House in New York
8 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
In the picturesque rural town of Marilla, right outside East Aurora, this lovely completely renovated cape home is a beautiful, comfortable and welcoming choice. It’s a peaceful option that’s about 20 minutes from many of Western New York’s popular destinations. A nice choice for a family, a couple, or an individual…traveling for family visits, shopping and site-seeing or a business trip.
We are walking distance to The Marilla Country Store. Founded in 1851, the store is the oldest continuously operating country store in New York State.
On the first floor is an inviting farmhouse kitchen that seats 8 comfortably. Everything you need to eat-in is provided, including a full-size gas oven with air-fryer option and modern amenities. The coffee bar is stocked with a colorful collection of mugs (pick your favorite to use during your stay!) and options for coffee and teas.
A spacious and comfortable living room has enough seating for all, with a large, plush sectional, two recliners, a large TV, plus an electric fireplace for cool nights and a cozy atmosphere!
Also on the first floor is a serene bedroom with a king bed, nightstands with USB ports and TV.
A private room with a couch, lift top table and TV offers a quiet work or hangout space. The couch can be converted to a full-size bed. A full bath with shower completes the first floor.
The second floor offers two pretty bedrooms, one holds a queen bed and the other has two twin beds, comfortable for adults as well as children. A second full bath on this floor has a tub with shower.
There is plenty of space in the game room to enjoy a large selection of games, cards and books.
With plenty of outdoor area to enjoy too, you’ll love your time at the Marilla Country Cape!
We are walking distance to The Marilla Country Store. Founded in 1851, the store is the oldest continuously operating country store in New York State.
On the first floor is an inviting farmhouse kitchen that seats 8 comfortably. Everything you need to eat-in is provided, including a full-size gas oven with air-fryer option and modern amenities. The coffee bar is stocked with a colorful collection of mugs (pick your favorite to use during your stay!) and options for coffee and teas.
A spacious and comfortable living room has enough seating for all, with a large, plush sectional, two recliners, a large TV, plus an electric fireplace for cool nights and a cozy atmosphere!
Also on the first floor is a serene bedroom with a king bed, nightstands with USB ports and TV.
A private room with a couch, lift top table and TV offers a quiet work or hangout space. The couch can be converted to a full-size bed. A full bath with shower completes the first floor.
The second floor offers two pretty bedrooms, one holds a queen bed and the other has two twin beds, comfortable for adults as well as children. A second full bath on this floor has a tub with shower.
There is plenty of space in the game room to enjoy a large selection of games, cards and books.
With plenty of outdoor area to enjoy too, you’ll love your time at the Marilla Country Cape!
Amenities at Delightful, newly renovated, 3 bedroom cape in a charming country setting
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Our stay at Paul & Sandy’s was absolutely exceptional from start to finish. You can immediately tell they put so much heart and care into creating a truly welcoming experience. The attention to detail was unlike anything we’ve experienced at other VRBO rentals.The extras they included made such a difference — plenty of towels, thoughtful personal items and paper products stocked throughout the home, a beautiful welcome basket, and even a delicious cinnamon roll gift that felt so warm and personal. It’s rare to find a rental that feels this cared for and generously prepared.The bedding was fabulous, the furniture was incredibly comfortable, and every space felt cozy, polished, and relaxing. The outdoor area was beautiful as well, and although we unfortunately weren’t able to enjoy it because of the rain, we could tell it would have been a perfect place to unwind.There were so many extra amenities that made the stay feel elevated and stress-free. On top of all of that, communication was fabulous the entire time — responsive, kind, and helpful.This was one of those stays that genuinely stands out, and we will absolutely be back. Highly recommend Paul & Sandy’s to anyone looking for the perfect home in the area.
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
We had a great stay! The layout of the home was perfect for our family! The property was immaculate and the hosts exceeded our expectations in terms of amenities especially in the kitchen! We highly recommend staying at the Blue House if you have the opportunity!
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
Loved this place! So comfortable and cozy. Beautifully decorated and the hosts have thought of everything to make the house truly feel like home. From the welcome basket of goodies upon check-in and the stocked coffee/tea bar and cinnamon rolls for breakfast to the baby gate, toddler bed rail, books, games and toys for all ages - this place truly met all of our needs and provided an enjoyable mini vacation. The hosts are wonderful, friendly and accommodating.
10 / 10Outstanding·Dec 2025
This was a wonderful ‘cottage’- one that accommodated 3 couples and a single with ease. Warm, well stocked, beautifully decorated, communication on point. The hosts thought of everything (everything!!). It is our first choice the next time we travel to Buffalo. We loved it!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(37 Ratings)
"Our stay at Paul & Sandy’s was absolutely exceptional from start to finish. You can immediately tell they put so much heart and care into creating a truly welcoming experience. The attention to detail..."
Wendy C.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
