Cottage in Honeoye Lake
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this cottage rental
Close to everything - sleeps 7 - on the lake where they fish in the winter.
Family-owned since 1917, it is the last house on the road with lots of trees for privacy. The private beach is great for bonfires. New heavy-duty dock and canoe. Updated and restored the interior - added new beds and mattresses, couch, and all new kitchen with proper cooking pots, dishes, and cutlery etc. Screened front porch – very relaxing. Do not rent out much - NOT a loud party place.
Hello All,
This is not a usual rental so the fa
New bathroom vanity, vessel sink with waterfall style faucet and LED adjustable mirror,
Full service heated bidet toilet seat. Adjustable temperature and spray with air dryer.
New kitchen sink and faucet.
55" flatscreen - highspeed internet 100mbs+ – Bluetooth speaker with / mic
Heated/Cooler thermal bed toppers for each bedroom. Pump hot or cold water through your mattress pad. It's amazing and with good sheets!
Over the past 12 years, I have restored and updated. I replaced the entire kitchen down to studs and made it open-concept to the living/dining room. Restored the original hardwood floors and added the original bedroom layout with the original library/reading area just as it was. The new bar counter was made of 100-year-old barn wood from across the lake.
The fully screened front porch overlooks the lake and beach. You can cook meals in a full kitchen – dishwasher – microwave - coffee makers and eat your meals at the counter – expandable wood table or on the height-adjustable porch table with every seat facing the water. The chairs fit each table. Extra table leaves to the left of the bar top. Or cook on the outside propane BBQ
The toilet has a great foot pump flush (to city sewers) that continues as long as you hold it down. The shower uses a tankless heat on-demand system so all the hot water that you want. The new purified mountain lake water is here. Waited 20 years for it – So soft on your skin.
There is a canoe with new life jackets and paddles if you feel like going out on the water
So if you want to unwind, get away from it all and relax – this place might be just what you are looking for. There is dining and a supermarket and drugstore etc 4 miles away. There is a lot of great hiking and wineries 10 miles away. It is a restored cottage with a lot of character, antiques, books etc and not a hotel but you will have a great time.
Please look at the photos and email me any questions
Thanks
Trent
Guest access
The cottage has full access - there is a canoe and paddles.
Other things to note
There is a pizza / wings, chinese, Subway, CVS, Dollar General and Shure Fine grocery store in town as well as some restaurants and cafes in town.
Naples is 8 miles south with more shops, a large winery and Grimes Glen waterfall park.
Family-owned since 1917, it is the last house on the road with lots of trees for privacy. The private beach is great for bonfires. New heavy-duty dock and canoe. Updated and restored the interior - added new beds and mattresses, couch, and all new kitchen with proper cooking pots, dishes, and cutlery etc. Screened front porch – very relaxing. Do not rent out much - NOT a loud party place.
Hello All,
This is not a usual rental so the fa
New bathroom vanity, vessel sink with waterfall style faucet and LED adjustable mirror,
Full service heated bidet toilet seat. Adjustable temperature and spray with air dryer.
New kitchen sink and faucet.
55" flatscreen - highspeed internet 100mbs+ – Bluetooth speaker with / mic
Heated/Cooler thermal bed toppers for each bedroom. Pump hot or cold water through your mattress pad. It's amazing and with good sheets!
Over the past 12 years, I have restored and updated. I replaced the entire kitchen down to studs and made it open-concept to the living/dining room. Restored the original hardwood floors and added the original bedroom layout with the original library/reading area just as it was. The new bar counter was made of 100-year-old barn wood from across the lake.
The fully screened front porch overlooks the lake and beach. You can cook meals in a full kitchen – dishwasher – microwave - coffee makers and eat your meals at the counter – expandable wood table or on the height-adjustable porch table with every seat facing the water. The chairs fit each table. Extra table leaves to the left of the bar top. Or cook on the outside propane BBQ
The toilet has a great foot pump flush (to city sewers) that continues as long as you hold it down. The shower uses a tankless heat on-demand system so all the hot water that you want. The new purified mountain lake water is here. Waited 20 years for it – So soft on your skin.
There is a canoe with new life jackets and paddles if you feel like going out on the water
So if you want to unwind, get away from it all and relax – this place might be just what you are looking for. There is dining and a supermarket and drugstore etc 4 miles away. There is a lot of great hiking and wineries 10 miles away. It is a restored cottage with a lot of character, antiques, books etc and not a hotel but you will have a great time.
Please look at the photos and email me any questions
Thanks
Trent
Guest access
The cottage has full access - there is a canoe and paddles.
Other things to note
There is a pizza / wings, chinese, Subway, CVS, Dollar General and Shure Fine grocery store in town as well as some restaurants and cafes in town.
Naples is 8 miles south with more shops, a large winery and Grimes Glen waterfall park.
Amenities at South End For Fishing - Beach for Bonfires - New City Water
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Honeoye Lake
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Aug 2025
The house was quiet, comfortable and cozy. It was wonderful to be right on the lake and to have use of the canoe. Trent was great to deal with, very communicative and gave us lots of hints and tips for the area.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Aug 2025
Easy check-in, kitchen supplies were excellent excellent WiFi, comfortable indoor and outdoor accomodations. Beautiful spot on the lake with easy water access. Our family of four and our dog were very happy and comfortable here. Good swimming if you paddle out beyond the weeds.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Aug 2025
It was clean, comfortable and had all we needed. It's immediately apparent upon arriving how much thoughtfulness was put into this place. Thank you so much!
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jun 2025
Cottage is true to the pictures. We spend so much time on the porch listening to the water and birds.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(13 Ratings)
"The house was quiet, comfortable and cozy. It was wonderful to be right on the lake and to have use of the canoe. Trent was great to deal with, very communicative and gave us lots of hints and tips fo..."
Greg S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
