House in Tisbury, MA
10 guests · 6 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Step into the timeless charm of Oak Bluffs while enjoying the comforts of a thoughtfully renovated home. The Legacy House blends 250 years of history with modern upgrades—creating a one-of-a-kind stay just 2 blocks from Inkwell Beach and a short stroll to everything you love about Oak Bluffs.
Whether you're planning a multi-family summer getaway or a peaceful fall retreat, this home offers the space, location, and character that make Martha’s Vineyard unforgettable.
Why Guests Love The Legacy House
- Unbeatable Location – Walk to Inkwell Beach, Circuit Avenue, Ocean Park, and the ferry
- Historic + Renovated – 250-year-old home with a brand-new kitchen and updated bathrooms
- Perfect for Groups – Comfortably designed for 2 families or group gatherings
- Outdoor Living – Wrap-around porch, large rear deck, and outdoor shower
Peaceful Setting – Quiet, charming neighborhood just steps from the action
No Hidden Fees – Transparent pricing, always
The Space
This spacious home is filled with warmth, personality, and room to gather.
- Large front sitting/family room for relaxing together
- Full dining room for shared meals and memories
- 5 thoughtfully arranged bedrooms across two levels
- 2 full bathrooms (one on each floor)
- Ample off-street private parking
Start your mornings with a sunrise walk to the water—or join the iconic “polar bears” for an early swim. Spend your afternoons biking, shopping, or relaxing on the porch with a drink in hand.
Sleeping Arrangements
Designed for flexibility and comfort:
- Bedroom 1 (Upstairs): King bed, spacious, bright, flat-screen TV
- Bedroom 2 (Upstairs): Queen bed + private balcony
- Bedroom 3 (Upstairs): Double + twin bunk with trundle (ideal for kids)
- Bedroom 4 (Upstairs): Twin with trundle (sleeps 2, great for kids/teens)
- Bedroom 5 (Downstairs): Queen bed, large room, ground-level access, TV
Outdoor + Local Highlights
- 2 blocks to tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts
- Easy walk to beaches, shops, dining, and entertainment
- Classic Oak Bluffs neighborhood full of history and charm
Please Read Before Booking (Important Details)
We want your stay to be seamless, so here are a few important notes:
- 7-night minimum during peak season
- This is a historic 250-year-old home—full of charm, but not a hotel-style property
- Linens & towels are not included by default but we will order them for you
- We arrange rental and delivered prior to arrival based on your guest count
- Accuracy in your reservation is important to ensure proper setup
No pets allowed
A Different Kind of Stay
The Legacy House is for those who appreciate character, history, and togetherness over a cookie-cutter experience. If you're looking for a place where mornings start on the porch, days are spent walking to the beach, and evenings bring everyone back together—you’ll feel right at home here.
Whether you're planning a multi-family summer getaway or a peaceful fall retreat, this home offers the space, location, and character that make Martha’s Vineyard unforgettable.
Why Guests Love The Legacy House
- Unbeatable Location – Walk to Inkwell Beach, Circuit Avenue, Ocean Park, and the ferry
- Historic + Renovated – 250-year-old home with a brand-new kitchen and updated bathrooms
- Perfect for Groups – Comfortably designed for 2 families or group gatherings
- Outdoor Living – Wrap-around porch, large rear deck, and outdoor shower
Peaceful Setting – Quiet, charming neighborhood just steps from the action
No Hidden Fees – Transparent pricing, always
The Space
This spacious home is filled with warmth, personality, and room to gather.
- Large front sitting/family room for relaxing together
- Full dining room for shared meals and memories
- 5 thoughtfully arranged bedrooms across two levels
- 2 full bathrooms (one on each floor)
- Ample off-street private parking
Start your mornings with a sunrise walk to the water—or join the iconic “polar bears” for an early swim. Spend your afternoons biking, shopping, or relaxing on the porch with a drink in hand.
Sleeping Arrangements
Designed for flexibility and comfort:
- Bedroom 1 (Upstairs): King bed, spacious, bright, flat-screen TV
- Bedroom 2 (Upstairs): Queen bed + private balcony
- Bedroom 3 (Upstairs): Double + twin bunk with trundle (ideal for kids)
- Bedroom 4 (Upstairs): Twin with trundle (sleeps 2, great for kids/teens)
- Bedroom 5 (Downstairs): Queen bed, large room, ground-level access, TV
Outdoor + Local Highlights
- 2 blocks to tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts
- Easy walk to beaches, shops, dining, and entertainment
- Classic Oak Bluffs neighborhood full of history and charm
Please Read Before Booking (Important Details)
We want your stay to be seamless, so here are a few important notes:
- 7-night minimum during peak season
- This is a historic 250-year-old home—full of charm, but not a hotel-style property
- Linens & towels are not included by default but we will order them for you
- We arrange rental and delivered prior to arrival based on your guest count
- Accuracy in your reservation is important to ensure proper setup
No pets allowed
A Different Kind of Stay
The Legacy House is for those who appreciate character, history, and togetherness over a cookie-cutter experience. If you're looking for a place where mornings start on the porch, days are spent walking to the beach, and evenings bring everyone back together—you’ll feel right at home here.
Amenities at The Legacy House: Walk to Inkwell Beach + Historic Charm, Modern Comfort
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Tisbury, MA
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
Great location in beautiful quirky old house. We could easily walk everywhere and we were comfortable outside, on the porch and in the living room. 2 of the bedrooms best for kids and be prepared for walk-thru bathroom. 6 “Seniors” had fun.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2025
Absolutely Unforgettable. Love it here!!!From the moment we stepped onto the wraparound porch of this charming Oak Bluffs retreat, we knew our Martha’s Vineyard vacation would be something special. This beautifully maintained Victorian cottage perfectly captures the whimsical spirit that makes Oak Bluffs the crown jewel of the island.The House: Character Meets ComfortThe property seamlessly blends historic charm with modern amenities. Original hardwood floors gleam throughout, while updated fixtures and appliances ensure every convenience. The kitchen is a dream for morning coffee preparation and evening meal planning, with granite countertops and stainless steel appliances that make cooking a pleasure rather than a chore.Each bedroom feels like a private sanctuary, with comfortable beds dressed in crisp linens and charming period details that transport you back to Martha’s Vineyard’s golden age. The master suite’s en-suite bathroom features a clawfoot tub perfect for soaking after long beach days.Can’t wait to come back. Great memories made in Oak Bluffs!
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2024
Adorable home in a central location of OB. Exceeds the picture, home is comfortable and has everything you need.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2024
The house was so great and the location was perfect! Enough privacy but walking distance to everything. We loved it!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(9 Ratings)
"Great location in beautiful quirky old house. We could easily walk everywhere and we were comfortable outside, on the porch and in the living room. 2 of the bedrooms best for kids and be prepared for ..."
Madge W.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
