Cottage in Keuka Lake, NY
4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this cottage rental
This cottage provides an ideal quiet location for couples or a family of two to four people.
It is located off of 54A in Branchport at 450 Crescent Beach Drive.
Guests can enjoy being on Keuka Lake with one of the most beautiful views in the Finger Lakes.
Keuka Lake State Park and its many trails is also accessible by walking south along Esperanza Drive about 1.5miles.
This cottage has 30 feet of frontage which is level from the parking area to the lake.
The Branchport end of Keuka Lake is known for excellent fishing and beautiful sunsets.
This cottage can also be rented for extended families or friends that may be renting next door at the Halls Cottage 448 Crescent Beach.
It is located off of 54A in Branchport at 450 Crescent Beach Drive.
Guests can enjoy being on Keuka Lake with one of the most beautiful views in the Finger Lakes.
Keuka Lake State Park and its many trails is also accessible by walking south along Esperanza Drive about 1.5miles.
This cottage has 30 feet of frontage which is level from the parking area to the lake.
The Branchport end of Keuka Lake is known for excellent fishing and beautiful sunsets.
This cottage can also be rented for extended families or friends that may be renting next door at the Halls Cottage 448 Crescent Beach.
Amenities at The Pickerel Inn at 450 Crescent Beach Branchport, NY
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsThe property received glowing positive feedback for its great location, beautiful views, excellent communication with hosts, and cozy accommodations. Visitors had enjoyable experiences and would love to return.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
Great accommodations and the owner was accessible and responsive.
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Sep 2025
Great location, like being close to the water
10.0 / 10.0Outstanding·Jul 2025
We had a wonderful time. The cabin is cozy & the views incredible. We would stay here again!
6.0 / 10.0Average·Aug 2022
The views and proximity to the water are the only things that made our stay good. The boathouse/bathhouse/garage turned into cottage has 1/3 of it with no more than a 5’9” head clearance, including the dining area, hallway and bathroom. Not mentioned anywhere, even in any of the posted glowing reviews! My 6’3” husband had to bend over or hit his head on beams the whole time! Makes me wonder if only hobbits rented it previously. The bathroom and shower vent into the rest of the cottage, and the “door” to the bathroom is only about 16” wide, and does not cover the whole entrance, doing nothing to keep bathroom smells in the bathroom. The living room, with the queen bed, has no way to darken the room, so when the sun comes up at 6 AM, you’d better be ready to get up. The neighbors’ house, which is literally 3’ away, was being remodeled, so we had circular saws and hammering the whole time. The other house on the property, which is much larger, had all the parking spaces across the road filled when we got there so we were glad we only brought one small car, which is all that will fit in the driveway-our truck would not have fit. The row boat was full of water (we bailed it out and turned it over), there was no chaise lounge to be found. The neighbors, who drastically outnumbered us, had the paddle boat. The stairs to the beach were rickety and unlit. Missing rocks on the wall, overgrown vegetation, missing lights all screaming for attention. This was honestly my most disappointing rental in over 20 years with VRBO!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(40 Ratings)
The property received glowing positive feedback for its great location, beautiful views, excellent communication with hosts, and cozy accommodations. Visitors had enjoyable experiences and would love to return.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
