House in Keuka Lake, NY
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Penny Lane is a spacious, inviting home on Keuka's East Bluff neighborhood. Located just a few minutes from the Village of Penn Yan, this home is ideal for a summer vacation or a spring/fall getaway. The home was built with views of Keuka Lake from all of the bedrooms and main living areas and has a lovely 2 story dock over the water.
*Private lakefront
*Lakeside deck
*Two story dock
*View of the lake from every room
*Lower level family room
On the main floor is an open living space with large kitchen, dining area and Living room. The Kitchen is stocked with cookware and dinnerware and has a large island for additional dining. The Living room has comfortable seating, a tv, and patio doors out on the small side patio where the gas grill is located (the interior fireplace in the living room is not in working condition and cannot be used by guests). From the dining area, there are large windows looking out over the lake, making it easy to dine while enjoying the views of the water. The patio doors from the dining area go out onto a small balcony where you can enjoy a few moments of quiet in the rocking chairs.
There is a large Primary bedroom, with a King size bed, on the main floor with windows overlooking the lake. The main floor bathroom is across the hall and has a tub/shower along with large vanity and double sink.
On the upper floor there are 2 bedrooms and another full bath....Bedroom 2 has a Queen bed and Bedroom 3 has a Double/Full size bed. Each of these bedrooms has their own smart TV for guests to enjoy a show from their cozy bed. The full bath on this floor has a tub/shower and is across the hall from Bedroom 2.
The Lower level has a large open Family Room area with a tv, sleeper sofa, spacious desk/office area and an additional bedroom and bathroom. The bedroom on the Lower level has a bunk bed with each bunk being a Double/Full size bed, and large windows overlooking the lake. The Lower level full bath has a tub/shower
From the Lower level Family Room you can walk out onto a small patio and down the landscaped stairs to the dock. The dock has two levels and, from the house, you'll walk down onto the top level of the dock where you can find outdoor seating and a gas firepit. From the top level of the dock there is a flight of stairs to the lower dock where there are 2 whip systems for tying up water equipment. There is a kayak available for guests to use as well. The lower level of the dock also connects to the large outdoor deck area that overhangs the lakefront and where you can enter the water for swimming. Penny Lane has beautiful and expansive views of Keuka Lake from the upper level of the dock and you'll love watching the sun set from here!
*This home does have a flight of stairs from the parking area to the main entry door. If you have mobility issues, please be aware that you will need to navigate a flight of stairs to access the home
*Air conditioning is provided with central air.
*A limited amount of paper towel, toilet paper, soaps, is provided for each guest.
**We ask that renters to be over the age of 25. By booking you agree with this policy and comply with the request that the renting party is over the age of 25.
**No pets or animals allowed
**No parties allowed
**Smoking prohibited
**Parking for 3 vehicles only!
**Lake conditions are not guaranteed and are non refundable
**Guest must comply with maximum occupancy at all times, no exceptions. No more than 10 people are allowed on the premises at any time, and excess guests will be asked to leave.
**Guests are asked to initial a rental waiver, sent via email, immediately after booking
**DOCKS: A dock is provided, you are solely responsible for ensuring docks, boatlifts, and/or mooring facilities are adequate.
Guest assumes liability for use of the dock and assumes responsibility and liability for damages done to the dock during their stay, whether the damage is done by their watercraft or the guest themselves.
**Seasonal amenities: kayaks and some outdoor furniture are available seasonally and are often available for use from mid-May to October
*Private lakefront
*Lakeside deck
*Two story dock
*View of the lake from every room
*Lower level family room
On the main floor is an open living space with large kitchen, dining area and Living room. The Kitchen is stocked with cookware and dinnerware and has a large island for additional dining. The Living room has comfortable seating, a tv, and patio doors out on the small side patio where the gas grill is located (the interior fireplace in the living room is not in working condition and cannot be used by guests). From the dining area, there are large windows looking out over the lake, making it easy to dine while enjoying the views of the water. The patio doors from the dining area go out onto a small balcony where you can enjoy a few moments of quiet in the rocking chairs.
There is a large Primary bedroom, with a King size bed, on the main floor with windows overlooking the lake. The main floor bathroom is across the hall and has a tub/shower along with large vanity and double sink.
On the upper floor there are 2 bedrooms and another full bath....Bedroom 2 has a Queen bed and Bedroom 3 has a Double/Full size bed. Each of these bedrooms has their own smart TV for guests to enjoy a show from their cozy bed. The full bath on this floor has a tub/shower and is across the hall from Bedroom 2.
The Lower level has a large open Family Room area with a tv, sleeper sofa, spacious desk/office area and an additional bedroom and bathroom. The bedroom on the Lower level has a bunk bed with each bunk being a Double/Full size bed, and large windows overlooking the lake. The Lower level full bath has a tub/shower
From the Lower level Family Room you can walk out onto a small patio and down the landscaped stairs to the dock. The dock has two levels and, from the house, you'll walk down onto the top level of the dock where you can find outdoor seating and a gas firepit. From the top level of the dock there is a flight of stairs to the lower dock where there are 2 whip systems for tying up water equipment. There is a kayak available for guests to use as well. The lower level of the dock also connects to the large outdoor deck area that overhangs the lakefront and where you can enter the water for swimming. Penny Lane has beautiful and expansive views of Keuka Lake from the upper level of the dock and you'll love watching the sun set from here!
*This home does have a flight of stairs from the parking area to the main entry door. If you have mobility issues, please be aware that you will need to navigate a flight of stairs to access the home
*Air conditioning is provided with central air.
*A limited amount of paper towel, toilet paper, soaps, is provided for each guest.
**We ask that renters to be over the age of 25. By booking you agree with this policy and comply with the request that the renting party is over the age of 25.
**No pets or animals allowed
**No parties allowed
**Smoking prohibited
**Parking for 3 vehicles only!
**Lake conditions are not guaranteed and are non refundable
**Guest must comply with maximum occupancy at all times, no exceptions. No more than 10 people are allowed on the premises at any time, and excess guests will be asked to leave.
**Guests are asked to initial a rental waiver, sent via email, immediately after booking
**DOCKS: A dock is provided, you are solely responsible for ensuring docks, boatlifts, and/or mooring facilities are adequate.
Guest assumes liability for use of the dock and assumes responsibility and liability for damages done to the dock during their stay, whether the damage is done by their watercraft or the guest themselves.
**Seasonal amenities: kayaks and some outdoor furniture are available seasonally and are often available for use from mid-May to October
Amenities at Penny Lane: 4 bedroom lake home on Keuka Lake, large sun deck
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
This home was great for our three generation family vacation! The house was clean and lovely! It’s centrally located to all of the area attractions and wineries.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
Gorgeous lake views from various spots on the house. Large well set up kitchen. Plenty of space in all 3 floors. Excellent dock space for sitting and enjoying lake views.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
We had a wonderful stay with family at Penny Lane! We love Keuka Lake and were there for a family wedding. Here are a few comments: 1. There was no mention about all of the stone steps leading down to the front door. We had 2 family members with leg & knee problems. 2. My sister-in-law and I wonder what your cleaning service actually does other than wash towels, washcloths, and sheets (and put them back on). We empty all trash, sweep floors, start dishwasher, wipe down counters, clean out refrigerator, take out all garbage and recyclables, etc. We left the house cleaner than when we came! Reminder to your cleaners- dust all rooms including bedrooms, family room and kitchen. Other than these two things, it’s a beautiful house with beautiful views!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Lovely, well laid out house, perfect for our 3 generation gathering. Well equipped kitchen, toy box, crib, great waterfront, comfortable beds and convenient location.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(14 Ratings)
"This home was great for our three generation family vacation! The house was clean and lovely! It’s centrally located to all of the area attractions and wineries."
Valerie L.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
