Cottage in New York
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this cottage rental
The Pultneyville Harbor Office Cottage is the perfect size for a couple or a small family. SLEEPS 4 AT A GREAT PRICE. Stay with us for your visit or vacation.
***Book now***
Updated in 2014 & 2021 the cottage is located among 1800’s homes and just a half-mile from historic Pultneyville. This sweet little abode began life in the early 1900’s as the Pultneyville Harbor Office, before being moved to its present location in the 1950’s. In 2014 & 2020 we went through it stem to stern, and painted, mended, or replaced everything in her, while keeping the original heart and soul of the cottage.
The family room has a sofa (sleeper) and 2 chairs, plus a bar height table and 4 stools for dining or working. A Flat screen TV with Google Chromecast is provided and free Wi-Fi. (NOTE Strong reception for AT&T & Verizon Wireless cell service)
Mature shade trees and a wonderful lake breeze keep you cool in the summer. **NEW 2025 window AC Unit that works great even on the hottest of days** Fans are also provided. In the off-season a new in 2017 furnace keeps you warm & cozy.
The newly renovated kitchen features all new appliances, cabinets and finishes. If you want to cook, the kitchen is ready for you with complete cookware and dinnerware. A microwave, drip & Keurig coffeemakers, toaster, and a blender are included too. An outside WEBER gas grill is also provided.
There are 2 bedrooms, both with double beds (NEW 2024 memory foam). There is an IKEA sleeper sofa in the living room that sleeps 2 as well. Linens included! (additional fees apply for more than 4 people, and Note the cottage is very tight with more than 4 people).
The bathroom is very roomy, and includes a tub/shower unit. Towels provided.
***Please note there is NO SMOKING in The Cottage***
Step outside and enjoy seating on the covered front porch, with a beautiful view of the cherry orchard across the street (we are surrounded by orchards). In the back is a wood patio with a table and chairs, and a fire pit (wood is available for purchase in the area). A short 10 minute walk across the street brings you to a 100-foot high bluff with beautiful views of Lake Ontario, part of the new Cornwall Preserve with hiking trails and peace & quiet. NOTE the cottage is not on the lake, so there are no lake views from the cottage property.
And there is plenty to do nearby…the area is known for antique shops, dining, boating, and fishing.
Take a half-mile walk to town, and you’ll find the Pizza Stop & The Local (with Bar), churches, and beautiful Pultneyville Harbor.
12 minutes east by car is Sodus Point, a dining, boating and fishing mecca. There are 2 lighthouses, a museum (free summer Sunday concerts on the lawn 2PM), fishing pier, several marinas, boat rentals, charter fishing boats, 2 playgrounds, skate park, ball field, really nice public beach(with lifeguards), multiple restaurants (open late), a Jazz club, ice cream stands, gift shop, golf course, church, and convenience market.
3 miles east is Hughes Marina, with fishing, boat docks, boat launches and boat and kayak rentals. 4 miles west is the Bear Creek boat launch operated by the Town of Ontario (permit required), and this is a very popular fishing location.
Palmyra is 20 minutes south.
We live right next door and will be happy to be your host for your stay, and help you locate any of the local services. Hope you stay with us at The Pultneyville Harbor Office Cottage.
***Book now***
Updated in 2014 & 2021 the cottage is located among 1800’s homes and just a half-mile from historic Pultneyville. This sweet little abode began life in the early 1900’s as the Pultneyville Harbor Office, before being moved to its present location in the 1950’s. In 2014 & 2020 we went through it stem to stern, and painted, mended, or replaced everything in her, while keeping the original heart and soul of the cottage.
The family room has a sofa (sleeper) and 2 chairs, plus a bar height table and 4 stools for dining or working. A Flat screen TV with Google Chromecast is provided and free Wi-Fi. (NOTE Strong reception for AT&T & Verizon Wireless cell service)
Mature shade trees and a wonderful lake breeze keep you cool in the summer. **NEW 2025 window AC Unit that works great even on the hottest of days** Fans are also provided. In the off-season a new in 2017 furnace keeps you warm & cozy.
The newly renovated kitchen features all new appliances, cabinets and finishes. If you want to cook, the kitchen is ready for you with complete cookware and dinnerware. A microwave, drip & Keurig coffeemakers, toaster, and a blender are included too. An outside WEBER gas grill is also provided.
There are 2 bedrooms, both with double beds (NEW 2024 memory foam). There is an IKEA sleeper sofa in the living room that sleeps 2 as well. Linens included! (additional fees apply for more than 4 people, and Note the cottage is very tight with more than 4 people).
The bathroom is very roomy, and includes a tub/shower unit. Towels provided.
***Please note there is NO SMOKING in The Cottage***
Step outside and enjoy seating on the covered front porch, with a beautiful view of the cherry orchard across the street (we are surrounded by orchards). In the back is a wood patio with a table and chairs, and a fire pit (wood is available for purchase in the area). A short 10 minute walk across the street brings you to a 100-foot high bluff with beautiful views of Lake Ontario, part of the new Cornwall Preserve with hiking trails and peace & quiet. NOTE the cottage is not on the lake, so there are no lake views from the cottage property.
And there is plenty to do nearby…the area is known for antique shops, dining, boating, and fishing.
Take a half-mile walk to town, and you’ll find the Pizza Stop & The Local (with Bar), churches, and beautiful Pultneyville Harbor.
12 minutes east by car is Sodus Point, a dining, boating and fishing mecca. There are 2 lighthouses, a museum (free summer Sunday concerts on the lawn 2PM), fishing pier, several marinas, boat rentals, charter fishing boats, 2 playgrounds, skate park, ball field, really nice public beach(with lifeguards), multiple restaurants (open late), a Jazz club, ice cream stands, gift shop, golf course, church, and convenience market.
3 miles east is Hughes Marina, with fishing, boat docks, boat launches and boat and kayak rentals. 4 miles west is the Bear Creek boat launch operated by the Town of Ontario (permit required), and this is a very popular fishing location.
Palmyra is 20 minutes south.
We live right next door and will be happy to be your host for your stay, and help you locate any of the local services. Hope you stay with us at The Pultneyville Harbor Office Cottage.
Amenities at A quiet cottage in a historic town, near boating, fishing & dining - SLEEPS 4.
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
Clean and quaint. cozy and just perfect for weekend getaway.
8 / 10Excellent·Nov 2025
I arrived on a windy, rainy night. The cottage was warm and cozy! The interior has character, it's quaint and unusual.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
The cottage was just as described and served our purpose for a two night stay. Would stay again.
6 / 10Average·Jun 2025
Although cute, it should not be labeled for 6 people. The 2 bedrooms have no room for luggage, they had to be in the front room. The kitchen was a galley kitchen with apartment size refrigerator and stove. The table with 4 chairs was long and narrow facing the wall. There were only 5 forks but plenty of knives and spoons, pots and pans, etc. The out door space was pretty and quiet. It advertised a view of the lake but you could not see it because of the cherry orchard. To stay for 2 or 3 days it would be fine but not a week.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(108 Ratings)
"Clean and quaint. cozy and just perfect for weekend getaway."
candy m.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
