Cottage in Keuka Lake, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this cottage rental
Beautiful lakefront with plenty of outdoor living space and a well laid out traditional lake cottage is what Lightfoote Lagoon is all about!
Lakeside comfort and charm greets you inside the cottage. Enter the dining area and immediately feel at ease. Open dining room/living room and kitchen is brightened by the natural light through the windows that span the entire front of the cottage. The living room features a gas stove for heat and ambiance, comfortable furniture, a flat screen TV and views of the lake. Off the living room are two bedrooms, one with a queen bed. The other a twin bed. And off one of the downstairs bedrooms is the stackable washer/dryer combination. Off the far end of the dining room you will enter another bedroom with a queen bed and all the amenities. Up one step off that bedroom is the front sunroom.
A flight of stairs in that bedroom leads up another queen bed with a bathroom. The stairs to that room are steep and narrow be advised. Views of the lake can be seen from every window.
At the lake, your time is spent outdoors, so enjoy the pavilion for picnics and BBQ's; place the deck chairs around the fire pit and watch the stars come out at night; lounge in the sun on the natural beach; take the paddleboat out for a leisurely ride; fish off the dock;We also have two kayaks for you to use. enjoy your morning coffee on the deck; or go swimming in the lake! Located on the east bluff of Keuka Lake Lightfoote Lagoon offers peace and serenity, but is just minutes from Penn Yan and the Keuka Lake Wine Trail.
Note: Smoking is not allowed . The cottage is not handicap accessible.
No pets are allowed.Cottage is not guaranteed allergen-free. Also I need to mention there are stairs from the driveway to the cottage. About 30 half way down there is a landing. They are not steep.
Lakeside comfort and charm greets you inside the cottage. Enter the dining area and immediately feel at ease. Open dining room/living room and kitchen is brightened by the natural light through the windows that span the entire front of the cottage. The living room features a gas stove for heat and ambiance, comfortable furniture, a flat screen TV and views of the lake. Off the living room are two bedrooms, one with a queen bed. The other a twin bed. And off one of the downstairs bedrooms is the stackable washer/dryer combination. Off the far end of the dining room you will enter another bedroom with a queen bed and all the amenities. Up one step off that bedroom is the front sunroom.
A flight of stairs in that bedroom leads up another queen bed with a bathroom. The stairs to that room are steep and narrow be advised. Views of the lake can be seen from every window.
At the lake, your time is spent outdoors, so enjoy the pavilion for picnics and BBQ's; place the deck chairs around the fire pit and watch the stars come out at night; lounge in the sun on the natural beach; take the paddleboat out for a leisurely ride; fish off the dock;We also have two kayaks for you to use. enjoy your morning coffee on the deck; or go swimming in the lake! Located on the east bluff of Keuka Lake Lightfoote Lagoon offers peace and serenity, but is just minutes from Penn Yan and the Keuka Lake Wine Trail.
Note: Smoking is not allowed . The cottage is not handicap accessible.
No pets are allowed.Cottage is not guaranteed allergen-free. Also I need to mention there are stairs from the driveway to the cottage. About 30 half way down there is a landing. They are not steep.
Amenities at Beautiful sunrises with Crystal clear waters
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Oct 2025
The sunrise over the lake with the fall colors just staring to pop was exactly what we were looking for. Crisp mornings on the dock with a cup of coffee. The outdoor space couldn’t be better. The house has some quirky upstate New York charm that makes it feel more cozy than upscale. We did enjoy some giggles. Tina was quick to respond to any query we had, both before and during our stay.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Aug 2025
Pavilion was awesome to use, great location.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jul 2025
Amazing location and views. We spent most of our time outdoors and the pavilion made it so comfortable to be outside even during rain and heat.
6.0 / 10.0Average·Oct 2025
The best thing about our stay was the beautiful lake. We were not happy with the requirement to wash and dry all of linens before check out. Had I known I would have brought my own. Also very rustic with visitors from ants and mice. The floors are very uneven and made it somewhat uncomfortable since I have vertigo issues.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(86 Ratings)
"The sunrise over the lake with the fall colors just staring to pop was exactly what we were looking for. Crisp mornings on the dock with a cup of coffee. The outdoor space couldn’t be better. The hous..."
Sandy L.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
