great location to get anywhere on the island.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
House comfortable and clean, fantastic for pets. This was a very cute, beachy home for the week.
8 / 10Excellent·Aug 2025
Clean kitchen, bathrooms, and living areas. Use of household amenities was very convenient. Had some trouble with one of the neighbors persisting we allow our dog to play with his dog, which based on the dog's behavior we kindly declined multiple times. Other than than location was great, screened in porch was fantastic... happy to have been there all together (doggo included) on vacation.
6 / 10Average·May 2026
I completely understand that it is a pet friendly house but the bedding should be clean. You should not have to search for clean linens and those are covered in dog hair as well. I should not have to do laundry the first day were there especially when I pay for a cleaning fee. Minus the bedding situation the house was good and the backyard was great for our pups!

$$$$
expedia logo

FAQs

Is parking included with this house?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at Pony Paradise by Seaside Vacations & Sales. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Pony Paradise by Seaside Vacations & Sales pet friendly?

Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.

What amenities are available at Pony Paradise by Seaside Vacations & Sales?

We found 3 amenities for this rental. This includes non-smoking, pets allowed, and family friendly.