House in Wyoming
6 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Summary:
Tucked away in Story, Wyoming—just 20 minutes from Sheridan—My Story is a one-of-a-kind, history-rich retreat where the creek is the soundtrack and the design is intentionally eclectic. This is an old, character-filled home—expect creaks, quirks, and a layout as unique as the setting.
Guests love the peaceful creekside deck, frequent wildlife, the comfort-forward king bedroom, and the show-stopping copper soaking tub ("10/10—don't skip the bath").
Please note: some art is adult-themed, the 4th bedroom is accessed from outside, and well water can be mineral-forward. This isn't a cookie-cutter cabin—it's a story you get to live in. Book now and write yours.
The Space:
Whether you're traveling as a couple, family, or small group, this retreat is designed for comfort, connection, and a true Story, WY reset. The home unfolds across a quirky, historic layout, offering multiple sleeping areas and plenty of space to unwind together—or apart.
Sleeping Layout (please read carefully):
Stone-Walled King Bedroom (Guest Favorite): King bed. Dramatic stone walls, fireplace, and a true "wow" factor guests rave about.
Primary Queen Bedroom: Queen bed. Conveniently located near the kitchen and living areas.
Bedroom 1: Twin bed. Cozy, private, and ideal for restful nights.
Tower Room (4th Bedroom): Twin bed. Accessed via an exterior staircase—unique, private, and memorable, but not for everyone.
The heart of the home is the open living and dining space—perfect for meals, games, and movie nights. The kitchen is fully stocked for real cooking (a consistent 5-star highlight). Outside, the deck and creekside setting are why so many guests return: morning coffee by the water, wildlife wandering through, and a level of quiet you can truly feel.
Guest Access:
You'll have full access to the entire home and spacious backyard, giving you room to relax and explore. Enjoy morning coffee on the deck, let kids discover hidden corners, or gather under the stars by the fire pit.
Self check-in makes arrival easy, and once you're here, the space is entirely yours to enjoy.
The Neighborhood:
When we say "local," we mean it. Nestled in the heart of Story, Wyoming, this retreat is surrounded by mountain scenery, wildlife, and a pace that invites you to slow down.
Wake to birdsong, spot deer and wild turkeys, and occasionally glimpse moose or elk. Wildlife is part of the magic here—please admire from a distance and secure food properly.
Just minutes away you'll find hiking trails, Story's local charm, and the Wagon Box restaurant. In warmer months, drive Red Grade Road for breathtaking Bighorn Mountain views; in winter, it becomes a favorite for snowshoeing and backcountry exploration.
Downtown Sheridan is about 20 minutes away, offering boutiques, dining, museums, and culture—close enough for convenience, far enough to return to true quiet.
Getting Around:
Story is peaceful and rural—a car is recommended for exploring the area. Many attractions are within 10 minutes, while scenic routes and historic sites are 30–60 minutes away and well worth the drive.
Rental Car Option: A Tesla Model Y may be available upon request (subject to availability).
Bike & E-Bike Rentals: Great for quiet roads and nearby trails.
Transportation: Story does not have rideshare services; Sheridan does.
Every drive here is part of the experience—slow down and enjoy the scenery.
Other Things to Note:
Story is peaceful and rural—a car is recommended for exploring the area. Many attractions are within 10 minutes, while scenic routes and historic sites are 30–60 minutes away and well worth the drive.
Rental Car Option: A Tesla Model 3 may be available upon request (subject to availability).
Bike & E-Bike Rentals: Great for quiet roads and nearby trails.
Transportation: Story does not have rideshare services; Sheridan does.
Every drive here is part of the experience—slow down and enjoy the scenery.
Other Things to Note
Historic Home: This is an old home with real character—creaks, quirks, and natural imperfections are part of the charm.
Water: Well water is safe but mineral-forward; sensitive guests often bring bottled water.
Layout & Mobility: Bedrooms are spread out with stairs, including narrow/steeper areas. Not ideal for guests with mobility challenges—message us before booking if this applies.
Adult-Themed Art: Some art is mature. Please reach out before booking if this is a concern.
Finding the Driveway: The home is tucked back and can be tricky in the dark. Please review arrival instructions carefully.
Supplies: Essentials are provided to start your stay; longer visits may require replenishing.
Quiet Hours: No loud music; quiet hours begin at 10 PM.
Parking: Driveway parking available; trailers/RVs by request.
Heating: Propane heat and fireplaces keep the home cozy—please don't adjust thermostats.
Well & Septic: Flush toilet paper only.
Nature: Peaceful, wooded setting with wildlife—secure food and admire from afar.
This home is thoroughly cleaned and prepared before every stay. If you have questions before booking, we're always happy to help.
Who This Home Is Perfect For
This home is a great fit if you:
Love historic homes with real character, creaks, and stories
Appreciate eclectic design, global art, and a creative, lived-in feel
Want a peaceful creekside escape with wildlife, trees, and true quiet
Enjoy unique features like a giant copper soaking tub and a dramatic stone-walled king bedroom
Are comfortable with a non-traditional layout, including stairs and a bedroom accessed from outside
Want a place that feels personal, soulful, and one-of-a-kind, not mass-produced
Are looking to unplug, reset, and slow down in Story, Wyoming
As one guest put it: "Even if you're not a bath person, help yourself to the giant tub—10/10."
Who This Home May Not Be Ideal For
This home may not be the best fit if you:
Prefer brand-new, hotel-style spaces with uniform layouts
Are highly sensitive to older-home details like creaks, mineral-forward well water, or natural wear
Need step-free access or have mobility challenges with stairs
Are uncomfortable with adult-themed or eclectic artwork
Expect a cookie-cutter or ultra-modern aesthetic
Prefer a home where all bedrooms are on one level and inside-only
If you've read this far and are smiling—this place is probably for you. If you're unsure, message us before booking and we'll happily help you decide.
Interaction with Guests:
You'll have complete privacy during your stay, but we're always just a message away. Whether you need help with the home, local recommendations, or arranging extras, we're happy to assist.
Our goal is simple: make your time in Story effortless, peaceful, and memorable.
Tucked away in Story, Wyoming—just 20 minutes from Sheridan—My Story is a one-of-a-kind, history-rich retreat where the creek is the soundtrack and the design is intentionally eclectic. This is an old, character-filled home—expect creaks, quirks, and a layout as unique as the setting.
Guests love the peaceful creekside deck, frequent wildlife, the comfort-forward king bedroom, and the show-stopping copper soaking tub ("10/10—don't skip the bath").
Please note: some art is adult-themed, the 4th bedroom is accessed from outside, and well water can be mineral-forward. This isn't a cookie-cutter cabin—it's a story you get to live in. Book now and write yours.
The Space:
Whether you're traveling as a couple, family, or small group, this retreat is designed for comfort, connection, and a true Story, WY reset. The home unfolds across a quirky, historic layout, offering multiple sleeping areas and plenty of space to unwind together—or apart.
Sleeping Layout (please read carefully):
Stone-Walled King Bedroom (Guest Favorite): King bed. Dramatic stone walls, fireplace, and a true "wow" factor guests rave about.
Primary Queen Bedroom: Queen bed. Conveniently located near the kitchen and living areas.
Bedroom 1: Twin bed. Cozy, private, and ideal for restful nights.
Tower Room (4th Bedroom): Twin bed. Accessed via an exterior staircase—unique, private, and memorable, but not for everyone.
The heart of the home is the open living and dining space—perfect for meals, games, and movie nights. The kitchen is fully stocked for real cooking (a consistent 5-star highlight). Outside, the deck and creekside setting are why so many guests return: morning coffee by the water, wildlife wandering through, and a level of quiet you can truly feel.
Guest Access:
You'll have full access to the entire home and spacious backyard, giving you room to relax and explore. Enjoy morning coffee on the deck, let kids discover hidden corners, or gather under the stars by the fire pit.
Self check-in makes arrival easy, and once you're here, the space is entirely yours to enjoy.
The Neighborhood:
When we say "local," we mean it. Nestled in the heart of Story, Wyoming, this retreat is surrounded by mountain scenery, wildlife, and a pace that invites you to slow down.
Wake to birdsong, spot deer and wild turkeys, and occasionally glimpse moose or elk. Wildlife is part of the magic here—please admire from a distance and secure food properly.
Just minutes away you'll find hiking trails, Story's local charm, and the Wagon Box restaurant. In warmer months, drive Red Grade Road for breathtaking Bighorn Mountain views; in winter, it becomes a favorite for snowshoeing and backcountry exploration.
Downtown Sheridan is about 20 minutes away, offering boutiques, dining, museums, and culture—close enough for convenience, far enough to return to true quiet.
Getting Around:
Story is peaceful and rural—a car is recommended for exploring the area. Many attractions are within 10 minutes, while scenic routes and historic sites are 30–60 minutes away and well worth the drive.
Rental Car Option: A Tesla Model Y may be available upon request (subject to availability).
Bike & E-Bike Rentals: Great for quiet roads and nearby trails.
Transportation: Story does not have rideshare services; Sheridan does.
Every drive here is part of the experience—slow down and enjoy the scenery.
Other Things to Note:
Story is peaceful and rural—a car is recommended for exploring the area. Many attractions are within 10 minutes, while scenic routes and historic sites are 30–60 minutes away and well worth the drive.
Rental Car Option: A Tesla Model 3 may be available upon request (subject to availability).
Bike & E-Bike Rentals: Great for quiet roads and nearby trails.
Transportation: Story does not have rideshare services; Sheridan does.
Every drive here is part of the experience—slow down and enjoy the scenery.
Other Things to Note
Historic Home: This is an old home with real character—creaks, quirks, and natural imperfections are part of the charm.
Water: Well water is safe but mineral-forward; sensitive guests often bring bottled water.
Layout & Mobility: Bedrooms are spread out with stairs, including narrow/steeper areas. Not ideal for guests with mobility challenges—message us before booking if this applies.
Adult-Themed Art: Some art is mature. Please reach out before booking if this is a concern.
Finding the Driveway: The home is tucked back and can be tricky in the dark. Please review arrival instructions carefully.
Supplies: Essentials are provided to start your stay; longer visits may require replenishing.
Quiet Hours: No loud music; quiet hours begin at 10 PM.
Parking: Driveway parking available; trailers/RVs by request.
Heating: Propane heat and fireplaces keep the home cozy—please don't adjust thermostats.
Well & Septic: Flush toilet paper only.
Nature: Peaceful, wooded setting with wildlife—secure food and admire from afar.
This home is thoroughly cleaned and prepared before every stay. If you have questions before booking, we're always happy to help.
Who This Home Is Perfect For
This home is a great fit if you:
Love historic homes with real character, creaks, and stories
Appreciate eclectic design, global art, and a creative, lived-in feel
Want a peaceful creekside escape with wildlife, trees, and true quiet
Enjoy unique features like a giant copper soaking tub and a dramatic stone-walled king bedroom
Are comfortable with a non-traditional layout, including stairs and a bedroom accessed from outside
Want a place that feels personal, soulful, and one-of-a-kind, not mass-produced
Are looking to unplug, reset, and slow down in Story, Wyoming
As one guest put it: "Even if you're not a bath person, help yourself to the giant tub—10/10."
Who This Home May Not Be Ideal For
This home may not be the best fit if you:
Prefer brand-new, hotel-style spaces with uniform layouts
Are highly sensitive to older-home details like creaks, mineral-forward well water, or natural wear
Need step-free access or have mobility challenges with stairs
Are uncomfortable with adult-themed or eclectic artwork
Expect a cookie-cutter or ultra-modern aesthetic
Prefer a home where all bedrooms are on one level and inside-only
If you've read this far and are smiling—this place is probably for you. If you're unsure, message us before booking and we'll happily help you decide.
Interaction with Guests:
You'll have complete privacy during your stay, but we're always just a message away. Whether you need help with the home, local recommendations, or arranging extras, we're happy to assist.
Our goal is simple: make your time in Story effortless, peaceful, and memorable.
Amenities at My Story | Historic Creekside, Copper Tub, King
Non-smoking
Family friendly
Map of Wyoming
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
Host was great and house was amazing
10 / 10Outstanding·Dec 2025
This property is excellent. Very extremely well kept inside and comfortably decorated. My bed was very comfortable. Outside left a little to be desired. I had to sweep all the walk ways and deck. But that is part of living in a bunch of trees. The fireplace was very cozy and warm and the additional heat it every room was great. Could use a light on the stairs up the back to the upper bedroom. It was a terrific Christmas for me and my adult children. Thank you.DH
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
Beautiful, eclectic property. All the extras are great. A wonderful stay for a very reasonable price.
6 / 10Average·Jun 2025
The bathrooms were listed incorrectly the master bath is bath only not shower only.Would have liked to have better communication on the heating instructions had to figure it out in our own.Pretty property had everything you could think of except toilet paper both bathrooms had only a small amount of tissue left. Contacted “owner” ( do not think this was the owner believe it was a property manager) only response was should be some well wasn’t any so had to drive back into Sheridan to get some. The art work I main bathroom really not suitable for young children Nice place just a few things that really could be improved on
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(20 Ratings)
"Host was great and house was amazing "
Kevin K.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
