House in Fly Creek, NY
10 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* This is a charming, late 1800s home in the hamlet of Fly Creek! 4 bedrooms 2 bathrooms, private yard and a dedicated work space!
From here you can walk to the Fly Creek General Store for all your basic needs and then just a short 4 mile drive to Cooperstown to visit the Baseball Hall of Fame! Fly Creek Manor has everything you need for a cozy country getaway!
4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park24 miles to All Star Village
Fly Creek Manor has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The master bedroom is downstairs and has a king bed. The remaining 3 bedrooms are upstairs, 2 have queen beds and 1 has two full beds as well as a bean bag that converts to a spare king sized bed (CourdaRoy’s brand). An air mattress can also be provided if this is more comfortable to use. With all these beds including the spare CordaRoy bed or air mattress the house comfortably fits 12. There is one bathroom upstairs and one downstairs. Both has walk in showers, no tubs. There is a dedicated work space with a desk and there is Spectrum WiFi provided. The living room has 2 couches that will each seat 3 people and a TV set up for streaming such as Netflix, Disney Plus and Amazon Video. There is a full kitchen with everything you need to cook during your stay. There is a lovely large washer and dryer as well to use! Outside is a private yard with a charcoal BBQ and a fire pit. Fly Creek Manor is so cute and cozy you won’t want to leave! We have left all the charm that makes it an 1800s home but still providing all the amenities needed to have a wonderful and cozy and relaxing stay!
Guests will have the entire home and yard to themselves. Only off limit areas are the basement and barn, for safety reasons only.
There is a keypad to check in. I live in Fly Creek and so am available if needed but I do not come to the home otherwise as I know guests usually enjoy their space and time together.
Right in the main drag of Fly Creek, this is on a side road just right off of the main road and not out in the hills. Great central location. I myself call Fly Creek my home because of its charm, growing amenities and overall wonderful people.
Best to have your own car, ride shares are hard to find. There is a trolly in the village.
This home is right in the main section of Fly Creek so there are neighbors. The neighbors are wonderful and very nice and we want to keep a great relationship with them so just please be mindful of late night noise.
From here you can walk to the Fly Creek General Store for all your basic needs and then just a short 4 mile drive to Cooperstown to visit the Baseball Hall of Fame! Fly Creek Manor has everything you need for a cozy country getaway!
4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park24 miles to All Star Village
Fly Creek Manor has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The master bedroom is downstairs and has a king bed. The remaining 3 bedrooms are upstairs, 2 have queen beds and 1 has two full beds as well as a bean bag that converts to a spare king sized bed (CourdaRoy’s brand). An air mattress can also be provided if this is more comfortable to use. With all these beds including the spare CordaRoy bed or air mattress the house comfortably fits 12. There is one bathroom upstairs and one downstairs. Both has walk in showers, no tubs. There is a dedicated work space with a desk and there is Spectrum WiFi provided. The living room has 2 couches that will each seat 3 people and a TV set up for streaming such as Netflix, Disney Plus and Amazon Video. There is a full kitchen with everything you need to cook during your stay. There is a lovely large washer and dryer as well to use! Outside is a private yard with a charcoal BBQ and a fire pit. Fly Creek Manor is so cute and cozy you won’t want to leave! We have left all the charm that makes it an 1800s home but still providing all the amenities needed to have a wonderful and cozy and relaxing stay!
Guests will have the entire home and yard to themselves. Only off limit areas are the basement and barn, for safety reasons only.
There is a keypad to check in. I live in Fly Creek and so am available if needed but I do not come to the home otherwise as I know guests usually enjoy their space and time together.
Right in the main drag of Fly Creek, this is on a side road just right off of the main road and not out in the hills. Great central location. I myself call Fly Creek my home because of its charm, growing amenities and overall wonderful people.
Best to have your own car, ride shares are hard to find. There is a trolly in the village.
This home is right in the main section of Fly Creek so there are neighbors. The neighbors are wonderful and very nice and we want to keep a great relationship with them so just please be mindful of late night noise.
Amenities at *Fly Creek Manor*3.7Mi to HOF*4Bedrooms2Ba/Sleep10
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Fly Creek, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Mar 2026
Lovely home in the quaint, quiet, and very convenient town of Fly Creek, just a short drive to all Cooperstown attractions and a very short walk to a nice little sandwich and diner shop with tasty BLTs and muffins! Lol. The level of attention paid to every welcoming detail and appointment to the home were very much appreciated. Plenty of off-street parking and a beautiful tree-lined view while washing the dishes. We were lucky to have a fresh fall of snow on the pines and boughs. Bedrooms were comfortable and inviting and were perfect for everyone. Bring a dog bed for your pooch, because the owners were very accommodating on short notice for our traveling dog and a sudden second canine companion. We all loved the place. Thank you again, Marc & Samantha! We hope to return one day again if you'll have us!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
This is a renovated 150 year old home. One bedroom is down and 3 up a very steep and shallow stair case. Check in and out was easy, we loved the lovely little porch area. It is not more than 100 feet from a general store and a charming restaurant with excellent food. It is about a 10 minute drive to the baseball HOF.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2025
Great spot. Great hosts. Many thanks.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(5 Ratings)
"Lovely home in the quaint, quiet, and very convenient town of Fly Creek, just a short drive to all Cooperstown attractions and a very short walk to a nice little sandwich and diner shop with tasty BLT..."
V M S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
